Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Stupid Question

Posts

Stupid Question

#1

Stupid Question

KurtK in Indy

>Among many I have floating around my pea brain....I think I heard at one point that one can use acetone as an accelerant for CA glue. Is that correct and could you just put it in a sparay bottle to use?

Thanks

Re: Stupid Question

#2

Re: Stupid Question

Stuart Johnson

>Kurt, I think acetone is used to dilute CA. I've heard/read plain water will work as an accelerator. I've never done either so can't swear to either one working.

Re: Stupid Question

#3

JL

Re: Stupid Question

JL

>Acetone is a great solvent. I wouldn't be tempted to use it as an accelerator. You can try N,N-Dimethyl-P-Toluidine, which is the active agent. Some have tried water and some have tried dilute ammonia in water. I'd vote more for the ammonia in water.

Re: Stupid Question

#4

Acetone got my fingers unstuck from CA :-)

GalenV

>

Re: Stupid Question

#5

Re: Stupid Question

john lucas

>Kurt Acetone is the solvent. I don't think it will work as an accelerator. I have tried most of the solvent replacements, water, baking soda, ammonia, etc. I haven't found any that work anywhere near as good as the accelerator made for that purpose. it's a lot cheaper than the glue and lasts a long time so I no longer see any reason to try the other stuff.

Re: Stupid Question

#6

Galen - Got your email at home

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>regarding the pilaster detail I posted. I started writing back and got pulled away from the keyboard by my two kids. I'll try and finish my response soon.

Ray

Re: Stupid Question

#7

Acetone Will Dissolve CA....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I keep a glass jar handy and when I get a plugged-up glue bottle tip I put it in the jar. When I have several tips in the jar I pour in some acetone. By the next day all of the tips are clean and the dissolved glue is in the bottom of the jar.

Wally

Re: Stupid Question

#8

Good question *LINK*

John K Jordan

>KurtK,

One thing I read is that accelerators vary widely and some are formulated for specific types of CA glue. The recommendation there was to use the accelerator made for the type of glue you have. This would explain why some people have different experiences with different home brew accelerators.

Checking the MSDS sheets for several CA accelerators:

MSDS for one accelerator : 100% N,N-DIMETHYL-P-TOLUIDINE

MSDS for one accelerator : synthetic hydrocarbon (light naphtha odor)

MSDS for one accelerator : 70-80% heptane, 20-30% acetone, .1-.5% toluidine

MSDS for one accelerator : 90-95% actone, 5-10% toluene polymer

MSDS for one accelerator : 55-65% acetone, 35-45% ethyl acetate

MSDS for one accelerator : 97% acetone, 3% DMPT (toluidine)

MSDS for one accelerator : 80% N-Heptane (solvant), .01-.05% amidine

Some notes of comments by others on CA accelerators:

- mix water and baking soda for a good accelerator

- acetone is both a solvent and accelerant

- Acetone is the main component in some CA accelerators. Other accelerators contain no acetone and use other chemicals, isopropyl alcohol and n-heptane to name a couple.

- commercially available accelerators use amines carried by a solvent such as acetone - the amine catalyzes the reaction. An aromatic amine is aniline, toluidine, etc

- Be sure to use an accelerator formulated to work with specific cyanoacrylate glue

- using baking soda can make the glue cloudy instead of clear

Some instructions say to apply the accelerator to the part, let it dry, position, then apply the glue. Some say to apply the glue than the accelerator. Some people say using accelerator will weaken the bond. Some say the accelerator will not weaken the bond. Some say accelerator will harden the surface but the glue underneath will still be liquid.

Again, differences in instructions and experiences may be due to the type of glue and the type of accelerator used.

What I do: buy the accelerator from the same place I buy the glue. I like the StickFast in the aerosol can since when I buy little pump sprays they always seem do dry out too fast. However, I rarely use accelerator - things seem to bond OK without it with just a bit of patience. It's interesting that StickFast uses different formulations of accelerator in the aerosol can and pump.

You might find the section on Curing Process interesting in the link below, written by woodturner and StickFast guy, Joe Matwick. It mentions that gluing wood is sometimes more difficult than other materials since woods are more or less acidic and dry, two things which inhibit CA curing.

JKJ


History of CA glue

Re: Stupid Question

#9

Re: Stupid Question

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>As others have said, acetone is a solvent not an accelerator.

