Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Compressor replacement

Posts

Compressor replacement

#1

Compressor replacement

Jerry Klug

>Steve,Antonucci asked about replacement compressors. I have been off line for a few days and just caught up on your compressor threads. The reply I didn't see was that all single stage (typically 125 psi) units are very noisy and do not lend themselves to a long life if run continously. The have to have time to cool down between cycles. I have had 5 compressors starting with a tiny oil-less for an air brush. Then it was a Sears 16 gal on wheels, a SpeedAire 60 gal, a DeWalt 2.5 gal contractors torpedo and finally my Ingersol Rand 60 gal two stage. The IR was a bit expensive but it can be running right next to my lathe and I can still concentrate on my turning. It does not overheat with a lot of run time either. The mention of synthetic oil is not only good for low temperatures but lubricates the pump much better than petrolium based oils.

The advantage to the IR is quiet operation, lots of air (that isnt hot), minimal maintenance and a thick tank ( no corrosion problem).

The disadvantages are higher price (more on that later), 220 V circuit for power and even though it is fairly quiet, it isn't quiet enough for my beagles to want to be near it when running.

I got mine during a "tool days" sale at my local hardware shop where all the factory reps were showing their stuff. That marked it down from around $1200 to $875. I recently retired from a State Inspectors job where I routinely inspected commercial installations of pressure vessels. I have seen thousands of compressor installations and found a lot of business trading up and selling their used ones. You might look at Craigs list for a used two stage in your area.

Things to look at on a used compressor, whether single or two stage:

Oil should be clear and not milky

No rust around legs

Liquid from petcock drain shouls be minimal and watery ( no emulsions but can be rusty colored)

Safety relief valve should be able to be manually opened and should not exhaust damp air

Pressure regulator functioning with shut off at 125 psi for single stage or 175 psi for two stage

NO DENTS IN TANK!

The "build plate" should be easily read and it will show the date manufactured, NB and serial numbers, tank thickness and max allowable pressure

You should have a pressure vessel inspector in your area. Contact your Labor and Industried department to see how to contact an inspector. We would check thickness of tanks with an electornic ultrasonic gage for people who wanted to buy a compressor if asked. That is the only way I know of telling whether a tank is safe or not. Hopefully the inspector in your area isn't looking to increase revenue for his department. I routinely inspected a 1908 tank that was still in good working condition. The owner and his forefathers always drained the accumulated condensation each week. American made tanks usually are thicker than the tanks from other places in the world. The BORGs often have tanks that are brand names but will have tanks made in Mexco.Not bad quality but they are made to the absolute minimums and therefore have no corrosion allowance. Where American made tanks for a single stage will usually be 0.125 thick, the ones from south of the border are 0.095. They meet minimum Code for design but if they start to rust, there is nothing left for safety.

The cooler the air is, the less moisture that can be suspended inthat air. Not too important for blowing out chips from a hollow form but very important if spraying laquer. My single stage compressors had a lot of heat and would cause fish eyes in paint unless there was some type of dryer.

This has been a bit long winded but there are some things to consider about replacing your conpressor.

Re: Compressor replacement

#2

Re: Compressor replacement

don lewonczyk

>There you said it best, nothing better then a man that has worked with compressors and knows his stuff. Thanks for the info, it wants to make me sell my other compressors and get a two stage, my 60 gallon 5HP trips the overheat on the motor after two cycles, a real pain when you are trying to get something done. DonL

Re: Compressor replacement

#3

Thanks Jerry- very interesting info

john lucas

>

Re: Compressor replacement

#4

Steven Antonucci

great summary! Thanks

Steve Antonucci

>

Re: Compressor replacement

#5

Re: Compressor replacement

matt overton

>I'm going to inspect mine today. THANKS

Re: Compressor replacement

#6

Ellis Walentine

One other thing...

Ellis Walentine

>... and I still don't know how to inspect for it without taking the compressor apart, and maybe not even then... and that is the unloader valve. My understanding is that this is the check valve that lets the air out of the cylinder(s) when the compressor is turned off, so that it doesn't impede startup, like the unloader on a big chainsaw. I can't stress how critical this is, since a stuck unloader on our old '40s-vintage two-stage compressor is what appears to have been the cause of our devastating shop fire in 1999 that erased my entire history of woodworking. The motor (5-hp, 3-Phase) just sat there and cranked but the compressor wouldn't turn over. The current draw overheated the connector in the breaker box causing a huge arc that blew a hole in the box and the shop was toast.

At least that's what the fire marshall suspected.

Ellis Walentine, Host