Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Tailstock vibration

Posts

Tailstock vibration

#1

Tailstock vibration

mfoster

>I don't do a whole lot of work between centers, but when I do I find an annoying bit of vibration/movement while turning near the tailstock.

I have an older Woodfast longbed lathe with riser blocks. I just can't seem to figure out what might be loose enough to cause the vibration. I have been fighting this problem for a while and thought that it was a very slight bit of wobble in my Oneway live center (had it for quite a while now) so I just got a new one. No improvement. So today I took the tailstock apart and inspected it as well as I can by eye. The screw assembly on the rear of the tailstock has some axial play, but there is a screw driven lock on the quill that is about 1" in length and seems to to lock the quill assembly solidly. I tightened everything that I could and gave it a spin again. Maybe a little better, but still not as solid as I would like.

I am turning some French style rolling pins for Xmas gifts. (I had planned this before the recent thread on rolling pins. Seems this is a common item for turned gifts.) I am turning 2" blanks of curly maple 22" long and find turning near the headstock has far less vibration than when turning the tailstock. I think this is something that I have lived with for a long time, and just compensated for it or found ways to deal with it. The curly maple that I'm turning may help to set up some vibration with the undulations of the wood, but I still find turning near the headstock more pleasant than when I get near the tailstock.

This has got me stumped. It seems that turning near the tailstock should be as tight and vibration free as near the headstock. I expect a little vibration in the center of a long blank, but not at the ends. Anyone got any ideas? This little annoyance in pushing me ever closer to taking the plunge and getting a Stubby.

Re: Tailstock vibration

#2

Re: Tailstock vibration

John K Jordan

>Yikes, what kind of lathe? I get zero vibration, also using the Oneway live center. I have some play in the tailstock unless the quill is tightened down (I never do that) but still get no vibration and I've turned some shafts as long as the lathe would allow.

My first thought was the center, since I have another center with inserts - one is poorly machined and I always get vibration from that one. But the chances of two being bad is slim.

Some wild thinking here, not based on experience: Is the tailstock aligned properly with the headstock? If you put the points together are they aligned? If not, that might contribute to vibration since the piece would have to change alignment every rotation. Applying force with the tool might make this worse.

If the tailstock is aligned when moved close to the headstock, I imagine it could still be misaligned (or misaligned worse) when moved to the end of the ways if the frame is twisted. (The cast iron can twist if the legs are not perfectly level.) In the absence of a good way to check the long alignment, you might try adjusting (or shimming) one leg or the other and see if the condition improves or worsens.

If it's not alignment, I can't think of what it would be unless the wood itself was badly out of balance but this is unlikely if it happens with every piece. Does it get worse or better if the tailstock is tightened more?

JKJ

Re: Tailstock vibration

#3

Re: Tailstock vibration

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Two things come to mind:

If you always have this problem, regardless of what type of wood you are turning, I'd suspect the live center.

A common problem with softer woods is that the hole that the tail stock center sits in becomes enlarged during turning. The solution is to periodically readjust the live center.

What I usually do is to start roughing the square stock to round at the tail stock end at a very low speed. The repetitive jarring of the gouge into the corners of the wood enlarges the hole that the center point sits in. I re-tighten the live center into the wood once or twice. This seats the center more solidly in the wood. Then I crank the speed up to normal turning speed for the rest of the turning.

Re: Tailstock vibration

#4

Re: Tailstock vibration

Michael Stafford

>Any chance that there is some gunk in the Morse taper in the tailstock? Perhaps the taper is not seated properly and you are getting some wiggle under load. It is very easy to clean the taper with one of those reamers and remove trash that might have accumulated.

Re: Tailstock vibration

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Tailstock vibration

Richard Allen

>I suspect that the problem can be attributed to the risers. Not much you can do about that. There is a possible work-around. If you drive the blank with a Oneway "safety" center and use the oneway live center in the tailstock you can flip so that you can avoid cutting wood at the tailstock end.

Re: Tailstock vibration

#6

Re: Tailstock vibration

john lucas

>Richard and Mike both gave the answers I would.

Are you turning right handed for both ends or switching hands. I'm not as good with my left and will occasionally have trouble getting perfect cuts on the tailstock end when using my left hand.

If that's not it I would lean toward the risers or possibly the locking mechanism not holding the risers strong enough on the ways. If you don't have trouble with the tailstock slipping then this probably isn't it. Riser blocks can easily produce vibration. You have more mass in the headstock end which might dampen it. What did you use for Riser material. I would suggest MDF,it seems to compress less than other woods. Of course metal would be best. Corian might work well also.

