Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

First end grain lidded box questions

Posts

First end grain lidded box questions

#1

First end grain lidded box questions

GalenV

>Tried to go through the steps and make my first lidded box. Thought square bottom would be easier.

Wood I had available was soft maple and knew maybe tougher to get smooth end grain but just trying the steps.

Have no square nose scraper but used a 3/8" bedan. Since it has an end bevel of 45 degree is it a poor tool to try to always use rather than a rectagular square nose with 80 degree bevel?

I have no side scraper but used my RS multitip tool and the half tear drop scraper with point towards the bottom. Since this scraper has a 90 degree edge seemed like it did not cut(scrape) well. Would grinding a 80 degree bevel edge give me a better cut? A new tip is a lot cheaper than buying a true side scraper.

Got 1 3/4 boxes done. The 3/4 box had good lid and on the bottom I had a catch trying to hollow and after rattling out of chuck it has no top lip. That box was too deep for reach over the rest. Good box was made less depth. Any rules on depth limits or practical depths?

Is the flat bar box rest that can project into the box a good way if you don't buy heavy scrapers?

Comments welcome, but not going to give up.

Thanks Galen.

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

#2

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

john lucas

>I think the bedan makes a great scraper but you have to keep the cutting tip lower than the support area of the tool rest. A skew on it's side is an even sharper tool, but that depends on how you sharpen your bedan. A skew on the side has effectively a negative rake because the top surface will be going down hill. If you tilt the bedan handle up you get the same cut.

I think box depth has more to do with the over all shape. If you go with Raffen's book he says the lid should start about 3/5's or so up the box and that's a good starting point but I think you could easily make a box that is tapered that could be 6" tall and the lid could only be an inch or less. This would violate that rule but done properly would look really nice.

I think hollowing tools make great scrapers. They are often thicker and vibrate less. The flat tool rests do a very good job of supporting the tool in deep boxes. I don't own one but have use the one that Bestwoodtools sells and it works great.

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

#3

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

Michael Stafford

>In my opinion rounded bottom boxes are much easier for beginners and first boxes. Trying to get a flat bottom and square corner and straight sides particularly in a deep box is difficult and sometimes not for the faint of heart. The deeper you go in a box the amount of leverage working against you increases exponentially. You do not mention in your post the dimensions of the box you were working on so I cannot completely visualize the problems you were having.

The first time I tried to hollow a deep box as described in the Raffan book "Turning Boxes" I used a long and strong 3/4" wide and 1/2" thick square scraper. It would hollow just fine and if kept sharp did a good job of leaving the sides cleanly cut as long as you kept the tool cutting above the center line so that the sharp left corner and side did the cutting.

Now when you to the body you better be ready for some monumental catches if you aren't careful. You have to learn to feather the scraper along the bottom just lightly scraping. It helps to have the scraper ground with something less than a 90 degree angle with respect to the left corner. I actually grind my square scrapers with a rounded end where only the left corner is square and end is slightly curved. This helps prevent the whole end coming in contact with the bottom all at once and eliminates some catches.

Once you have achieved the desired depth you can take the same scraper freshly sharpened and starting in the middle take light feathery scrapes to the left until the bottom is the same depth and smoothness all the way across. If you have a big catch it can be very difficult to remove all the torn grain in the bottom.

With regard to the side grain. It is vertical grain and will require some sanding. Do as Raffan suggests and make a sanding stick. Take a large dowel or section of broom handle and cut a slit in one end so that you can insert sand paper and wrap it around the dowel and sand the sides. To sand the bottom just extend the paper beyond the slit in the dowel and bend it over and sand until your desired level of smoothness is achieved.

Deep hollowing is difficult and is not something I would recommend for a first box. Refine your techniques on smaller boxes and gradually progress toward larger and deeper boxes.

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

#4

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

robo hippy

>I do love to do boxes. For your first efforts, I would suggest keeping the depth to no more than about 1 to 2 inches. Problems with reaching that far off the tool rest that you can learn to deal with later. With a square bottom, you want to be careful when you go from the bottom to the sides. You don't want the tool to be in contact with both the side and the bottom at the same time. Big catch! Use a square scraper that is angled back/relieved on both the inside edge, and the tip so that it is less than a 90 degree angle. I prefer the slightly rounded bottom transition because it is easier, and when you round the outside of the box to match, it looks better than a straight cylinder. I have found the carbide disc cutters to be the best tool for the inside of the boxes. I have the Eliminator, and would think the Hunter will work as well, but you want more of a straight shaft, and you want the cutter at a 45 degree angle rather than flat. Flat tends to be catchy. I can often get a surface that needs little or no sanding.

robo hippy

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

#5

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Unless you buy another, I would not regrind your RS teardrop scraper to 80 as it would decrease it's versatility. It would become a one-sided scraper and you would lose 50% of your edge.

I find that the teardrop leaves a nice surface with a fresh 90 grind and angled just slightly.

keithz

Re: First end grain lidded box questions

#6

Re: Thanks all for input.

GalenV

>Somehow I thought making a larger box I could also leave thicker walls and lips till I saw things were going right. I probably have seen more books and video on rounded inside but thought for larger dia. box this would leave too much wood. Well they were all thoughts. Harder to sand right in the 90 degree corner as I found out.

First box was 3" dia. 2 3/4 bottom 1 3/4 top. Second was still 3" dia. but 1 7/8" bottom and 1 1/4 top.

John I have used my skew for a scraper on spindle type turning but it's an oval skew and it seemed poor idea to try and keep level inside a box. Not like a rectagular I have seen used.

Michael, yes my next will probably be rounded inside bottom and top and not as tall. Was thinking of buying a Sorby 829H box scraper or the 825H diamond side scraper but did not know if one is better than another.

Kieth, Using the Sorby teardrop scraper let me us the straight edge on the box side and with the point in I would not contact the bottom.

I did turn it up to present just the edge but thinking if I ground the edge to 80 I could keep the flat side of the tool on the rest.

I would buy another cutter as I have used it on either face on bowls.

Thanks again all for input.

Galen