Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

Posts

OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#1

OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

ILYA ZAVORIN

>The only reason I am posting this question here is that it has to do with woodworking.

My wife and I want to remodel our kitchen including replacing the cabinets that are about 500 years old and look horrible. The question is whether there is a credible and hopefully unbiased source on how to choose cabinets.

One specific question I am trying to answer is what cabinet frames should be made of. I've heard several conflicting opinions, including:

- They should be made of plywood. Anything like particle board or any other type of engineered wood is bad since it's not as solid as plywood and so will not hold as well in the long term.

- They should be made of solid wood.

- They should be made of MDF. Engineered wood is so much better nowadays than that used in the cheap particle board furniture that I bought at Walmart when I was in college, especially when it comes to cabinetry.

- Buy them from IKEA. Cheap and good quality.

- Do not buy them from IKEA. Cheap and crappy.

In many cases I had an impression that the person giving me advice (i) had very limited knowledge, e.g. of just one type of material; (ii) was trying to sell me something; (iii) both. So can I find a knowledgeable and at the same time unbiased source of info?

I realize that price is a very important factor. We have a small 10X10 kitchen and got one rough estimate from a custom shop for about $10000 for the cabinets. IKEA would cost us I think about $2500. So we want to be somewhere in the middle. At the same time, we want these cabinets to look good and function properly for the next 10 years or even longer, so if this means paying more, we are willing to do that.

Thanks in advance for any help!

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#2

Dick Hines

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabi

Dick Hines

>We bought cabnits a few years ago from Lowe's. They are the special order ones not the ones they stock all the time. They came and measured for foot print and ordered them. It took a couple of weeks to get them.

A guy who installs for Lowe's and his son came out and did the whole job in one day. Took out the old ones and installed the new ones.

They are hickory and look great. My wife loves them. That's all that counts. If the wife is happy, I am happy.

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#3

JL

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabi *LINK*

JL

>I personally prefer a plywood carcass with a solid wood face frame construction. We replaced our cabinets in our home down in Marietta ~10 or so years ago. We had Jim Bishop Cabinets. Really nice cabinets.

They have a dealer locator - give it a shot. For our kitchen (~20 lineal feet of counter and with corresponding upper cabinets and a separate wall to ceiling pantry and some quality counters) it ran $7-8K.


Jim Bishop Cabinets

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#4

Talk to a real lumber yard.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Real lumber yards - the lumber places that contractors use - usually have a wide selection of cabinet options, from economy to luxury. The bigger lumber yards usually have someone that can (and will) honestly answer your questions and help you select the cabinets that will best fill your needs. They usually don't handle installation, but they know the contractors that can and will do a superior job at a fair price.

Unless you want cheap, I'd avoid the mass market retailers and home centers.

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#5

Steven Antonucci

Depends on your tastes

Steve Antonucci

>I think Ikea gets a bad reputation for "cheap" because they are inexpensive, but not poorly made. If you need to brag about your custom kitchen, Ikea won't be the place for you. However, Ikea's furniture lasted me for 10 years and through 3 moves without any mechanical issues or delamination. They know what they are doing when it comes to engineered materials.

I can't imagine using real wood in a small kitchen. You'd always be close to a boiling pot of water and the wood would likely expand and contract over time. No personal experience with all wood cabinets, but lots of experience with joints opening up...

Steve

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#6

Ellis Walentine

Unbiased source of cabinet info...

Ellis Walentine

>... is right here. Welcome.

I suspect that what you mean by "frames" is the cabinet bodies or carcases themselves. These are the heart of kitchen cabinetry. They can be made of any man-made board, including plywood, MDF, flakeboard and MCP (melamine-coated particleboard). The only reason to prefer plywood for the cabinet bodies is that it holds up better in very wet situations. If you don't anticipate any plumbing nightmares, any of the other options will do. Plywood has pros and cons like the other options. On the plus side, it is warm and natural looking. On the minus side, you need to finish it, usually with lacquer. MDF alone is not a great choice unless you intend to paint or lacquer it. MCP is good if you want really dirt-resistant surfaces.

