Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

OT for metal working

Posts

OT for metal working

#1

OT for metal working

mfoster

>Well I got the reamer for the MT on my tailstock spindle. It is a finish reamer and I believe it is meant to be used by hand, but I have never really done any metalworking and could be all wet. I started by just using the weight of the reamer and turning it. I am using WD 40 as I don't have any metalworking oil. Didn't really seem to do much, so I started adding progressively more down pressure while turning the reamer with a crescent wrench. I found a little black sludge on the reamer, but no filings to speak of. Didn't really seem to be cutting at all. So I tried a few gentle taps with a hammer followed by turning it. Seemed to grab a little tighter (hard to turn), but still no real shavings. After this I tried it out with the new Oneway center in and gave a spindle some abuse with a parting tool. Still has much more vibration than at the headstock, and when using the parting tool with one hand and feeling the tailstock with the other, the center is the only thing that vibrates.

So I think that the reamer is not really doing it's thing. I'm thinking: chuck the thing in a drill, or chuck it in my Axminster chuck with the metalworking type step jaws and lightly feed the tailstock into it. Bad idea? I don't really want to screw up the quill because I'm not sure I could get a replacement for it.

I'd welcome any and all suggestions.

Thanks

Mike

Re: OT for metal working

#2

JL

Re: OT for metal working

JL

>I'm not a metal worker or machinist. In the rare instances where I've had to clean out a Morris taper, I've done it by hand. Of course I've used the small composite MT cleaners, not a reamer.

When I've had to ream holes in metal, I've usually done it by hand (tapered machinist reamer). How about you chuck it in your chuck and spin your chuck by hand? You could slowly advance the tailstock quill when needed.

Just a thought.

Re: OT for metal working

#3

Re: OT for metal working

john lucas

>I would not do it under power. You will probably screw it up worse. I would look into the cost of replacing the tailstock spindle. If it's not too expensive then go ahead and ream the tailstock you have. Then if you mess it up you know where and how much a new one costs. I replaced one on my old Delta and it was surprisingly inexpensive. I'm sure prices have changed and your might be a lot more expensive.

I'm not sure but I think the morse taper is hardened, at least to some extent. That's probably why you will only get small shavings and not cuts. I've never tried to ream a morse taper. I have reamed softer metals and they cut with hand pressure.

Re: OT for metal working

#4

Re: OT for metal working

GalenV

>I agree with John that you are using a high speed steel taper reamer on a spindle that at least has been surface hardened. Driving one into the other with a hammer is only going to make circular scratches at best and sure no shavings. Maybe chips that you do not want. A tapered hone may have polished the surface but not much more.

If you tried to turn the reamer under power you would need a slow 25 to 30 rpm and flood with a light oil. Remove the spindle surface hardness and you will end up replaceing in a short time.

Is the tail stock casting not bored round so you are not locking the spindle down tightly in an obround bore?

Do you get the same amount of vibration or play with the tail stock just set out to allow the live center to seat as you get with the tail stock fully entended out? I would assume you get less if not extended if bore is just out of round.

Just thoughts it miight be the spindle casting bore and not the morse tapper.

Galen

Re: OT for metal working

#5

Re: OT for metal working

mfoster

>Thanks Galen and John. I was thinking maybe the tailstock is hardened. I found a thread on Rec.woodturning that discussed this same issue and they mentioned that they are often hardened. I guess I'll have to see if a quill is available for my Woodfast. I wish I knew for sure that the problem was with the MT.

Galen, the quill does have some play in the tailstock housing before locking it down, but I figured that wouldn't make a lot of difference once its locked down. I can feel the center vibrate, but not the quill when testing it. I still have to believe that the machining from Oneway must be the better of the two pieces, but it may be possible that I have 2 Oneway centers that aren't machined well. Is there some way to check the centers for correct taper?

Re: OT for metal working

#6

Re: OT for metal working

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The quill will have play before it's locked down so your ok. Tighten the tail stock and quill then install the live center, now grab onto the live center then push and pull on it... what moves. If the MT doesn't fit correctly you'll see a noticeable movement in that joint. If that is fine check the live center they have a recessed nut to load the bearings sometimes this will loosen a bit and cause the center to vibrate. A small punch is enough to check (tighten) this nut.

