Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Photography question?

Posts

Photography question?

#1

Photography question?

Dennis Yoder

>I tried to photograph this NIP thin walled vase that I turned last week. Did not turn out well. Not only the poor pix but I took it outside to let the sun shine thru the side when the wind took it out of my hand and it cracked in 3 places when it hit the ground.

How do you illuminate the side walls and produce the "halo" around the entire vase with a black background. Thanks. Dennis Y


img

Re: Photography question?

#2

Re: Photography question?

John K Jordan

>Dennis,

Bummer - I hate it when mother nature wrecks my stuff!

I'm not sure of the exact effect you are looking for. Some of the "halos" I've seen around woodturnings are from a soft spot of light aimed at the background. There are other ways to make halos in general, including using a soft diffuse filter on the camera which will spread the light from a bright subject. However, this blurs the subject some. Another way is with a composite of two exposures. Another way is to do it afterwards in Photoshop where you can control any glow effect you can imagine.

I'm sure someone else will have a better response, but if not, maybe you can post or point to an example picture of what you're after.

JKJ

Re: Photography question?

#3

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>Dennis I may have a few minutes at work this morning to set up this scenario. I use a small spot light that shines in the bowl. If it fits the bowl perfectly you will have the bowl lit and usually the bottom 1/3 will be too bright. This has to do more with how the light bounces off the interior because of the shape.

I adjust my exposure for this bright light ignoring all the rest. You need manual exposure for this. Then I take a second light and add just enough light to light the outside. You have to leave the outside a little dark to make the inside look like it's still lit.

That's it in a nutshell. I don't have any thin bowls right now so I'll have to look at what I have around the house or shop. I'll shoot a photo or two to show you how it's done.

Re: Photography question?

#4

Re: Photography question?

Russ Fairfield

>I use a non-professional approach and illuminate the object with a light bulb inside of it. There are no fancy lighting fixtures, and there is no wash of outside light to worry about because all of the light is contained within the piece of wood. I use a plug-in night light on the end of an extension cord. A higher wattage bulb and a dimmer can be used to vary the intensity of the light and the color of the wood, but I prefer to do it with light bulbs of different wattage. The light in the photo is a clear night-light on the end of an extension cord, at full power without a dimmer, and a black paper background. There is no editing of the photo other than cropping and removing the cord with an editing brush.

A halo can be created with the intensity of the light, camera exposure, and bringing the black background closer to the object. Some experimenting is required. A halo can be made above the top with a mini-flood or spot light that is aimed upward. Some of the photo editors have a "halo" option that works pretty well. I prefer to not use the halo because it detracts from the detail of the object in the photo. Sometimes, the eye can be fooled into seeing a halo by softening the edges of the background.


img

Re: Photography question?

#5

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>Good job Russ. Excellent balance between the translucent side and the outside. That's where most people fail.

Re: Photography question?

#6

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>Here's the set up I came up with for home use. I put a spot light in the desk lamp. It's just a standard spot like you would use in your kitchen lights. I used a commercial snoot with Cinefoil on it to make a cone. You could just as easily make one out of black paper but be wary of fire. You may be able to make one out of aluminum foil or copper flashing. Then spray the inside flat black.

Move this light up and down until it produces the size circle you need. I'll go into the camera and settings in the following photos. This is a white translucent plastic bowl.


img

Re: Photography question?

#7

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>This is just a shot of the bowl up close. The circle of light is much smaller than the bowl because this bowl is so translucent. You may have to play with the size of the circle because the back of the bowl or the bottom may be to bright. By changing the size of the circle and move it either forward or backward you have more control over the total illumination of the piece.

This was shot at 10 seconds at f16 on the Tungsten setting of my camera.


img

Re: Photography question?

#8

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>This is a thin goblet that was pierced. The first thing to do is to move the light up and down to fill the goblet. l

Then set your camera to the tungsten white balance setting and begin testing the exposure. It will be quite long so use a tripod and cable release if you have one. If your camera doesn't have a cable release use the self timer.

I use at least f8 for all art work and f 16 or 22 if it's 3 dimensional work. For this goblet 10 seconds gave me an exposure that showed illumination through the wood. I don't change this exposure for any of the rest of the photos.

You'll notice the top is too hot. This is a problem with this kind of work because you can't always shine a light through the piece. Sometimes you have to light the back wall of the piece to make things like piercings show. This can be controlled with very careful placement of the light and some other tricks I've learned but the best way is to simply lower the camera to limit how much of the inside you see.

I'm using he same set up as the first photo but the light was a little lower making a smaller circle.


img

Re: Photography question?