Once the cabinets are installed, I know of no engineering reasons to prefer one type of cabinet board to another. They are under very little stress and will not be subject to unanticipated failures.

IKEA is another story. You will find plenty of cost-effective solutions there, and if you like the look, they can save you some dough.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#7

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabi

John K Jordan

>Ilya,

You might look around for some other cabinet shops as well, perhaps out in the country away from the big cities. I found a guy along the side of the road that makes custom cabinets - in fact he lives just over the hill from me and has been making cabinets for over 50 years. His price was way less than HALF of the cheapest I could find elsewhere. Before hiring him, I asked for references and visited people in the area he had built for.

He built the kitchen to my drawings - hardwood plywood for the carcases, solid hickory for everything that showed (the front frames, doors and drawer fronts), the rest various hardwoods. I personally would not want MDF - you should see what happens if it gets wet.

Also, if you know any architects they may point you towards someone they've learned to trust.

JKJ

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#8

Re: Unbiased source of cabinet info...

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Ellis, thanks, this is exactly the type of info I was looking for!

Now, a couple of follow-up questions. First, how big should the "plumbing nightmares" be to affect selection of materials? For instance, a couple of years ago our there was a small leak under the kitchen sink and we did not notice the dripping water for awhile because it was partly soaking into the old cabinets and partly into various stuff we stored in the cabinet. I suspect something like this had also happened to the previous owners, so now this particular cabinet is all black, warped and probably rotten inside. When we install everything new, we should not expect any incidents for awhile. On the other hand, we've heard horror stories from our friends about improperly connected dishwasher hoses causing flooding in a just completed kitchen etc. If something like this does happen, I would not want to ruin my cabinets, in addition to all the other damage. So does this mean I should just choose plywood?

Second, suppose I have the same exact cabinets made from different materials: plywood, MDF etc. Is there a rule of thumb about which materials will be more and less expensive?

Third, do you happen to know what materials IKEA uses for their bodies?

Thanks

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#9

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabi

Jim Canning

>I sold cabinets for 30 years and if I needed a well made cabinet at a reasonably price I would look at the Dynasty brand by Omega Cabinets. All Plywood box, solid fronts, self closing glides and hinges, many styles and stains and they can make a custom cabinet if needed! All of this is available with in 6-8 weeks.

I would go to the Omega web site and find some dealers close to you, contact at least 2-3 of them. I am sure that they would come out to measure,design and install if you want them to. But I would talk to more then one dealer to get the best price oh yeah get some referances.

I have no connection to the Omega/Dynasty company any longer I stopped working in the cabinet field almost two years ago............I just know that the product is great as is there service people.

Jim

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#10

Ellis Walentine

Here's my take...

Ellis Walentine

>I'm another cost-conscious person about to build some kitchen cabinets and I plan to make them entirely of veneer core plywood -- shop birch to be exact. It's nice-looking if bland and cheaper than the higher-quality plywood you would use for visible surfaces like cabinet ends. If you will have exposed ends on any of these cabinets, substitute the higher quality panel for the shop birch in those areas.

I don't use MDF for cabinets and any of the flake-core and fiber core boards will swell up like a sponge if they get wet. The cost difference isn't worth the angst. You should finish the plywood with a couple coats of lacquer. You might line the sink cabinet with cabinet liner, a thin HPL (high-pressure laminate -- Formica and others make it) to resist the constant abrasion of all the stuff you store down there.

My 2�.

Ellis

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#11

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabi

matt overton

>You might try sherrs.com. I don't know how much you want to do by yourself, but they sell all you need to build very good quality cabinets at very good prices

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#12

Omega cabinets

John K Jordan

>The Tennessee Omega factory is not one mile from our place. I didn't realize they made quality cabinets. I do see the parking lot full whenever I go that way so it looks like business is good.

JKJ in East TN

Re: OT: looking for credible source/advice on cabinets

#13

Re: Omega cabinets

Jim Canning

>Yes that is a new factory, the main one is in Waterloo Iowa.