Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

Posts

Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#1

Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

Philip Morris

>I have been reading up on turning boxes and have seen a number of turners like Richard Raffan, Keith Rowley and Chris Stott use a combination type of collet chuck. Seems like it could be safer than having jaws protruding from the chuck body.

An internet search shows one offered under the name "Scheppach pcc2000" in Europe, but nothing stateside. Anyone know why?

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.

Richard Allen

>When I bought my Record CL3 it came with a "combination chuck".

You had to make tenon sizes just so. When compared with the four jaw chucks we use now these combination chucks are a nightmare.

The one use I found for the chuck was the pin chuck configuration.

If you were going to use the chuck for making boxes then you would need to make the stock or at least the tenon a very specific size. A tenon bigger or smaller by 1/4" and the chuck couldn't work. A tenon bigger or smaller by 1/8" and the chuck would have a light grip which would break free of the chuck during normal turning operations.

For the pin chuck configuration the chuck would be worth $50. The other configurations might be worth an additional $25 if you are someone who likes to experiment (and fail) a lot.

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#3

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.

mfoster

>Ditto what Richard said. I have one still kicking around in my shop. It came with a couple sets of jaws that will expand into a dovetail recess. I made this work and actually completed a lot of bowls with them, but they are a real pain to set up and fiddle with and are still nowhere near as strong or as accurate as even my worst scroll chuck.

I do find that I still will use the collet chuck that came with it. As Richard said the tenon (with a slight dovetail) has to be dead on to use it. He was really generous in saying that you have 1/4" of play. I would say more like 1/16". It will grip things well, and accurately, however you have a more tentative hold on the wood, and can't put a lot of force on it perpendicular to the lathe bed, or the wood will pop out. I saw Richard Raffan do a demo years ago in Phoenix. He used a chuck that he designed and sold. It was strictly a collet chuck that had 3 or 4 steps in it, so he had some choices in the size of tenon to grip, but it still had to be accurate. You could get his chuck for a while, but I haven't seen it in the catalogs for a long time. I still find that I pull this chuck off the rack once in a while, so I haven't chucked it :).

I used to use it for a pin chuck and a screw chuck pretty regularly, but only rarely now. I find that there are easier/quicker ways to hold the wood.

Don't know anything about it's availability or if it is even still being made. I think that it was made by Axminster in England. Check out Craft Supplies http://www.craft-supplies.co.uk/ or the Axminster site.

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#4

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have the same chuck. It was called a Six In One Chuck. It had to be assembled and re-assembled to use it's different features. I haven't used it in years.

Wally

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#5

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.

Philip Morris

>Thanks, ya'll,

I expected to hear that the modern chucks and their selection of jaws had surpassed this design. I appreciate hearing from folks who have used them in the past. It was just curious that these chucks are still available in Europe, when they have the same modern chucks also available to them.

I am wanting to start turning boxes. The standard jaws on my Stronghold chuck don't really go much smaller than 2". My No.1 jaws can grip small, but when gripping tenons between 1 and 2" will protrude from the body of the chuck. I am just not comfortable working that close to a spinning saw.

I guess I will have to look at using larger stock, making jam chucks or buying a smaller chuck.

Thanks again,

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#6

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.

John K Jordan

>If you have to work close to spinning jaws, wrapping tape or a big rubber band around the jaws can help prevent losing chunks of flesh.

I use 50 mm (minimum) jaws for almost all boxes. Pin jaws work well for smaller things, but I don't know what's available for the Stronghold.

JKJ

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#7

JL

Do you know a knitter?

JL

>My wife found the "chuck cuff" in the Lee Valley catalog. She had some odds and ends of sock yarns from various socks that she has knitted. She knit me a chuck cuff. It is colorful enough so that my hands don't go near it.

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.S.?

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Why Are Combination Chucks Not Available in U.

Brad Vietje

>Phillip,

I have one that has all the issues mentioned already. If you want to make multiples of the same design, and use calipers to measure and mark every tenon, they will work just fine.

However, if you make some of the taller box forms, the additional grip from some of the modern jaw sets is hard to beat.

Another option -- especially if you already have a 4-jaw scroll chuck -- is to make some dovetail jaw sets, or a dovetail circular chuck insert from a hard wood, with a split in it, which when compressed in the metal jaws gives it a small, but usable range of tenon sizes.

Even if you use a scroll chuck with 2" jaws, you can make smaller work which is parted off and reversed at the finish, or even part work off a glue block.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT