Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Complete newbie question

Posts

Complete newbie question

#1

Complete newbie question

Alex Yeilding

>The totality of my turning experience is chucking a piece of birdseye maple in my drillpress and using my block plane and sandpaper to round out a knob for a tool. worked well, but I suspect the DP isn't designed to take those side loads, and that wasn't the safest procedure!

Anyway, I was thinking of buying a mini lathe, which should meet my needs for furniture knobs, tool handles, and things like pens, wine stoppers, etc., and then move to a full-size lathe if the bug bites me.

But I have the opportunity to get a Jet 1236 lathe for not a whole lot more. Anyone care to comment on that lathe? If I'm doing small stuff, would I find a mini more convenient to use?

Re: Complete newbie question

#2

Re: Complete newbie question

john lucas

>I think the 1236 is a decent lathe and I don't think it will be much different to use than the mini. Besides you might want to try a table leg or 1/4fluted column for furniture.

The mini lathe is easier to store if you don't have a place for the larger lathe. On really big lathes the tool rest and tailstock can be a pain to move around when turning small work but the 1236 isn't much larger than a mini lathe. It also has a little more horsepower which is handy if you decide to turn larger items.

Re: Complete newbie question

#3

Re: Complete newbie question

Greg Haugen

>In my opinion, yes, you would find a mini lathe would be better to use. I'm not a fan of the style of lathe that the jet 1236 is made from, same as the Delta "iron bed". It has features that a lathe that size and strength shouldn't have, in my opinion. Mainly the headstock swivel-there is no need to turn outboard on that lathe-it's not made for it. Also each time you'd slide the headstock, since it does swivel, it would have to be re-aligned with the tailstock. The "reeves" drive for the speed control drives me nuts with the noise that they can make. I'd rather change belts and turn on a quiet machine- and the variable speed models are hands down better. In my opinion the new 1220, is A LOT better of a lathe than the 1236. I'd sacrifice some swing even and prefer the 1014 over the 1236. Rikon and Steel City also have excellent "smaller" lathes, the "mini" term doesn't really do these newer machines justice.

I'd even be so bold to say it would be a matter of time and the 1236 will be a machine in the past and be discontinued.

This is my opinion, I've been wrong before-ALOT! :-)

Greg H.

Re: Complete newbie question

#4

Motor is the same as the new "smaller" lathes

Greg Haugen

>The newer lathes have really "raised the bar" for smaller lathes. The jet 1220 has the same 3/4 horse than the 1236. Along with the extension for the 1220, it's bigger than the 1236. It looks as though it will be the replacement.

Greg

Re: Complete newbie question

#5

Correction from previous post

Greg Haugen

>The jet 1236's headstock doesn't slide but does pivot. I was thinking of the Delta Iron bed about the sliding headstock.

Re: Complete newbie question

#6

Re: Complete newbie question

Tony - Memphis

>Can't comment on the lathe you mentioned, but I needed a lathe for making furniture parts. I'm not into bowls and such. I bought the Jet mini with the extension and have been real happy with it. I've turned legs, finials, etc. I bought an index wheel for it and that is a nice add-on. I also added a longer tool rest. Anyway, been a good machine for a non-turner like me.

Tony

Re: Complete newbie question

#7

No shortage of strong opinions on WC!

davidwalser

>Alex,

You've heard some of the downsides of the Jet 1236. They're all true. The design is out of date and there are better lathes on the market. Having said that, I still think the Jet 1236 is a good lathe and may be the better choice for you. The extra size and horse power may come in handy and the extra mass can help soak up vibration. The Jet will handle all the pens, knobs, bottle stoppers, small bowls and spindles you throw at it.

On the downside, the Jet 1236 has a rotating headstock. If you rotate the headstock (to turn outboard), it can be difficult to get the headstock and tailstock back into alignment. The simple answer to this problem is never rotate the headstock! Problem solved. (If you feel you must rotate the headstock for this-once-in-a-lifetime-so-I-can't-justify-a-larger-lathe project, aligning tailstock and headstock is not too difficult. I have a short bar that has a #2 Morse Taper machined on each end. Using this tool, it's child's play to get proper alignment.)