Re: Tailstock vibration

#7

Re: Tailstock vibration

mfoster

>Thanks all for the thoughts.

My centers don't align perfectly, but very close. There is no adjustment provided in the tool as supplied, but with the judicious use of metal shims, it is really close. The thing about this is that I can't see how it would really matter. It would definitely matter if holding the wood by some fixed method (such as faceplate or chuck) but not between centers.

I bought the lathe with factory risers. These are machined cast iron, and I cranked on the bolts that hold the riser to the body of the tailstock. Can't see any happening here. There is a cam lever that holds the tailstock to the bed, which I have adjusted so I can crank on it as well.

I was thinking about this last night and came up with what Michael suggested, gunk in the Morse taper. Duh! Not sure if this is it, but would be really great if it was. I have one of those Morse cleaners and will inspect it carefully when I go out to the shop today. The live center felt solid, but it is possible that it is wobbling a little. I'll try it today and report back with the results.

Thanks again all

Mike

Re: Tailstock vibration

#8

Re: Tailstock vibration

John K Jordan

>>The live center felt solid, but it is possible that it is wobbling a little.

Hey, if you know a turner nearby you might try his live center on your lathe and vice versa to test.

JKJ

Re: Tailstock vibration

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tailstock vibration

keith tompkins

>Mike, Here is what I think may be happening....You get no vibration when turning at the headstock because the wood being turned is near the center driving it, giving the blank some support. When turning near the tailstock, the drive is 20" away, and applying the tool to the wood sets up a resonance between the two centers. This effect is very noticable when turning finials, you can actually watch the drag caused by the tool "twist" the wood, causing the vibration you noticed. An easy solution would be to turn one side of the pin, then swap it end for end, finishing up on the headstock for both ends.

Re: Tailstock vibration

#10

Re: Tailstock vibration

John K Jordan

>Kieth,

I thought of that too, since I turn a lot of long, thin spindles.

However, I just finished 9 french rolling pins from a variety of woods and had no vibration, with everything from heavy roughing and sizing cuts to light cuts with a skew. I imagine the stock is too thick (about 2") and too short (22") for significant vibration from flexing, even though it is tapered at the ends.

Flipping the work could well get Mike's current project done, though, regardless of the cause.

JKJ

Re: Tailstock vibration

#11

Re: Tailstock vibration

mfoster

>Well I spent half the day cutting up a couple of maples that I hauled out of the woods yesterday, splitting and stacking it for next year's firewood. They were only about 12" in diameter and not really big enough to bother with having them cut for lumber or even turning. I have 2 more trees up in the woods that blew over this summer that are still alive, but I intend on having these cut into lumber and using the largest end for some turning stock for hollow forms and a few bowls. That's for later this summer.

I still managed to get some shop time in and completed 2 more rolling pins. I looked at the morse taper and cleaned it out well. It seemed Ok, actually a little rusty, but no real crud. So I pulled out all of my live centers and gave them all a go. I found that using some of my older centers actually seemed to improve the problem. I could still get a little vibration going with them, but this could be controlled by stabilizing the blank with my hand. Put either of the Oneways in, and the vibration increased noticeably.

So here's what I now think may be the problem. The morse taper on the Oneway is noticeably longer than either of the live centers that show less vibration. Possibly the morse taper is not perfect that deep into the quill. I'm guessing if that is the case that the Oneways fit tighter deeper into the recess, causing a slight movement on the end towards the headstock. I can't feel it, but this seems possible. I have to think that the quality control from Oneway is topnotch, so would tend to think that the morse recess in my Woodfast is not perfect. So, is there such a thing as a Morse reamer?? Is this something my local machinist is likely to be able to handle?

John and Keith, my thoughts were right along with yours regarding the vibration. I was also blaming the curl in the maple with starting up some of the vibration/harmonics. It still seems that I shouldn't have it at all. I can actually complete the rolling pins even using the Oneways by stabilizing the blanks with my hand and taking very careful cuts. I just don't think I should have to go to these lengths.

Mike

Re: Tailstock vibration

#12

Re: URL for Morse taper reamer

-!-

>http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INLMK3?PMK0NO=979826

Re: Tailstock vibration

#13

Re: Tailstock vibration

John K Jordan

>How about grinding the end off one of the rotating centers? I'm want to take some off of one of mine to increase the clearance.

JKJ

Re: Tailstock vibration

#14

Re: If you have a self-ejecting quill...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>You may need to extend the quill a little further to get the taper to full seat. I have that problem with with several centers.

On the other hand, my Jet mini head stock taper is short and I've had to grind away some of the taper on several drive centers.