Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Tool Steel Questions

Posts

Tool Steel Questions

#1

Keith Tompkins

Tool Steel Questions

keith tompkins

>I recently posted a photo of my new roughing gouge I purchased at an antique center, a 2" Buck Brothers gouge. I took it to a class I was teaching, and used it for two days, as needed, roughing blanks. Hmmmm, not bad...still sharp. Tonight I quartered two 18" ash logs with a splitting maul, then directly rough turned 8 cylinders for an upcoming demo with the same gouge. NOW it's dull. No big deal, except this tool is probably 60 years old and made of high-carbon steel. I have expensive, high-speed steel tools that cannot hold up to that kind of abuse. What's up with that!

Re: Tool Steel Questions

#2

Re: Tool Steel Questions

john lucas

>Keith is it the grind. Some rough out gouges have a really steep grind and these hold an edge longer than a shallow grind. My best friend up here still likes his Buck Brother tools. He says when they get short they lose their edge holding capabilities so he just rehardens them and the work fine.

Re: Tool Steel Questions

#3

Re: Tool Steel Questions

Gordon Seto

>A wild guess, would that be because of the size of the gouge? A bigger gouge, a wider cutting edge to wear down.

Re: Tool Steel Questions

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool Steel Questions

keith tompkins

>Hi John, (and Gordon) I ground this gouge to the original angle. I just measured it at 32 degrees (more acute than a 45). I find this curious, since we are told that the older steels are far inferior to the new hs, powdered, whatever the sales pitch is. Perhaps the steel has a naturally high vanadium percentage, or the makers had forging methods that are no longer used to create a tough steel. Gordon, I was roughing very aggressively, taking a 1" wide swath, creating long continuous ribbons. I have several hs steel tools that would have needed sharpening before this old gouge did. I'd like to see a scientific comparison between some of the newer and older steels...I bet there would be a few surprises.

Re: Tool Steel Questions

#5

Re: Tool Steel Questions

R Payne

>It depends a lot on what HSS is being used. Some have alloys that create large carbides that can result in faster dulling when the tool is ground to a shallower angle. Carbon steel can be sharpened to a shallower angle than HSS. Then there is heat treat. Many (maybe most) HSS do not harden to the same hardness level that can be achieved with carbon steels. In general the higher hardness the more wear resistance. The forging should not be a factor as the heat treat will (theoretically) undo any influence from the forging.

ron

Re: Tool Steel Questions

#6

Re: Tool Steel Questions

john lucas

>I may be wrong but for turning tools hss can be hardened as much as needed. Usually somewhere around58 to 62rockwell. All tools are hardened based on what the manufacturer thinks is the best balance between hard fragile edge and softer less fragile edge. It could simply be that your tool has been left harder than the HSS tools.