A larger concern is the Reeves drive. Electronic variable speed is nicer and some would prefer to switch pulleys to using a Reeves drive. Still, properly maintained (keep it clean and only change speeds while the lathe is turning), a Reeves drive should provide years of trouble free service. I have a Harbor Freight clone of the Jet 1236 that has served me without problems for over 5 years. Certainly a genuine Jet should be expected to do just as well.

I also have a Woodfast lathe which is my primary lathe. Still, the HF sees a lot of action. I use it for small items like pens and for longer spindles that won't fit on my Woodfast's short bed. I also use the HF when I'm in the middle of a project on the Woodfast.

HTH

Re: Complete newbie question

#8

i agree!

robert davis

>

Re: Complete newbie question

#9

Re: Complete newbie question

Philip Morris

>Alex,

Just to be clear that the Jet 1220 "mini" has the same size motor as the Jet 1236.

I had a 1236 and "upgraded" to a 1220 variable speed (VS). Although the 1236 is heavier than the 1220VS, it is actually less stable when roughing an unbalanced blank. This is because the lowest speed for the 1236 is 550rpm, whereas the lowest speed of the 1220VS is 200rpm. I placed the same unbalanced blank on both machines. The 1236 had a noticable vibration (even with 300lbs of gravel on the stand), while the 1220VS showed no vibration (just sitting on a workbench)until I turned it up over 400rpm. The 1220VS uses a DC motor and is way quieter than Reeves Drive used on the 1236.

In the defense of the 1236, it is a decent lathe if the price is right. It is true that rotating the headstock to do larger turnings is not a good idea. However, you can rotate the headstock to reduce back strain when hollowing. Also, rotating the headstock is nice when buffing becuase you don't have to worry about the buffer wheel grabbing your turning and slamming it into the lathe bed. I recently sold my 1236 for $200, which was a pretty fair price for both parties. My $0.02.

Re: Complete newbie question

#10

Ric Taylor

Re: Complete newbie question

Ric Taylor

>Alex,

There are many of us around here that started with a Jet 1236. It's a great lathe and it will serve you well. I had one as my first lathe and it did a heck of a job on everything I tried. I never had any problems with the reeves drive, or any of the other problems that others have mentioned.

I bought mine used (it was used as a demo/classroom machine in a woodworking store, so it had a lot of "miles" on it), and I sold it three years later for more than I paid for it ($500). Used lathes are not difficult to sell, there is a good market for them.

I turned everything on that lathe from tiny to large items without any trouble.

I have since moved on to a larger and heavier Jet. The 1236 will allow you to discover what part of woodturning you enjoy, and then you can sell it and get something bigger or smaller as you desire (yes, some people do upgrade to smaller lathes, especially if they find they enjoy working on small items).

Ric

Re: Complete newbie question

#11

Dick Hines

Re: Complete newbie question

Dick Hines

>If you are like most turners you WELL end up turning larger things than you first thought you would. Go for the largest lathe you can afford. You can do small things on a big lathe but not big things on a small lathe.

Case in point. Yesterday I turned 3 pens on my PM 3520. Today I am working on a 16" bowl on the same lathe.

Re: Complete newbie question

#12

Re: Complete newbie question

Wayne Fladby

>You would be able to turn a tool handle on a mini, but you would never be able to drill the end of it.

The 1236 would be a better choice for a first lathe.

Re: Complete newbie question

#13

Thanks, all

Alex Yeilding

>For your responses. Variety of opinions, indeed, but explained with enough rationale that I feel like I understand the trade-offs. Right now I feel like a Jet 1220 VS would be the way to go. The auction I am looking at still has some 1236s and a 1014VSI at attractive prices. If either stays at a price that would have me just shrugging and saying "oh well" if I make a mistake, I will probably act, else wait to get the 1220 (before I learn that I really need a Powermatic or Oneway!)

Thanks again for the informative answers.

