>Thanks to those of you who responded to my recent post about band saws. Since some of you have voiced similar disappointments with the delta plus block arrangement I guess my next question is to ask what I should do to overcome what I perceive to be the shortcomings of my current arrangement.
I am most frustrated by my lack of getting a decent resaw. At the moment I would like to be able to resaw boards which are full 4/4 and are about three and a half inches high. I have made a fence to help keep the board straight, use a half inch four tooth blade. The problem is the blade wonders significantly and produces an unsatisfactory cut. What should I be looking at to correct this problem?
Secondly, I am not able to cut green bowl blanks as well as I feel I should. Seems to lack power and get bogged down. I use a 3/8 inch three tooth blade for this operation.
I somehow think tension has something to do with the problem but am, afraid to overtension.
Any suggestion to help the situation will be greatly appreciated since there some other things Santa can buy if I can solve at least some of the bandsaw problems.
>you have the right blades, however I've not done much re-sawing, so I'm not positive about that one.
But I know that when a blade wanders, it is normally one or both of two problems... Not enough tension on the blade, and trying to force the cut to go faster. I learned when making bandsaw boxes that if I began to notice the blade wandering a little, it was because the blade had become dull, and I was unintentionally pushing harder to try to keep up the normal speed of cut.
When I first began using the bandsaw a lot, I was afraid I was going to overtighten the tension, and the blade wandered too much. I gradually tightened the blade until the wandering stopped, and then marked the tension arrow for that certain blade.
>skip i have a jet 14 in. with riser block use a timberwolf 3/8 blade for green bowl blanks lubricated as timberwolf suggests with pam. not a problem with bogging down if i go slow..resawing ...tension could be the problem..highland woodworking sells a resaw blade that performs better than most..
>Putting a 2 HP motor on the 14" Delta, making sure the tensioning mechanism works, and a new and stiffer tension spring, will solve most of the resawing and greenwood bowl blank problems.
I have posted a couple articles on my website about my experiences with the Delta 14" bandsaw. It might be useful.
>When you say "wander" do you mean from side to side several times in a short distance or does it head off in one direction? The first can be improper tension or the wrong blade for the job or a dull blade or improperly adjusted guides. The second indicates a normal adjustment is needed for drift. The Duginski book will tell how. (Every bandsaw user needs to read his book, IMHO)
Lack of proper tension is the biggest thing that causes problems. The springs and tension gauge on the bandsaw are not entirely useful. I purchased a high-tension spring and a tension gauge. I bought a Starrett, but Iturra Design sells several other models for much less money.
Also, for cuts with a long frequency, a single-point fence might be more useful.
Ask the resaw question on the Flat side of Woodcentral - more people there are resawing lumber. There have been a number of threads discussing this in detail in the past few months and years.
Thick green wood is another issue. One thing that works wonders is to use Brian Hahn's method of modifying a blade - break off every other tooth of a 3 TPI blade to make a 1.5 TPI blade. I've done this and the difference is amazing.
Here again, lack of sufficient tension can be a big problem. The blade can try to "bow" sideways in the cut vastly increasing the tension and stalling the motor. One author says the blade bows to "seek it's own tension".
Another thing with green wood is buildup on the blade. On my Delta gunk always builds up on the inside of the blade, squished and reapplied by the tires. This can greatly increase friction and bog down the saw. I use a brush inside but that's not enough. I've applied lubricants but they don't work. What works for me is to hold a small metal rod to the side of the blade while running and strip off the buildup. I use a piece of brass square tubing so accidental contact with the teeth won't destroy the sharpness. (I use a big screwdriver on my bandsawmill for the same thing) If you try this, I am not responsible for injuries.
Another thing that works for gunk is changing the guide blocks: I generally use "cool blocks" but I recently read of a trick - use the stock steel blocks on the left-hand side and set that clearance to rub lightly but constantly. Use cool blocks on the other side. The sharp upper edge of the steel guide block tends to clean off the blade as it runs.
I currently use a very aggressive 1.5 Lenox blade on the 18" Rikon for cutting thick green wood. That blade with a lot more power is no comparison to my smaller Delta.
>My old Walker-Turner had a 1-HP motor that just didn't have enough zip for the kind of bowl-blank cutting you're talking about. I replaced it with a 2-HP Baldor and the difference was like night and day. My 20" saw has a 3-HP motor and that sails through everything without a whimper. So, horsepower is part of the issue.
Regarding your problem with the blade wandering when resawing 3 1/2" high material, it could be any one of a few things. First, if you're using a straight fence without compensating for drift, that would cause the blade to wander. Not enough tension is another possible issue. I wouldn't be concerned about putting too much tension on the blade. Your tension springs will probably bottom out before that happens. And make sure you're using the right blade and that it is SHARP (emphasis intended). I use and prefer a point fence, which can take several forms, from a sharp perpendicular edge to a long curving contour centered on the blade. The latter is what Duginske uses. He tuned our old Delta saw with a riser block that we had at the old American Woodworker shop, and I easily cut 11 3/4" high walnut veneer on it. In fact, the board I cut was featured on the cover of one of issue #61.
Another thing that can cause a blade to wander is the width of the blade. Resawing puts a lot of pressure on the blade and, whether or not it is tensioned to the max, a narrower blade can actually deflect in its width. When this happens, the telltale sign on the sawn face will be a dishing or cupping effect. In that case, I suggest a wider blade, possibly with fewer teeth. 1/2" and 3/4" x 3 tpi is fairly common; I use 2-3 tpi variable pitch blades with good results. For your short stock, though, you shouldn't need anything coarser than 3-tpi.
Qualitatively, I would consider all of the traditional 14" bandsaws (Delta, Jet, etc.) to be fairly lightweight. You can push them to their limits by adding riser blocks, heavier tension springs and bigger motors, but they are still medium-duty machines. If you want a businesslike saw, you should be looking at a minimum of a 16" model with a foot or more of resaw capacity built in and at least a 2hp motor. The bigger the better. The trade off with larger saws is that you tend to need a smaller saw, too, for scroll work and other chores that don't require the heavy cutting capacity of the bigger machines.
Your questions have been well answered, I think. One detail not specifically mentioned is whether your blade is centered on the wheels such that cuts parallel to your fence. If not "centered" this would cause the blade to drift consistently in only one direction, either left or right. As Ellis said, a point fence or curved fence could compensate for this. An alternative would be to adjust the upper wheel to move the blade slightly forward or backward on the wheels (with appropriate adjustments to all the guides as well), so that it cuts parallel to the fence.
>Thanks to all for the good advise. There are obviously several places to look for the problem. Since several folks have said they have the same machine and like it I will try to tune mine up before letting Santa replace it.
As before I am I am impress with the breadth of knowledge of this group and even more impress with the willingness of all to share what the know and to help those of us who need to be enlightened.