No shortage of strong opinions on WC!
davidwalser
>Alex,
You've heard some of the downsides of the Jet 1236. They're all true. The design is out of date and there are better lathes on the market. Having said that, I still think the Jet 1236 is a good lathe and may be the better choice for you. The extra size and horse power may come in handy and the extra mass can help soak up vibration. The Jet will handle all the pens, knobs, bottle stoppers, small bowls and spindles you throw at it.
On the downside, the Jet 1236 has a rotating headstock. If you rotate the headstock (to turn outboard), it can be difficult to get the headstock and tailstock back into alignment. The simple answer to this problem is never rotate the headstock! Problem solved. (If you feel you must rotate the headstock for this-once-in-a-lifetime-so-I-can't-justify-a-larger-lathe project, aligning tailstock and headstock is not too difficult. I have a short bar that has a #2 Morse Taper machined on each end. Using this tool, it's child's play to get proper alignment.)
A larger concern is the Reeves drive. Electronic variable speed is nicer and some would prefer to switch pulleys to using a Reeves drive. Still, properly maintained (keep it clean and only change speeds while the lathe is turning), a Reeves drive should provide years of trouble free service. I have a Harbor Freight clone of the Jet 1236 that has served me without problems for over 5 years. Certainly a genuine Jet should be expected to do just as well.
I also have a Woodfast lathe which is my primary lathe. Still, the HF sees a lot of action. I use it for small items like pens and for longer spindles that won't fit on my Woodfast's short bed. I also use the HF when I'm in the middle of a project on the Woodfast.
HTH