Re: Complete newbie question

#14

Re: Complete newbie question

Barry Turner

>A few years ago, I had the same dilemma. My wife had already decided to get a Jet Mini for me as a Christmas gift. We were in the store and she offered to up the ante and upgrade my gift to a Jet 1236. As you say, it was only a few dollars more. I looked at both lathes very carefully and decided the Mini was a better built lathe than the 1236 and went ahead with the Mini. The Mini is a great lathe. I had heard reports of the Reeves drive on the 1236 being noisy and prone to problems. Its hard to find a drive that is quieter than a belt drive on the Mini. I have had no regrets over buying the Mini. If the "turning bug" really bites, you won't be stopping with a 1236 anyway. (I now have a Stubby 750, but I still have the Mini, too!)

Re: Complete newbie question

#15

Re: Complete newbie question

john lucas

>I'll tell you my story. I started with a Delta full size that was very similar to the Jet 1236. I did a lot of turning with it but always had little issues. Vibration was the biggest problem. I though it was my tool control and/or sharpening. A pulley broke on the drive system and it was going to take some time to get a new one. I had an order that needed to go out and had just gotten a bonus so I ordered a Nova Comet. This was a precurser to the Jet mini's made by Techantool. A very similar machine except for the motor placement. I could not believe how smooth it ran. My turning improved overnight. The Jet and Delta mini's came out right after this lathe and took over the market. Mostly because these mini's are so solidly built and run so smooth. That's why I'm in such a hurry to recommend them to new turners.

Re: Complete newbie question

#16

drilling question

Alex Yeilding

>"You would be able to turn a tool handle on a mini, but you would never be able to drill the end of it. "

Wayne, can you elaborate on that? The description of the Jet 1014 includes these statements:

"Live center has a removable pin for boring through stock" and

"Hollow tailstock allows you to perform long hole boring for lamps and other vessels"

Are these features not commonly found on minis, or does your statement refer to something else needed to drill the end of the handle? In this arrangement, are you limited to drilling a hole the same size as the hollow in the tailstock?

Could you chuck the blank in the head, then put a drill chuck with a MT2 taper in the tailstock, and rotate the blank while driving the drill with the tailstock ram?

Sorry if these are stupid questions! Be gentle on the newbie! ;-)

Re: Complete newbie question

#17

Re: drilling question

John K Jordan

>I think what he meant was a drill chuck in the tailstock with a bit would be too long to drill the end of a tool handle.

Another thing you can do is spin the drill chuck and push the tool handle into the bit just like a horizontal drill press. To end drill like this and keep things straight, some people build a little table to sit on the bed, perhaps with a sliding board with a groove or something to keep the handle straight.

When I turn magic wands on a jet mini I don't have enough room in front of the tailstock to hold the wood with a chuck. To get around this, I turn a short morse taper on the end of the blank and force it into the headstock MT.

Some people get bed extensions for the mini, but if you plan that from the start, why not get a longer lathe? I thought about getting one for mine, but seems like it would make it harder to carry around.

JKJ

Re: Complete newbie question

#18

Re: drilling question

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks. I hadn't thought of the length of the chuck and bit, added to the length of the workpiece. Already made the purchase, so I'll just have to figure out how. I like the idea of turning a tapered tenon on the workpiece.

Re: Complete newbie question

#19

Re: drilling question

Karl Rinehart

>Why not drill the piece before turning?

Re: Complete newbie question

#20

Re: drilling question

GalenV

>I was worried about drilling a long handle on my Jet 1220. Found I could easily turn a 14" long handle. To bore it last I had enough room with my jacobs chuck and drill bit in the headstock and used the tailstock without a center. The handle cupped nicely in the ram. I was ready to make a V-block with vertical adjustment off the bed so I could remove the tailstock for more room. I would think the v-block would work on the shorter lathe. Could get fancier with wheels like a steady rest but v-block is fast to make.

Karl's drill first works well to as used it later on another project and just had to turn a dowel to fit to hold the piece.

I'm learning a lot of tricks as I go too.

Easier in wood compared to the metal lathe I had.