Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Question about hollow forms and collars

Posts

Question about hollow forms and collars

#1

Question about hollow forms and collars

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I have been thinking for a long time about how people decide on the size and shape of a collar, if the decision is made to use on a hollow form.

I often use collars on my hollow forms, but have noticed that they tend to be short curved that continue or restart the curve of the form. I am pleased with the collars I use, but am interested in expanding the style of collar I turn.

Quite simply asked; when you decide to use a collar on a hollow form, how do you decide on the wood, shape, size, and height of the collar you turn?

Inquiring minds need to know.

Thanks in advance.

keithz

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#2

Timely query

Steven Kubien

>I'll be watching this one closely as I am about to put a collar on for the first time. I'm not really sure how to do it but trial and erro have worked before!

Steve

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#3

Re: Timely query *LINK*

Tom Young

>An example of one way to make a collar on a hollow form is described in the Honolulu Woodturners website in the "Tips & Techniques" section. The direct link is


http://honoluluwoodturners.org/index_files/collar.htm

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#4

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

john lucas

>I don't do a lot of collars and I think one of the reasons is that I have so much trouble deciding on the design. It's just way to easy to take away from the main form by the wrong choice of shape or color.

Here's the problem. I can hollow through a 1 1/2" hole about 3 times as fast as I can through a 3/4" hole. (assuming I'm doing a vessel small enough to use the 1/2" tools) Consequently it is much easier to hollow through a big hole and make a collar.

When you do this you are possibly lowering the quality of the whole piece. I say possibly only because I have seen many many wonderful pieces with a collar. Ideally you should design a piece and then not alter it simply because it's difficult to hollow through a small hole.

Been there done that, so I'll tell you how I got around it. The simplest way to have a small hole in the top is to hollow through the bottom. Rough out the vessel with the top at the headstock end. Cut a thin slice off the bottom and put this in a plastic bag (if this is green wood). This will be your plug and the grain frequently runs parallel to the slice so it can check easily, that why the plastic bag.

Now hollow your vessel through the hole in the bottom. After you finish shapeing part it off and clean up the top. Then drill as small a hole as you want in the top. (off center really messes with people minds) Put the vessel up to dry. I put it in a paper sack and set it in an area with little air movement. Turn the plastic bag inside out once or twice a day to let the plug dry very slowly. When both vessel and plug are dry carefully turn or carve the bottom hole to a taper. Glue the plug on a wasteblock and turn it to match the taper. Now glue it on place. Done properly with the grain aligned you can't see the joint.

second way. Cut the vessel in half where you would want a feature ring to be. Hollow both halves. Glue them back together and then shape the outside. Add a feature texture area to cover up the glue line. Again you can drill the hole in the top to any size you want.

Sorry I didn't answer the collar question. I'll leave that to people who make good collars. I struggle with it.

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#5

Steven Antonucci

Always use ebony :-)

Steve Antonucci

>As a general rule, I think ebony goes with everything. Ebony can also be simulated with almost any wood and a black Sharpie marker...

To John's point, when I see a collar, I immediately think that the form was hollowed out through a much larger opening. There's a certain amount of "deception" about putting a collar on a form- since a non-turner might not understand that it's a very different skill to turn through the little hole. I think that if the intent is to hide the entry hole's size, usually the collar fails because it wasn't "designed" into the piece, merely added.

I have added a few collars that are "rings" that are generally the same size as the hole. They tend to be flat, with fairly large openings. I use them on spalted maple to contrast the "decay" of the maple with the "refinement" of ebony. In addition, the black on black (spalt lines) is like matching your shoes to your belt...

Steve

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#6

Rob Wallace

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

Rob Wallace

>Hi Keith!

I also use a fair number of collars on hollow forms... their contrast seems to set-off the figure in the wood of the main body of the piece, and allows some "completion" of the curve for the eye at the top of the vessel.

One of the main reasons I use a collar is to limit the visual and tactile "penetration" into the interior of the piece by the viewer. I do not spend any time at all sanding the inside of a vessel that is not meant to be viewed - an absolute waste of valuable turning time. I make a collar that hopefully accents and complements the body of the piece, yet has a hole small enough to restrict probing eyes and fingers to encounter any roughness in the vessel's 'unfinished' interior. Although the vessel is still 'open', is is very much limited as to what senses get in, and what information gets out!

The point that John Lucas makes about more efficient hollowing through a larger hole is a good one, but I still find myself hollowing through as small a hole as is practical when roughing the piece, and then adjusting the hole size (relative to the final size of the collar) AFTER the piece is dried - i.e. during finish turning. Seems like a waste to not start hollowing through a larger hole, but if it is cut too large at the outset you have little control of the collar size (and to some degree, shape) if it needs to be smaller to balance the piece.

I have seen beautiful collars made for pieces that have been works of art in themselves (...several ornamental turned collars I've seen are exquisite). I think the collar's role is to complete the curve or accent another visual element through contrast or shape/form change at the top of the vessel. In my opinion, the collar should not outperform or overpower the form and figure of the body of the vessel - it should just provide the accent to bring the eye in and "complete" the piece. I have also seen collars that are far too large for a particular piece, and these appear to throw off the balance significantly.

Interesting question....!!

Rob Wallace

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#7

Good points Rob-thanks

john lucas

>

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#8

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

Mike Brazeau

>Art Liestman wrote an article in American Woodturner Spring 2002 on Collars. I thought it was available on the web, but can't seem to find it. One reference at Long Island Woodturners touches on it from a demo Art did. I have it if anyone wants a scan. Note deletion in email address.

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#9

Please scan the article

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I would be interested is seeing a scan of that article. It came out before I started turning.

I hadn't been able to locate anything in my searches.

keithz

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#10

I know where to find them :)

Stephen Mushinski

>Keith,

You can find the information you want on the WOW site. Wally has a how to on collars under the "Reviews" section and you will find Art's write up in the "File Cabinet".

Both good reading!

Steve

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#11

Re: I know where to find them :)

Mike Brazeau

>Thanks Steve. I knew it was somewhere.

Mike

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

#12

Re: Question about hollow forms and collars

Paul Zerjay

>Why not make the collar part of your lid?


img