Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Turning Pecan

Posts

Turning Pecan

#1

Turning Pecan

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>My son just brought me some Ikewood(downed in the hurricane) pecan from Houston. The ends are well sealed and no signs of checking. I have heard that this is very hard wood so is it better to turn green?

If so will it warp signifficantly as it dries or can I final turn it immediately.

Thanks,

JohnV

Re: Turning Pecan

#2

Re: Turning Pecan

Texian

>John,

If well sealed it may keep for several months, but at the first signs of checking you should at least rough turn it (10% rule) asap. Dunno about finish turning it green.

Dry, it is hard, but HSS tools are harder. The part I hated was sanding the end grain areas, so if finish turning dry you will want to make the smoothest finish cuts of which you are capable. I have a little left, and am resawing it into stock for segmented work. No end grain that way.

Re: Turning Pecan

#3

JL

Re: Turning Pecan

JL

>Pecan turns well when wet. When dry it is a very hard wood. Pecan is sometimes sold as hickory. I think that it makes some of the very best legs - you can turn a hickory/pecan spindle fairly thin and it will support a LOT of weight. I've had leg spindles that were down to 1/2" in the narrowest part.

Re: Turning Pecan

#4

Re: Turning Pecan

John K Jordan

>I understand pecan and hickory are very close, pecan being a species of hickory. I've turned hickory bowls and spindles, in fact, just came in from the shop after turning a spindle from some quite dry hickory. Roughing gouge, followed by skew chisel gave a great surface. I use water to raise the grain before finish sanding.

Green chunks warp like crazy and like to check too.

I think dry spindles are easier to turn than dry bowls, but either are certainly possible. (BTW, I find dry hickory no where near as hard as lyptus and I had fun making a bowl from it once.) An otherwise soft-spoken gentleman in our club once was described the hickory in a large bowl as "the most cussed wood I've ever turned."

JKJ

Re: Turning Pecan

#5

Re: Turning Pecan

Clay Foster

>I've turned a lot of pecan. It turns nice when it is green, but dulls tools quickly. It will warp significantly. When it is dry, it becomes pecancrete. Don't bother turning your grinder off if you turn it dry. It has great color, and will spalt nicely. Wood bores will walk across

Egypt to eat it.

Re: Turning Pecan

#6

Re: Turning Pecan

Sean Troy

>In regards to sanding end grain and tear out,the best solution I have found is dipping your sanding paper in Bio-Shield hard wax #32 ( made with Orange peels) and sanding. It will paste up on you so use new paper area freaquently with more wax. Speeds up sanding tear out considerably with no staining of wood or finnish effect.

Re: Turning Pecan

#7

Ric Taylor

Re: Turning Pecan

Ric Taylor

>John,

I have turned a lot of Houston Pecan, it is one of the most common trees around here.

Regarding you question on warping, a friend and I are currently finishing platters made from Pecan. The platter blanks were originally adjacent to each other in the tree. I guess you could say they are book-matched. Actually, the slab was cut down the middle to make the two platter planks.

We both rough-turned our platters, then let them dry. He air-dried his in his garage, and it warped terribly. I dried mine using the alcohol drying method. It was soaked in the alcohol for several weeks, because sometimes that's how long my breaks are between turning. Anyway, mine did not warp at all, and it is very stable.

Ric

Re: Turning Pecan

#8

with/without alcohol - good info!

John K Jordan

>Ric,

Your comparison of drying with and without alcohol soaking is interesting. I'm adding your experience to my growing collection of notes on drying methods, including alcohol soaking, microwave, boiling, etc. When people report a success or failure, they usually don't have a control for comparison, let alone one cut from the same slab! If you can add any more detail, I'll add that to the notes as well.

After soaking for several weeks, did you simply air dry in your shop? Did you both dry on a rack, leaning, flat on a shelf, wrapped up in something, under an elephant?

