catchless skew
John K Jordan
>Last month I mentioned I had come up with a simple modification to a skew that was impossible to catch when turning beads or cutting deep v-groves. As I wrote then, I couldn't make it catch if I TRIED! I finally had time to take a photo.
Note that this is not necessarily a USEFUL modification, perhaps good for a parlor trick or for impressing other woodturners!
I've read and watched several experts who recommend the skew for beads. Why? Presumably it's because the flat bevel helps support and guide the cut, whether the long or short point is down either long or short point down. Darlow uses short point down; I watched Frank Penta use the long. Both of these guys can evidently make perfect cuts every time without a catch. Some of the rest of us have occasional or recurrent problems! The skew has to be held at the perfect position and angle, but everything changes as the cut progresses. The motion needed is a perfectly coordinated swing, twist, rotate (by raising the handle), and thrust.
I sat down with a skew and thought about this. What part of the edge does the cutting? Just the tip. What makes it catch? When the edge behind the cut contacts the work for even an instant. What if that edge couldn't cut?
I took a small flat diamond needle file and rounded over the edge of a 1/2" skew everywhere except for a couple of milllimeters at each point. Photo below, taken after some use and honing. I marked the modified portion with blue to make it easier to see in the photo. I put a big red X on the side so I wouldn't grab that one by mistake.
I turned a dozen or so beads with this and could not make it catch. If I twisted or tilted incorrectly the rounded edge contacted the bead and instead of a catch the point either simply quit cutting or cut poorly. I made some reasonably good beads. I didn't use it enough for a thorough test.
Since a bead is normally cut only with the first few millimeters of the edge, this mod didn't change the way it worked.
The upside is this modification retains the good aspects of making beads with a skew. It can give an off-the-tool surface smoother than using a detail gouge, smoother than a 3-sided point tool, and FAR smoother than using a beading (scraping) tool. The down side is it makes the skew useless for anything else such as planing cylinders and making tapers and peeling cuts. (Still good for opening paint cans, though.)
It also works fine when making deep, narrow V cuts with sharp bottoms with the long point, something not possible with another tool. Here again, all the cutting is done with the first tiny bit of edge so the rounded-off portion doesn't change anything. However, Vs are so much easier than beads that I don't get catches when making such cuts unless I fall asleep at the lathe. Same as with beads, though, let the edge contact the work behind the point and you make an instant spiral.
This is just a novelty and probably not new, but perhaps interesting to some.
JKJ




