Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Posts

HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#1

HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

charlie belden

>HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

I�m going through my notes and a bunch of digital photos of the Cindy Drozda demonstration I attended earlier this year - in order to put together a web page or two about it for our wood turning club web site. I thought I had a fairly good understanding of how she turned the first of the three pieces she did- a finialed lidded box of myrtle with an inlaid rim. But when later tried to turn something similar, using what I thought was the procedure she used I bumped into How The Hell Did She Hold Things To Do This Part?

Now, having studied my notes and photos, and starting some line drawing illustrations of her chucking sequence I�m beginning to realize the importance of having a repertoire of �chucking� methods - and using the best methods for attaining the results I want - in the correct order.

When I think of �chucking� I think of a scroll chuck. Mount a chunk of wood in the jaws and cut away everything that doesn�t look like what I want - then part the piece off. A little whittling off the �nub�, a little sanding - and I�m done. OK - so with a lidded box I do all that twice - and maybe again for the finial (I like doing lidded boxes with finials, especially doing the finials).

But now, having gone over all this stuff from Cindy�s demo, I�m beginning to realize the importance of having - and when applicable -using - the right chucking method for an operation in a sequence. You can have every turning gouge and chisel under the sun. And you can have the skills and techniques to use them to make every cut you can imagine - IF YOU CAN HOLD THE PIECE IN ORDER TO MAKE THE NEEDED CUT. And THAT my friend may be one of the �secrets� to turning a good to pretty nice piece into a great piece, or at least a better piece.

Yeah, I know - Fred Holder�s book on chucking has most of the ways of holding a piece so you can turn something, some I�d probably never have thought of. And yes, I�ve gone through that book a couple of times. But it�s like studying algebra - �til you have a need to apply concepts in the real world it�s all abstract - and a little boring. Only when you see the abstract applied - to solve a real problem - do you begin to appreciate the value of all the concepts THEY made you slog through.

In the case of Cindy�s inlaid rim finial lidded box, she �chucks� things up six or seven times - using a chuck to hold a part, a part in the chuck to act as a face plate/glue block, a part to hold another part and a �turned to fit an immediate need� jam chuck - along with Saran Wrap and some �Festool Green� special masking tape. Each method is necessary in order to make the cuts that ultimately lead to an elegant, perfectly proportioned, nicely turned little piece that looks �just so�.

Turns out that having a lot of different ways to hold things can open up a lot of possibilities for getting around compromising an idea that otherwise wouldn�t be pursued. Hell, Escoulen had to invent his own chucks in order to make his ideas into realities.

So - do you compromise a great idea - either because you can�t figure out a way to hold a part for a particular turning operation, or because it�s just a bit of a hassle to turn a special jam chuck to hold the piece on - or in?

If you do take the time to come up with a way to hold a part in order to make the cut(s) it needs - has it taken the piece up a notch or two because you did?

Interesting this woodturning thing. So many things to consider, so much to learn - and apply.

Green tape. Who'd've thunk it?


img

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#2

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>Charlie...I always appreciate the time and effort you put into your thought provoking posts.

A couple of years ago I put up a "whiteboard" on the wall nearest my lathe. Often I need to make a "recipe" for a piece that will entail sequenced chucking and I plan that on the board. I agree wholeheartedly with you regarding the importance of chucking methods and planning them out, and there are few instructors that cover this element with appropriate focus.

I used to really resist making a part to hold a part of the part etc., and resisted making jigs and fixtures as well, but this aspect of turning presents a great challenge, and without challenge, I think I'd get bored. After some years of turning, I've collected a nice little box full of "one-off" jamb chucks, friction chucks, and tapered cylinders that are ready to be used another time, but sometimes I think it takes longer to dig through that box looking for just the right part than it would be to make a new one. So then, I make what I need and add it to the box when done. Who knows? It just might get used again someday.

Thanks for your post!

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

keith tompkins

>HI Charlie.... Here is "Keith's Rule": there is ALWAYS a way to put a piece back on the lathe. At the symposium in Orlando I used rubber bands to secure a piece to a turned wood chuck. If you believe there is a way, you'll find one!

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#4

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

john lucas

>Excellent post. I was lucky in that I started turning about the time chucks first came out. They were too expensive for my budget so I had to figure out all sorts of ways to hold things. I still do that today even though I have all sorts of chucks and jaws. You just have to approach things like this with an open mind and figure out some unique way to hold something.

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#5

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Carole Valentine

>I made my first 4-part piece (vessel, collar with recess, domed lid & final) recently. It took me a while, but eventually I figured out how to hold everything when and how it needed to be held, but as I told some friends, it would have gone a heck of a lot faster and smoother if I had just watched Cindy's video FIRST! The good thing is that when you struggle to figure out something yourself, it usually sticks with you!

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#6

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>One method for holding small pieces that is overlooked by many turners is using double faced tape. I use it regularly for turning small collars, small lids for use with finials and more. My method of using a plug inside the threaded portion of a faceplate to easily remove the piece after turning makes it quick and easy and no mess.