#9

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>For this shot I took another light that is pretty dim and move it almost 6 feet from the goblet. I shaded part of the light to make it even dimmer. You want just enough light to show off what's on the outside of the vessel if that's necessary. You still want to see the tranlucency of the wood. You can mask off the light with layers of paper of if it's a light that's in a reflector simply aim it somewhere else to lessen the amount of light hitting the goblet.

In Russ's photo above he added light to one side and let the illumination from the inside light the other. This is a very good idea. In the case of this goblet the outside is actually more important than the inside so I would only illuminate the inside to show off the piecrcing and possible how thin it is.


img

Re: Photography question?

#10

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>One last photo. I decided to add a small white card on the right side to bounce just a little more light into that side. I probably would not do that for a Norfolk Pine vessel because the overall tranlucency is more important than the outside.


img

Re: Photography question?

#11

Re: Photography question?

john lucas

>One last photo. I decided to add a small white card on the right side to bounce just a little more light into that side. I probably would not do that for a Norfolk Pine vessel because the overall tranlucency is more important than the outside.


img

Re: Photography question?

#12

Re: Photography question?

Bob Macgregor

>Is a pierced goblet a remedy for dypsomania?

BOB

Re: Photography question?

#13

Phun with Photography, but...( is this a rant? )

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>This same question comes up for me often. I can see that photography is fun, and PhotoShopping pics too, but I wonder why, other than enjoying that activity, we would WANT to make our turnings appear as they are not. Translucent wood turnings, as well as halos, color modifications, and such can be quite striking, but never again after the "shoot" will anyone ever see that piece look the same.

If we spent the time and effort to create an unreal effect and left it at that, well, we had our fun. But once that product is published on the web or otherwise, have we not stepped up to, or even over, the integrity threshold? If we hold such work, manipulated with camera and/or computer, up for sale, should we somehow advise our buying public that what they get will not look like the picture?

My questions about this are certainly not aimed at any particular turners, but is a question in general. Am I being anal this morning? Do any others out there ever wonder the same?

Re: Photography question?

#14

Re: Photography question?

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Dennis, halo effects or rim lighting is usually called back-lighting and creates a beautiful look that is very popular with professional photographers and cinematographers. Basically back-lighting is either natural or artificial light coming from behind the subject/product and directed towards the product instead of the background. For best affect, back-lighting needs to be equal or greater in intensity as the frontal lighting on the subject/product. This is where some type of hand held light-meter is usually required. The back-light also needs to be well controlled so that it doesn't flare into the camera lens. Camera lens hoods also help control flare. For artificial lighting, small spotlights, monolights, background specific lights with narrow angle reflectors work well for back lighting, although most any lighting source can be used if well controlled.

Re: Photography question?

#15

Re: Phun with Photography, but...( is this a rant?

john lucas

>Mike I sort of agree. However we buy a clothes and everything else based on how it looks on some perfect model that none of us resemble. The same is true with turnings. Marketing is what it's all about if you want to sell.

When you see a thin wall turning in a gallery it is often displayed with a light similar to what I did. This is done to attract the buyer and make the piece sell. It seems to work for Ron Kent. He's sold more of these pieces than anyone.

Re: Photography question?

#16

Re: Phun with Photography, but...( is this a rant?

Don at Central Illinois

>I think we want to present our turnings as the best they can be. Why do we spend so much time on the finish? To make it look the as good as possible. I don't think that people who see a stunning photo of a turning, expect it to look exactly like the photo. They realize that when they put it in their house, it won't have the halo, back lighting, etc. unless they provide it. I don't think you are being anal, but I do think that if we manipulate the photo so as to hide any defects, etc. then you would have a realistic complaint.

Re: Photography question?

#17

Re: Photography question?

Russ Fairfield

>This is the same piece as seen in the light, without any of the internal illumination. Why did I take the previous photo? I did it for the same reason as anyone else who has done the same thing - it looks kinda neat. It also shows off our ability to turn something with a uniform and thin wall thickness. Thick clunky work will not have the transparency to be photographed this way.

I take exception to the suggestion there is something wrong with using accent lighting effects and backgrounds to display an art object. Museums do it, gallerys do it, and individuals do it in their homes to show off all forms of 2D and 3D art. If we sell our work at art fairs, we should be showing our work in its best light in our display, because we will sell more of our work for doing it.

About the internal illumination, there is no reason it cannot be a permant feature of the piece. Just drill a hole through the bottom and wire the light into the piece so it can be seen that way anytime in any dark room.


img

Re: Photography question?

#18

Re: Photography question?

Dennis Yoder

>Thanks for everyone's responses. The methodolgy is much clearer now. Dennis Y

Re: Photography question?

#19

Re: Photography question?

DickL in Tampa

>Very well done. Thanks for the free photography lesson. One more thing to add to my bag of tricks.

Regards,

Dick

Re: Photography question?

#20

Re:Think about " Truth in Advertising!"

Jamie D

>