The accelerator's I've used contain acetone as a solvent/vehicle/thinning agent for the actual accelerator agent. The acetone serves the same function as lacquer thinner in lacquer or mineral spirits in varnish.

Re: Stupid Question

#10

Accelerator makes an easily fractured bond

john lucas

>I have made hundreds of hand mirrors. I played around extensively with different techniques for bonding the glue block to the good side of the mirror. I have settled on CA with Accelerator. When I do that method all you have to do is hit glue block hard and it fractures the joint at the glue line. Most of the time there is some glue left on both pieces of wood with no wood damage. If I leave the accelerator off it will almost always pull wood off of one or the other.

Re: Stupid Question

#11

Re: Stupid Question

Fog Tanner

>I have always found that the 1.5 second set time was fast enough. Also the accelerators weaken the glue joint, which is already a brittle joint. They do not take shearing loads very well. There have been a number of home brews over the years for accelerators, you can probably find them on the net now if you search the model airplane groups.

As noted acetone will dissolve the CA. I use notromethane, its a little more pricey but a whole lot faster and I have 30 gallons of it.

Fog

Re: Stupid Question

#12

Thanks for the replies, Folks!

KurtK in Indy

>

Re: Stupid Question

#13

Interesting....

KurtK in Indy

>The article in the link is very interesting, John. Probably all you ever needed to know and more about CA. Thanks for the reply!

Kurt

Re: Stupid Question

#14

Re: Stupid Question

Russ Fairfield

>Why do we buy an adhesive that says "Instant" on the label, and then try to make it cure faster??.

Re: Stupid Question

#15

Alcohol

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>I have used successfully alcohol DNA as an accelerator, it works and I like it because it does not smell bad, but with the CA glue I have now, it turns the glue white.

Sometimes it is irrelevant because further turning or sanding will take care of it.

Jorge

Re: Stupid Question

#16

Re: Good Article

GalenV

>Reading the article made me go look at what I was using. I just bought what was at the Woodsmith Store when I started to make pens and it required CA glue. STICK FAST is the trade mark but it has Woodsmith Store name and logo. I just assumed it may be their expensive version of glue.

Tried to use CA over the years but never had much luck holding kids toys or anything together, maybe just rough use. Always confused me as there were so many brands and versions on the market.

I see the TMI web site gives me a good idea of the difference in Stick Fast Series. It did surprise me to see they say accelerator is acetone.

I guess I was just told it was a good debonder to use in case I glued myself to lathe. It worked to free two fingers glued well and must be because I just flooded with acetone. Glad it did not glue me permanently!

Thanks again for making me read and THINK!

Re: Stupid Question

#17

I often wonder about that, also.

Allen Neighbors

>I guess it's because, get, have, faster, more power, etc., seem to be the watchwords of the day.

I tried it once, with a spritz of water on a piece that had spun out on the lathe. It came out again, later. It may have just been because I used water, but accelerant does make a weaker joint, I believe.

Re: Stupid Question

#18

A simple test you can do.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Put a couple of drops of acetone on a clean, non-reactive surface. I used the bottom of an empty Mountain Dew can. I first cleaned the date code off with some acetone and a paper towel, then applied fresh acetone.

Put a drop of CA glue at the edge of the acetone puddle and watch what happens.

In my test, the thin CA glue (two different brands) flowed into and mixed with the acetone. The medium viscosity CA glue sat at the edge of the acetone puddle. There was no sign of a hardening reaction after one minute.

As a second test, I cleaned the bottom of the can, put a fresh drop of each CA glue on the can, and squirted it with accelerator. All three CA glue drops hardened within a few seconds.

My conclusion is that acetone is not an accelerator for CA glue.

What little I know of the chemistry of CA glue supports this conclusion.

p.s. Like JL, I was a chemist in a previous life, although CA glue is way outside my field of expertise.

Re: Stupid Question

#19

Re: Good Article

John K Jordan

>> It did surprise me to see they say accelerator is acetone.

I don't think the accelerator is just acetone. If you look at the MSDS for their two types of accelerators, acetone is an ingredient but not the only ingredient. I forget exactly, but I think their two formulations are the last two in the list I put in the previous message. It was interesting to me that the aerosol can and pump bottles used different formulations.

MSDSs are wonderful. Manufacturers are required by law to make them available to the public and they have to be accurate. Sometimes they make them hard to find.

JKJ