Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

catchless skew

Posts

catchless skew

#1

catchless skew

John K Jordan

>Last month I mentioned I had come up with a simple modification to a skew that was impossible to catch when turning beads or cutting deep v-groves. As I wrote then, I couldn't make it catch if I TRIED! I finally had time to take a photo.

Note that this is not necessarily a USEFUL modification, perhaps good for a parlor trick or for impressing other woodturners!

I've read and watched several experts who recommend the skew for beads. Why? Presumably it's because the flat bevel helps support and guide the cut, whether the long or short point is down either long or short point down. Darlow uses short point down; I watched Frank Penta use the long. Both of these guys can evidently make perfect cuts every time without a catch. Some of the rest of us have occasional or recurrent problems! The skew has to be held at the perfect position and angle, but everything changes as the cut progresses. The motion needed is a perfectly coordinated swing, twist, rotate (by raising the handle), and thrust.

I sat down with a skew and thought about this. What part of the edge does the cutting? Just the tip. What makes it catch? When the edge behind the cut contacts the work for even an instant. What if that edge couldn't cut?

I took a small flat diamond needle file and rounded over the edge of a 1/2" skew everywhere except for a couple of milllimeters at each point. Photo below, taken after some use and honing. I marked the modified portion with blue to make it easier to see in the photo. I put a big red X on the side so I wouldn't grab that one by mistake.

I turned a dozen or so beads with this and could not make it catch. If I twisted or tilted incorrectly the rounded edge contacted the bead and instead of a catch the point either simply quit cutting or cut poorly. I made some reasonably good beads. I didn't use it enough for a thorough test.

Since a bead is normally cut only with the first few millimeters of the edge, this mod didn't change the way it worked.

The upside is this modification retains the good aspects of making beads with a skew. It can give an off-the-tool surface smoother than using a detail gouge, smoother than a 3-sided point tool, and FAR smoother than using a beading (scraping) tool. The down side is it makes the skew useless for anything else such as planing cylinders and making tapers and peeling cuts. (Still good for opening paint cans, though.)

It also works fine when making deep, narrow V cuts with sharp bottoms with the long point, something not possible with another tool. Here again, all the cutting is done with the first tiny bit of edge so the rounded-off portion doesn't change anything. However, Vs are so much easier than beads that I don't get catches when making such cuts unless I fall asleep at the lathe. Same as with beads, though, let the edge contact the work behind the point and you make an instant spiral.

This is just a novelty and probably not new, but perhaps interesting to some.

JKJ


img

Re: catchless skew

#2

Re: catchless skew

Fog Tanner

>Thanks ofr posting the pic John. I just received a new 1/2" skew that I got on sale. I was putting it away for when the other three 1/2" skews wore out, but now I will have to give this a go on it. I normally use a radiused edge and the one I received has a straight like the one in your pick. And I do have a small diamond hone/file.

Looks like you came up with an 1/8" skew with a 1/2" bevel for support. Thanks again for sharing and the narrative on what you did.

Fog

Re: catchless skew

#3

Re: catchless skew

Michael Stafford

>Not only can I make it catch, I am willing to bet a RC Cola that I can tear the wood right out of the lathe with your catchless skew....

Skews are effect negative rake scrapers....that's about it....

Actually, I have been working on my skew use since Ed's class. I am getting better, not great but better....

Re: catchless skew

#4

Re: catchless skew

john lucas

>John I'm a little confused. The reason a skew catches is when you come off the bevel. Not when you touch a different part of the bevel. when you come off the bevel you have no support so the area doing the cutting runs backwards.

Wish I could come over and try your tool. I was doing a demo the other day and was going to show them how to make the tool catch and couldn't do it. I kept getting clean cuts. You might have a good idea on that skew but for different reasons.

Re: catchless skew

#5

John, I can give lessons if you need it...

Michael Stafford

>

Re: catchless skew

#6

I need lots of help-Oh you meant woodturning

john lucas

>

Re: catchless skew

#7

Re: OXYMORON!!! (;-D)

Jamie D

>

Re: catchless skew

#8

Re: catchless skew

John K Jordan

>>Not when you touch a different part of the bevel.

The way I figured it was when you touched it with a different part of the edge, not the bevel, at least that's what it looked like to me. I turned the lathe by hand and watched what happened when I tilted the skew a bit too much in the wrong direction.

This subject could certainly use some more thinking.

Funny you mention the difficulty of getting a catch. I was trying to show someone the same thing about a catch when planing a cylinder. I could not get it to catch! I'm sure I had lots of catches when I was learning. The guy tried it and got a catch. Certain ways of doing things must become very ingrained. I was helping another guy and he got the worst vibration and uneven cut on one piece. I tried and could not duplicate the problem - it was smooth and clean. He took the same tool on the same piece and it was uneven again. Go figure.

Some of that might come into play when different people evaluate the same new grinds and new tools such as the Hunter.

JKJ

Re: catchless skew

#9

Jamie speaks the truth!!!!

Michael Stafford

>

Re: catchless skew

#10

Re: Catchless? Wanna Bet??

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: catchless skew

#11

Eli Alvesera grind

robo hippy

>Got to see Eli this summer, and he grinds his convex rather than concave. You can cut with the whole blade, and I do use it all, and with the rounded bevel rather than concave, it is almost impossible to come off the bevel.

robo hippy

Re: catchless skew

#12

Re: catchless skew - It Ain't The Tool

charlie belden

>As is often the case, it's not the tool that's the problem - but rather the loose nut attached to its handle (raising his hand and shyfully saying - "That would be ME.").

Attached are just two examples this Loose Nut has done - on a few occassions (oh sure).


img

Re: catchless skew

#13

Re: catchless skew - It Ain't The Tool

GalenV

>And to think, I can make either catch happen in less than a blink of my eye! :>(

Normally I thought doing something fast was good, but not always in turning.

Re: catchless skew

#14

Re: catchless skew

Bob Macgregor

>When I watched this video on making nesting dolls, I thought it looked like the skew he used was sharpened only at the ends. Does it look that way to you, too?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhR9ALVd0Js

Nice hook tool demo, too!

BOB

Re: catchless skew

#15

Re: catchless skew

john lucas

>No to me it looks like he uses all parts of the skew. At one point he is doing a planing cut with the middle. Then he uses the heel to round over the piece and the toe to clean up the ends and cut the V's. Really cool video.

Re: catchless skew

#16

Re: catchless skew

John K Jordan

>Was that a skew made from about a 3/4" round rod?

It would take me an hour to do what that guy did in a few minutes.

JKJ

Re: catchless skew

#17

Re: catchless skew

john lucas

>I agree John. The amazing thing is how precise those things are. My sister went to Russia about 5 years ago and brought back a bunch of those dolls. They stack with no more than 1/8" clearance.

That skew looked like 5/8 to 3/4 rod to me. I may have to make one.

Re: catchless skew

#18

Re: catchless skew

John K Jordan

>A missionary brought me a set from Russia about 25 years ago. I was impressed then, and more impressed now.

If you make a big round skew be sure to report on it! When I saw that I thought why don't we see those for sale? Plenty of people use small round skews which are perfect for rolling beads. I couldn't tell for sure from the video but it almost looked like it was flared out a bit on the end. ???

JKJ

Re: catchless skew

#19

Re: catchless skew

john in kansas

>He sure makes it look easy with that skew. Would anyone know what he would be driving the wood onto in the headstock? Seems like the bearings would not last very long with that type of a beating!

thnx,

john