HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)
charlie belden
>HOLD IT! (A limiting factor of design?)
I�m going through my notes and a bunch of digital photos of the Cindy Drozda demonstration I attended earlier this year - in order to put together a web page or two about it for our wood turning club web site. I thought I had a fairly good understanding of how she turned the first of the three pieces she did- a finialed lidded box of myrtle with an inlaid rim. But when later tried to turn something similar, using what I thought was the procedure she used I bumped into How The Hell Did She Hold Things To Do This Part?
Now, having studied my notes and photos, and starting some line drawing illustrations of her chucking sequence I�m beginning to realize the importance of having a repertoire of �chucking� methods - and using the best methods for attaining the results I want - in the correct order.
When I think of �chucking� I think of a scroll chuck. Mount a chunk of wood in the jaws and cut away everything that doesn�t look like what I want - then part the piece off. A little whittling off the �nub�, a little sanding - and I�m done. OK - so with a lidded box I do all that twice - and maybe again for the finial (I like doing lidded boxes with finials, especially doing the finials).
But now, having gone over all this stuff from Cindy�s demo, I�m beginning to realize the importance of having - and when applicable -using - the right chucking method for an operation in a sequence. You can have every turning gouge and chisel under the sun. And you can have the skills and techniques to use them to make every cut you can imagine - IF YOU CAN HOLD THE PIECE IN ORDER TO MAKE THE NEEDED CUT. And THAT my friend may be one of the �secrets� to turning a good to pretty nice piece into a great piece, or at least a better piece.
Yeah, I know - Fred Holder�s book on chucking has most of the ways of holding a piece so you can turn something, some I�d probably never have thought of. And yes, I�ve gone through that book a couple of times. But it�s like studying algebra - �til you have a need to apply concepts in the real world it�s all abstract - and a little boring. Only when you see the abstract applied - to solve a real problem - do you begin to appreciate the value of all the concepts THEY made you slog through.
In the case of Cindy�s inlaid rim finial lidded box, she �chucks� things up six or seven times - using a chuck to hold a part, a part in the chuck to act as a face plate/glue block, a part to hold another part and a �turned to fit an immediate need� jam chuck - along with Saran Wrap and some �Festool Green� special masking tape. Each method is necessary in order to make the cuts that ultimately lead to an elegant, perfectly proportioned, nicely turned little piece that looks �just so�.
Turns out that having a lot of different ways to hold things can open up a lot of possibilities for getting around compromising an idea that otherwise wouldn�t be pursued. Hell, Escoulen had to invent his own chucks in order to make his ideas into realities.
So - do you compromise a great idea - either because you can�t figure out a way to hold a part for a particular turning operation, or because it�s just a bit of a hassle to turn a special jam chuck to hold the piece on - or in?
If you do take the time to come up with a way to hold a part in order to make the cut(s) it needs - has it taken the piece up a notch or two because you did?
Interesting this woodturning thing. So many things to consider, so much to learn - and apply.
Green tape. Who'd've thunk it?




