Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

Posts

Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#1

Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

Donna Banfield

>My husband pointed out this sawv dust collection system at PSI for his Christmas list. Problem is, the good deal ends today/tonight.

I'm a little skeptical about the price...is it a good deal, or is this equipment that is really a poor knock-off of the better quality/more expensive ones? I note that there is no rating/review on it, so if anyone else has this one, please offer your opinion...good/bad/etc.


http://www.pennstateind.com/store/TSGUARD.html

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#2

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Donna -- I have never used one like this so I hesitate to comment, but I would suggest you bear in mind that most table saw dust goes downward, rather than upward, as the blade cuts into the wood; thus most table saw dust collectors I have seen are below rather than above.

And I think my preference would be to keep the top of a table saw as uncluttered as possible so you can concentrate purely on moving the wood past the blade without anything else to maneuver around.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#3

Nah...

Peter Teubel

>Tell Dave that Mike and I can design and build one that swings down from the ceiling to do the same thing. That way there is no support arm in the way to the right of the saw. Get him a Festool C12 drill instead (you know...the one YOU always wanted). That way YOU can use it too. ;)

- Pete

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#4

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector

Peter Hyde

>Donna this is in fact a guard with dust collection added. Note the bigger black tubing it is connected to. That in turn is connected to the dust collection system that collects the dust under the saw. This type of unit is used widely in industry and is very effective. The support on the end of the table doesn't interfere with cutting operations as it is beyonf the fence extremities when mounted correctly. Excaliber, Exakta and Beismeyer also make similar but are about double the price. So if you already have a DC system installed and want to incorporate some extra pick up above the blade these work really well.

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#5

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector

gtwilkins

>Donna, we have two overhead guard/dust collector units in our shop and they seldom if ever get moved over the saws. They are a pain in the a__, continually in the way and make it difficult to see the blade.

Plus these are big 4"dia. pipe units units, so there is maximum suck at the blade and I don't think they make that much difference, as was previously stated the best collection is from below.

For me, I wouldn't bother with one, lots of better things to spend money on.

Hope this helps ,Trevor

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#6

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector

Donna Banfield

>Thanks for everyone's response. We already have dust collection below at the base of the saw - a Jet 1.5 hp cannister, and when the new barn is finished, we'll replace that with a Cyclone.

I just questioned whether that price should make me skeptical. The other companies making this set-up are several hundred dollars more. And as everyone on this list already knows about most woodturning/woodworking tools, you get what you pay for.

And Pete, haven't Dave and I abused you and Mike enough with barn building this year? :^)

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#7

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

Sean Troy

>I have the Excalibur and combined with the lower dust port, I get so little dust from the saw, it's a dream. I don't have any problem seeing my cut either so I'm not sure what Trevor is refering to. I suppose we are different heights and that may make the difference in being able to view the cut? The difference in the PSI and Excalibur is how it mounts and the Excalibur swings out of the way when needed. Tube diameter is larger on the Excalibur also if I'm not mistaken. General Tools took over the Excalibur. Worth it in my shop IMHO.


http://www.general.ca/excalibur/pagemach/ang/50_EXBC.html

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector *LINK*

#8

Re: Opinions on PSI table saw dust collector

Donna Banfield

>Thanks, Sean. I appreciate the feedback. I went ahead and ordered the table saw dust collector set-up. What the husband wants...the husband gets in woodworking tools....

O.K. woodturning guys...settle down. ;^)

It's only because I get pretty much what I want when it comes to woodturning tools....and that makes all the difference in the world!!

Plus, I know how lucky I am.