>All was fine and I was somewhat happy with the results but as I was applying wipe on poly......the wood softened a bit from being wetted and I put my hand in the wrong place. Oh well, tomorrow I try to GLUUUEEE!
The wood is some trash wood from Peru. It started life as an ugly dyed brown charger. Got a stack of them from my sister in law, oh well 11 more to play with. It is about 12.5" in diameter.
The pic is from a cel phone, sorry about the quality
It appears the grain runs horizontally across the picture so that the break occurred where the grain was the shortest, if that makes sense. I would try to orient the piercing so that you avoid this area on both sides. Rotate your positions and stay out of the shortest grain. Clearly, pieces such as these are not meant to be handled and will never be dishwasher safe.
I have no experience with piercing so take the advice with a grain of salt.
Brian: bummer - the piercing looks good otherwise. This might be a design opportunity - sculpture that edge and make great art!
End grain certainly seems weaker in some woods. If this is weak, I'd be afraid to court more disaster. Douse the piece with glue first? I wonder how it would look with larger holes with wider spaces between?
BTW, our local turner/carver/sculpturer Ralph Watts told me that bradford pear has the strongest end grain he's ever used, able to support long, very thin carved tendrils. The texture is beautifully fine grained and takes fine detail as well. Also an old article in FWW indicated osage orange was very strong across the grain. I haven't seen any osage big enough for a plate or platter, but I've read about it. Bradford pear is easier to find, at least around here.
>I cringe every time a client picks one of these up. I suppose if I had one of the high speed grinders it wouldn't take me so long to do this stuff and I wouldn't be so emotionally attached. Doing it with the Dremel takes some serious time and patience.
>I was Malcolm Zander's demo assistant at the AAW Symposium in Richmond this year, and specifically asked him about the breaking of thin wood pieces in the extensive piercing artwork he does. This is one of the main reasons why he uses strong, dense woods, like pink ivory, which retain their structural integrity even when very thin. With less dense woods it may be critical to think-out where your piercings are with respect to cross-grain position and loss of strength due to thinness.
Just a question - is it the photo or just me? - Is the center pierced section off-center? It's one of the things that jumped-out at me (besides the break out - boo boo) about the piece.
I like the direction where you are going with this, and I also will soon be working to learn how to pierced turned items well. I recently bought a Powercrafter, and look forward to trying this on some pieces over the next few weeks.
>You are right about the grain. My original intent was to pierce the entire rim. I chose to split it up because it was my first piercing and because I was scared I would break it. Had I planned to do the three sections from the beginning I would have taken into account the grain orientation.
>Just the photo. I used a powercrafter to do the pircing, it took around 2.5 hours. Here is a pic after I glued it back together. The wife will still like it and say she can't tell it was broken but I will always see the hairline cracks.
>Great save Brian. We always know what is wrong with our work, even if others don't notice. The other day my wife asked "Have you ever made a piece that you were totally satisfied with?". I could not think of one. Have come close a few times.