Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

santa asked

Posts

santa asked

#1

santa asked

Skip Beardsley------WebKitFormBoundaryo2PSwy+o0IUR

>Santa, in the body of TLOMY, asked recently what kind of new bandsaw I wanted. Since I have not really thought that a new bandsaw might be in my future I must admit to having no idea how to respond. I only know I am unhappy with the one I have. It is underpowered and doesn't resaw easily. Possibly operator incompetence. In any case, does anyone have a recommendation I can pass along. Mostly, I turn bowls, up to sixteen inches, and do a limited amount of resawing.

Thanks for help.

Skip

Re: santa asked

#2

Re: santa asked

john lucas

>I am very happy with my Delta 14" with Riser block. I think the Jet is equivalent. You can resaw up to 11" and I've cut a lot of greenwood bowl blanks with it. Ideally it would be nice to have something a little heavier duty with more horsepower but this one does all I ask of it.

Re: santa asked

#3

JL

Re: santa asked

JL

>Nice Santa.

I've tried out the Rikon 14" at the Folk School. It is nice. I have a Rikon 18" and it is nice. I think the 14" Rikon (1.5 hp and a reasonable resaw capacity) is a good saw.

If you can find old iron, I like the Delta 14". I have one with a small (1/4") blade, which I use for curve cutting.

Re: santa asked

#4

Delta and Rikon *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Skip,

I went through the same exercise a few months ago.

I now have two: a 14" Delta with a riser and an 18" Rikon.

The Delta is great but when cutting large green blocks it could use a bit more power. In addition, it is limited in the amount of tension that can be applied so wider blades cannot be used effectively. Note that to make the stock saw useful, you almost have to add a high tension spring, stronger tension arm, and for ease of use, a quick tension release (Carter) if the new saw doesn't come with it.

I bought the Rikon after a lot of reading and balancing cost vs benefit. It's certainly not the best saw out there, but it seems a very good saw for the money. It has no problem with power and can handle a wide blade easily. My Delta now sits unused in the corner, but when I get a larger shop I'll put it back into service with a narrow blade.

I wrote a "mini review" of the Rikon 18" in the thread below.

JKJ


bandsaw thread

Re: santa asked

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: 20" Agazzani......

Jesper, Denmark

>I bought this some years back and cannot find a fault with it, except for small curvy work, the table is too low.

Re: santa asked

#6

Re: santa asked

John Scheideman

>I had a 14" Delta with a riser but was not happy with it for cutting bowl blanks. I bought a 16" MiniMax and have had it for about 4 years now. It made a huge difference and I've been very happy with it. The MiniMax people are great to deal with and provide super after-sale service.

John

Re: santa asked

#7

Re: santa asked

john lucas

>John I'm curious as to why you didn't like it for cutting bowl blanks. I know more horsepower might make it faster but I've been able to cut any bowl blank I wanted with my Delta. I can't cut real fast but then any faster and I might cut off a hand. It seems to cut quite well. My only complaint is the size of the table. I would like to have a much larger table. I've been looking at things like 20" bandsaws because they are more rigid and the table is larger but I this one seems to do all that I need.

I resawed some curly oak 11" wide for a friend. There are some saw marks but then I didn't use the best blade. I just cut up a bunch of cherry into bowl and hollow vessel blanks, some as thick as 10" without a problem. When I do stuff like that I have to ask myself why I want a bigger saw. Those of you who own one might be able to tell me.

Re: santa asked

#8

Slippery Slope warning......

Barry Irby

>I have a 14" Delta with riser block about ten years old and have a love hate relationship with it. I find it very frustrating. Maybe my expectations were too high. (By contrast, I have an old Delta Rockwell Contractors TS with a Forrest blade on it and I like it, it just cuts everything I pass over it, and does it well.) With a band saw, you have to have the right blade on it, narrow to cut curves and wider to resaw. I do a little of everything in my shop and find that I always have the wrong blade on the saw. Want to resaw? Spend 30 to 45 minutes putting on the other blade and tuning the guides. Need a bowl blank. Spend 30 to 45 minutes putting on the other blade and tuning the guides.

I have added a Carter release, band rollers, stronger spring, dust collection, not to mention a riser. The table is about the size of a postage stamp (remember those?). I have as much invested in this as I would have in a larger better equipped saw and it is still under powered.

If I had the money and larger shop, which I would have if I had the money, I would have two bandsaws. One for resawing and one for csu=vs and bowl blanks. So, once you get one, you may find yourself sliding down the slope toward a second one.

OTOH, I have made eight boxes this week for Christmas presents. Resawn most of the parts. Provides for nice grain matching and book matching. When it works it works. I think a rally nice blade would be a good thing, but a carbide tipped one costs over $100 and a bowl blank would ruin it in about a second. Since my son uses my shop, I would have to take the blade off after each use to protect it.