Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

Posts

Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#1

Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

GalenV

>Ok so I started to turn my third ever small box yesterday afternoon. Left it on the lathe to go to our turners� dinner. I had yet to finish the outside top and bottom. The lid was a loose fit so I had put a piece of tissue between it and the bottom to keep it from slipping while I turned the top. Taped the joint as well as it was still loose.

Well today I turned the outside top and ready to take off the top and finish the bottom.

You guessed it, the top is now solid to the bottom!

Very well could be in wiping down between sanding of the top I got the tissue wet or it just warped on last night.

So do I have a solid hollow form or is there any way to remove the top??????

Put it in the microwave and hope it blows its top before it splits???

Put it in the freezer????

Set it on a shelf as a lesson learned????

I�m sure this has never happened to anyone but me???

Galen

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#2

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

John K Jordan

>Superglue or hotmelt glue something to grip onto the sides?

Grip the top with rubber clamp?

Drill some holes in it and call it art?

Slice it in two with the bandsaw and add a hinge? (Hey, I want to try that one myself.)

I have an untested theory of a way to pop a tight top off a box: put the box into a closed chamber and open a valve to pull a vacuum on it. I think the rapid decease in outside pressure would pop off the top (if it didn't split the box). I haven't tested this because I find myself currently short a vacuum chamber.

JKJ

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#3

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

Fog Tanner

>Take it in your house and let it warm up. I made my daughter a small box with a suction fit lid. I was doing some work in her room one day and picked up the box to see if it still had a decent fit and could not get the lid off. She keeps it cold in her room and I had put the lid on in a warmer part of the house. When it cooled it wasn't coming off. I took it to another part of the house and let it warm up and it came off as it should. Normally you want to jam fit the lid and finish turn it and not let it sit overnight.

If the lid is too loose when you are trying to jam fit it on the base, you can use bee's wax. With the base spinning you hold the bee's wax to the tenon and melt a layer on the tenon. Quickly stop the lathe and place the lid on the tenon and hold it there until the wax cools. This will hold the lid while you finish turn it, but will allow you to remove it later. I got this from one of Chris Stott's videos where he missed the fit. I had the same situation and it works. You can twist the lid and it comes off, and you just polish the tenon with the lathe running to get rid of the excess wax.

I have also used super glue/hot stuff as a finish on the tenon to build it up and then retrued it to get a good fit when it was a thousandths or so loose.

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#4

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

Michael Stafford

>Galen, one of my most unorthodox turning tools is just for this situation. I have several old Rapala fillet knives. I carefully insert the edge of the blade in the join line and take hold of both the handle and the remainder of the blade and gently pry the join open. I move the blade to another part of the join and repeat until I can get the heel of the blade in the join. Once the heel is in it is much easier to pry off the lid. Do it a little bit at a time and you should have success.

By the way I bet you got the end grain hot while you were turning or sanding and that resulted in a loose fit and thus you needed the tissue paper. It happens quite frequently. Once you get the lid off recut the body flange removing a little dust until the lid fits as you like. Avoid sanding the flange as sanding can result in the flange being out of round which will give you a twist fit. Not the ideal box lid fit....

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#5

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>as a last resort, I put a box in the freezer when that happened to me. I don't remember how long. When I took it out I was able to get the top off.

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#6

Compressed air!

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>I would try compressed air right at the joint, and all the way around. If that didn't pop it loose, a tiny little hole drilled into the top (or bottom) and then the air nozzle held up to that hole should blow it loose. The hole can then be filled.

PS. Point it away from you!

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#7

Re: Turned box is saved!- Thanks

GalenV

>Thanks all, the box is saved!

John Jordan

The vacuum idea would be fun to have had my son try at ISU Materials Engineering. They surely have better than a bell jar and vacuum pump like in my school years.

Your comment on drilling made me think why not make a top hole, push apart with dowel rod and put a small finial to cover the hole.

Fox Tanner

Yah, like tell me now to normally finish all in the same day!

Lesson learned.

Your use of bees wax to hold sounds like a future plan if I screw up on loose fit again.

Barbara Gill

I did put it in the freezer as I had to leave for the afternoon. Took it out and it still seemed stuck, but as it warmed up in my hands it popped like a cork, SAVED!

Mike Jones

Had the freezer not worked I would have tried the hole and compressed air, probably better than the wood dowel rod hammered through to pop loose.

Don�t think I will forget this for a while.

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#8

Michal did not mean to leave you out

GalenV

>The idea sounded a little fishy, using a Rapala fillet knife. :-)

Besides I would probably cut off my fingers.

Me sand till I got the part too hot? COULD BE!

Sanding is still not one of my better points.

This old dog will try to keep learning.

Re: Turned box now a solid form -HELP!

#9

Glad It Worked For You Too!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>