Re: OT for metal working

#7

Re: OT for metal working

paul waddle

>If you put in a dead center,do you still get this vibration? Don't believe a slight out of alignment will cause vibration,I believe problem lies in the live center bearing or the morse fit you are investigating. I would put some prussian blue( nasty stuff) on the tail stock taper,insert the live center and chk for complete fit..pw

Re: OT for metal working

#8

Re: OT for metal working

Barry Irby

>I think the quill is hardened and you stand almost no chance of "fixing" whatever the problem is with a reamer. Even if the reamer would cut the inner surface of the taper, what are the chance you could make it cut in exactly the right fashion to correct the defect, if any?

It seems to me that if there is a vibration it is most likely int he live center. The quill and tailstock have not moving parts after it is locked down and there is little to vibrate. Have you tried the live center in a different lathe? It may only vibrate under load. I have seen several bearings that would spin smoothly by hand under no load and growled badly when loaded.

Does every live center and even ever dead center vibrate in the lathe?

Re: OT for metal working

#9

Re: OT for metal working

mfoster

>Barry,

It seems that all of my centers vibrate under load. This includes a new and an old Oneway center. Don't have a dead center and never really thought I needed one. I plan on testing all the centers on my Jet mini when I get home. Hopefully this will narrow down the problem.

Re: OT for metal working

#10

Re: OT for metal working

mfoster

>Thanks Paul

May have to resort to this if all else fails. Don't have any prussian blue but I understand the concept and may have to see if anyone around has some. I'm going to test out the centers on my Jet mini tonight.

Re: OT for metal working

#11

Re: OT for metal working

john lucas

>It could be the outside of the quill feed. When you lock the quill feed it is only being pressed against at one point. Ideally the casting would be ground accurately and this one point would push the quill against the other side and lock it securely. If for some reason the casting wasn't ground perfectly true or there's grit imbedded in the casting the quill could rock on this point and produce vibration.

I'm guessing of course because I can't play with the part myself. Hope this helps.

Re: OT for metal working

#12

Steven Antonucci

Are you sure it's not an alignment problem?

Steve Antonucci

>I can't see any way that the vibration would be caused by a faulty seating of the center. If you spin it by hand, does it appear to wobble?

I'd bet that your issue is one of axial alignment. Your points line up (i.e. point to each other), but not along the same axis. If you had a double ended taper, you could check it.

Steve

Re: OT for metal working

#13

Re: OT for metal working

mfoster

>I called Craft Supplies today to talk with their staff about the problem. Roger seemed to think that the play between the quill and the tailstock housing could be the culprit. It could be, but it just doesn't seem like it to me since I can feel the center vibrate and not the quill. Roger gave in and said he would go look to see if he has a quill just to shut me up. He found one it is on the way here. I might be wrong, but I figure for 85$, it's worth a try. I'll let you know the outcome.

Re: OT for metal working

#14

Re: Are you sure it's not an alignment problem?

Stephen Mushinski

>I am with you on this one Steve! First thing I was thinking when I read the wobble at the tail stock end.

Re: OT for metal working

#15

Re: Mike missed your question

GalenV

>Mike

Sorry I missed your question but others have given a lot of ideas.

A #2 Morse taper will have 1 mm change in diameter for 20.02 mm in length. 1 degree 25 minutes 50 seconds of taper angle.

You should be able to lay a straight edge along the taper and there should be no crown. If there is I could see how you would get wobble as it would not seat. You say it does seat tight so probably not it.

I know my Jet lives centers are cheap single row bearings and when I got vibration shortly after I started using the first. They sent me a new live center. I also pressed out the old and put in a new bearing. It has lasted for a while but I can already feel some movement. My double row bearing 60 degree cone live center is just a better quality and I would not expect it to cause vibration trouble.

I could see how alignment could cause vibration if piece was chucked (fixed)one end but if spur center to live center you would just turn on an offset axis and not vibrate.

Like others say if you do not see it or feel it yourself had to Guess.

Galen