Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

I was a bumble bee too...

Posts

I was a bumble bee too...

#1

Steven Antonucci

I was a bumble bee too...

Steve Antonucci

>I was at a turning club meeting many years ago and I had a 1/4" bowl gouge that I had brought along to show how I hollowed with it. One of the guys said "you can't hollow with a bowl gouge"...

I said "Really, I do it all of the time?"

The line was drawn, so I chucked up a piece of wood and showed him and the small crowd that had gathered. And I hollowed with a bowl gouge. Do you know what he said?

"I don't care what you say- you can't hollow with a bowl gouge!"- even though he had seen it with his own two eyes...

Nowadays, I preface everything I say or do in the presence of another turner with "This is how I do it..."

Welcome to hive.

Steve

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#2

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

Greg Haugen

>You reminded me of a good point.

It drives me NUTS when we bring in a "pro" and throughout their demo they say "This is THE right way to do this" or "this is the only way to do this" or "this is the RIGHT grind." I can't even sit still when I hear that. In my opinion, there are very few "wrong ways" in turning but many "right ways" to do something. I know there's several "newer" turners out there that have short gouges because everything a "Pro" comes they learn about the "magic" tool grind and then go home and change theirs. Why? If it's not broken, don't fix it. If the grind works for you, use it. If the tool works for you, use it. If you need to change it, then try something new. When I teach or demo I start, for instance with bowl gouge grinds, by saying, "a proper grind can range from 40 degrees to 85 degrees stubby. It all depends on what the tool is doing and how you're presenting it to the wood. These are the grinds I prefer___________." My hope is if someone is having troubles with their grind their comfortable to try another but if theirs works that they don't waste money and shorten it. Along with that "number" for the grind I also try to show them how to use a gouge-it's more than just a "degree angle" that turns it magic. Once they know how to cut with it, it can be adjusted to the application desired.

Sorry about that. I'm done ranting now. :-) Just a pet-peave.

Greg H.

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#3

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

Cyril Griesbach

>Greg, you really hit the nail on the head. Most of us have heard this many times as well and it always ticks me off as well. And, what is rarely mentioned is WHY it's the RIGHT grind, method of chucking, way to cut the blank...well you get the point. If asked, the big hat will say something like "because it's the way I do it" which brings us back to Steve's hollowing with a 1/4" bowl gouge where he showed the guy and he still didn't believe.

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#4

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

John K Jordan

>>It drives me NUTS when we bring in a "pro" ... "this is the only way to do this"

That doesn't bother me. The guy found what works for him and sticks to it but it doesn't mean I have to, although I will listen and maybe learn something. You know, you almost have to feel a little compassion for someone so closed minded and fixed in their ways they actually believe that. Another thing to keep in mind is people who assert their way is the only way often do so to cover their insecurity.

I tend to use what has worked for me as well, but fortunately I'm no pro and can afford to pay attention to how others work and maybe learn something new. I learned a great bowl grind and some techniques from the Jimmy Clewes videos just last week that have already improved my off-the-tool surfaces. Two dogwood pieces I just finished needed only 600 grit paper, with a bit of 400 in a problem area. (Of course, it takes me 8 times as long as Jimmy, but hey, who's keeping time!)

JKJ

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#5

Fortunately, not all demonstrators are like that.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>We had a demo by Binh Pho three weeks ago. He started with turning a thin wall bowl and prefaced his presentation with, "there are many ways to do this. This is how I do it." (or something like that) He never once talked about grinds.

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#6

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

Paul Waddle

>A person may not be blessed with both a woodturning AND people personable talent. Actually they are lucky,I don't have either. I don't mind listening others,I'll give them their due,but you can beleve, if I run into difficulty,even not attributeable to their instructions I return to my own devices... There's some thing to be said of one's comfort ways.

Most learning,especially a skill,is an accumualtive process. Well meaning instructors want to glide you through an effortless evolution-makes a smooth demo and makes everyone smile-why go the alternative?? pw

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#7

Re: Fortunately, not all demonstrators are like th

Donna Banfield

>I didn't know that I was a Bumble Bee, but after reading everyone's description, I think I am -- even though I'm not black and yellow striping on the fatter body parts ;^)

I've taught woodturning at Rockler and Woodcraft, and have done demos for woodturners (clubs and symposiums) and the public (non-woodturners). I have always made sure that at several times during the demo or instruction I make this statement, "There are probably a half dozen different ways to do this same thing, and here's one (or two, or three) of them. Try it/them out and see if it works for you."

If what I am demonstrating or teaching is completely unfamiliar (i.e., how to free-hand sharpen a bowl gouge, or how to hone a skew chisel with a slip stone), and they really want to understand how that specific technique is performed, I will try to set aside extra time to show how that is done. Then they have the ability to figure out whether that method is one that will work for them.

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Fortunately, not all demonstrators are like th

keith tompkins

>I tell people, this is how I do a certain function. If you like it, and it works for you use it. If not, that's OK too. Soon, by picking up bits and pieces from different sources, you'll develop your own style of turning. Take what works, reject that which does not.

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

#9

Re: I was a bumble bee too...

bowlman

>bzzzzzzzzzz bzz bzzzz bbzzzbzzz bzzzzzz bzzzzzbzzzz bzz bzzzz zbzz zzzzz bzzz bzzzz bzzzzz bzzzzzzzz bzzzzzzzz bzzzzbzzzz bzzzzzzzzz zbz bzzz zbz bzzz bzzz bzzzzz bzzzz bz bbzzzz ...