Wally

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#7

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Way back in the dark ages of woodturning, long before 4-jaw chucks came out, (about 1990) and before collet chucks were available, we made lots of jam-fit chucks, shop made collet chucks, and pin chucks held in machinist 3 jaw chucks. The 3-jaw chucks were used with a tenon but they weren't nearly as secure as the modern 4-jaw chuck is. Plus, they were real knuckle-busters.

Wally

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#8

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Russ Fairfield

>The mistake I see most often is where the woodturner let the chuck jaws determine the base diameter of a bowl. I know that wood is expensive, and they wanted to use the entire piece, but appearance is important too. Using a waste block would have allowed them to use all of the expensive wood and make the bottom smaller than the chuck jaws.

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#9

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Carole Valentine

>Double sided tape (the GOOD stuff)is essential, as Wally says. In my shop, so is painters tape and very thin wrapping tissue spritzed with water, since I don't always get my jam chucks turned as precisely as I'd like!

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#10

Steven Antonucci

Wrapping tissue!

Steve Antonucci

>That's got to be easier than using double face tape! I use DFT when they don't exactly fit (which is always), and I just use a razor knife to cut the tape away. Sometimes, it holds too well and I struggle to get the piece back off.

Wrapping tissue is now in my box!

Good tip!

Steve

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#11

Be sure to use the white tissue

Carole Valentine

>

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#12

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I have used tape for a long time

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#13

DF Tape The Easy Way....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>My method of removing pieces from the lathe when using DF tape makes it very easy. Turn a 1/2-inch deep plug to fit inside the threaded part of the faceplate. After the piece is turned, remove the faceplate from the spindle, place the plug inside the faceplate, thread it on to the spindle and the plug pushes the piece off. Takes a few seconds. Couldn't be more simple.

A friend sent this idea to Wood Magazine Tips, and they sent me a check. My friend wanted half as my agent...he got my thanks but no money.

Wally

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#14

Re: DF Tape The Easy Way....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I should mention that the only "good" tape is Permacel cloth tape. I get it at Craft Supplies.

Wally

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#15

How about hot melt glue.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I use it for securing lots of things at the intermediate stages of turning. Like the rim of a rough turned bowl to a face plate so I can true up the mortise/tenon. Or as a little extra insurance for a less-than-ideal match between the chuck jaws and the piece. Or a piece that really can't be held in a jam chuck, but there's no other way to hold it. Or...

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#16

double sided tape

John K Jordan

>A friend uses this tape for large bowls. (Holds great to a faceplate - he burnishes one layer to the faceplate, a second to the wood, then sticks them together) To remove, he uses a syringe and injects acetone into the tape from the side in several places which loosens it.

JKJ

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#17

Re: double sided tape

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>John, tell your friend that he's doing it the hard and messy way. Tell him to use my plug method. Comes off in seconds with no mess.

I usually use tape for platters. Works great.

Wally

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#18

Re: double sided tape

John K Jordan

>I'll tell him the method (I've used that method too) and tell him Wally said to use it, but he said the method he developed works fine for him and didn't mention mess or any particular degree of difficulty.

JKJ

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)

#19

Re: HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?) *LINK*

charlie belden

>Well - though it wasn't my intent to get into "chucking" tips and tricks, I picked up some useful info from this thread. Thanks.

But the issue I was trying to get into was doing whatever it takes to make the cuts that an idea requires vs compromising the idea in order to avoid taking the steps that the better design required. Maybe it's a matter of whether one is willing to take shortcuts and be content with Close Enough or work out the best way to take an idea to as perfect as one is capable, and maybe a little beyond that. Where I THINK the bounds of my skills and abilities are - and where they probably actually are is often a little different. It's when one steps outside The Comfort Zone and pushes at the boundaries that things can get really interesting.

Perhaps it's studying Cindy Drozda's designs and approach to turning that prompted my initial post. Even for a demonstration piece, she goes for as perfect as reasonably possible. On the inlaid rimme finial lidded box, she took no shortcuts. When she sensed a tool she was using needed sharpening she stopped and sharpened it. If she had to sand she didn't skip grits - and it turns out she knows a lot about sand papers, among other things - she'll make a tool required to make a critical cut, she'll customize a tool grind to get the cut she needs to make.

Now I don't know if the Seeds of Change piece on her home page - a three sided open piece - with three "finials" - one outside and two opposing each other inside - was inspired by a mistake in the tree sided box she turned at our demo (she turned through the sides of the box) - but it wouldn't surprise me if it was. The old given a lemon - make lemonade thing.

But back to Doing Whatever It Takes - I'm of two minds on that one. I like to Wing It - be it flatwork or turning or even carving. Take some wood and start playing with it, sometimes with no idea of where I'm going, most often merely a vague idea - subject to change as things develop. I'm beginning to realize how limiting that approach can be and have begun making and using jam chucks, changing jaws in order to follow a developing idea and planning the turning operations a little more. The idea of a white board is worth pursuing. Sure would come in handy on a current mentoring project - an 8' four door, rasied panel linen cabinet - with a relatively inexperienced woodworker. Finding wall space for it will be a trick - space always being an issue in a shop.

Back to the question - have you gotten to Do Whatever It Takes, or have you at least considered taking an extra step or two to take an idea up a notch? If so - did that change your work?


img

Seeds of Change Piece - inspired by a mistake?