Do you know of any other differences between how you and your friend handled the platters - turned to approximately the same thickness? What about average shop temperatures, humidity? For example, was this in a humid summer or dry winter, and were both shops similar in environment conditioning?

Do you happen to know which half had been closer to the pith? I had two slabs warp differently, the only difference was one was cut just to the side but very close to the pith, one further away. Some species seem to be far more sensitive to this.

I've tried some simple experiments with roughed bowls and smaller pieces, but I didn't think of trying big roughed out platters - warpage there could be more extreme and perhaps easier to quantify. I may take some slabs from a red oak log here. Just curious, what kind of container did you find to soak a big platter - a plastic bag?

Also, I can't find "Houston Pecan" in my reference books. Could that be a local name or a specific cultivar?

JKJ

Re: Turning Pecan

#9

Re: with/without alcohol - good info!

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>John,

My son lives In Sugarland on the southwest edge of Houston. His house is next to the levees along the Brazos river. In this area there are many Pecans close to 80 ft tall and often 2' or more dbh. I think they are just a southern pecan , not a particular cultivar.

I may have to try the alcohol soak. I rough turned a smallish bowl today and am trying the wrap in newspaper, place in plastic bag, change the papeer every day untill dry. With woods I've tried before this takes up to 4 weeks. I do get warping on some woods but seldom any cracking. I'll let you know hao the Pecan does.

Re: Turning Pecan

#10

Ric Taylor

Re: with/without alcohol - good info!

Ric Taylor

>John,

Houston Pecan is not a name, I was just indicating where the wood came from.

We both dried our rough blanks in our garages during the humid heat of the Houston summer. I use the Dave Smith method, wrapping the outside of the platter or bowl in paper grocery bags and drying it upside down on a rack. I use a large plastic clothing storage box with a snap-on plastic lid. It's about 20" by 28" or so, and designed to slide under a bed, or to stack several of them. They are the translucent boxes, and they are cheap at Bil Lots or WalMart. I seal the edge of the lid with tape to help prevent evaporation of the alcohol.

Basically, I don't do anything fancy or different, I just follow the Dave Smith instructions. The only thing that is different, is that I tend to soak for weeks instead of a day or two, and that is only because sometimes there are weeks between my turning sessions.

Ric

Re: Turning Pecan

#11

Ric - one more question

John K Jordan

>Ric,

Thanks. The big question for a comparison, then, is how did your friend dry his platter - also wrapped on the outside, or just set somewhere such that air could get all around it? I assume he didn't paint the blank with anchor seal, a method that always seems to work for me but takes a long time to dry.

And to sneak in another question, do you recall if his slab was cut close to the pith compared to yours? I'm just trying to consider all the variables.

JKJ

Re: Turning Pecan

#12

Ric Taylor

Re: Ric - one more question

Ric Taylor

>Hi John,

Sorry about the typos in my previous response (I was in a rush), and the questions I left unanswered. When typing a note on this system, you can't see the post you are responding to, and my senior mind is.... well .... senior.

I can't say positively how my friend dried his blank, but I do know that he normally leaves his rough-turned blanks laying out to air dry with no special techniques or waxing. When he fresh-cuts his blanks from the log, he usually wraps them in clear plastic and sometimes waxes the ends, but I haven't seen him do anything like that after he has done the rough-turning.

The two platter blanks we made (actually he did the cutting while I did the cheering..... it was his wood) were cut from a crotch section. Both blanks have great flame figure, although his is slightly better (after all, it was his log). I honestly can't remember which blank was closest to the pith. If I had to guess, I would say it was probably his that was closest. The original blanks were probably 22 inches across and 4 inches thick.

I haven't had 100% success with the alcohol drying, but it certainly does improve the odds. I recently had a pecan rough-turned bowl that split wide open after laying on the drying rack in the hot garage for about 6 months. It had also been soaked for probably at least a month.

I'll post a pic of my platter when I get it finished, although it will be awhile. I'm not getting much turning in right now due to an illness in the family, but the platter is probably 80% complete.

Ric