Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

Posts

Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#1

Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

charlie belden

>Once upon a time - you apprenticed to a master. Later it was considered proper that one copied the masters BEFORE developing one's own style.

It use to be that budding artists would go to art museums and draw or paint copies of the masters while looking at the original - sometimes looking VERY closely at the original. The idea was to study the lines and even the brush strokes, as well as the consistency of the medium being used. We're talking details here. And they would often have a notebook and take copious notes about what they thought were the techniques used.

With a hard won repetoire of styles, proportions, lines and strokes, and an understanding of the medium used as well as the tools as a wonderful foundation - THEN all that could be applied to creating original works.

Then folks like Jackson Pollock came along. Now don't get me wrong, his stuff is really interesting to study - up close - preferably looking at an original because prints can't really give you the 3rd dimensions his works have. Hell, some of Picasso's paintings - done mainly with a pallet knife - border on sculpture - with quarter inch relief in places.

The trend seems to have gone away from the balance of concept AND technique - moving towards an emphasis on CONCEPT and SPONTANEITY over technique and execution.

This trend seemed to be spilling over into turning - the "charred" angular block of wood with the Painted Red Hemisphere turned into one of its faces which "graced" the cover of an AAW quarterly magazine being a prime example.

I'm putting together a page or two on a demonstration Graeme Priddle did at our wood turning club. I took notes and a fair number of photos - some while holding a piece in progress as well as a finished version. Now I'm putting together some How It's Done illustrations and am really studying the photos, filling in details from memories of actually seeing and holding some of the pieces, and watching - up close - some of his "carving" techniques (which he does with a all sorts of cutting burs). And there are many "little things" which go into his pieces - which aren't in any way obvious in photos of the finished works.

Now I'm thinking about actually trying to turn and carve a piece like his double intersecting arcs "shield" shaped "Starfish Vessels" just to fill in details of the process which can only be gotten by DOING. Hell, I may even make and try his Wood Vaporizer.

And since I like multi-center turning I'm working on illustrations of a Cindy Drozda three intersecting arcs lidded box. I've actually turned a half dozen after studying my notes and photos from her demo at our club and doing illustrations of the procedure. And now I'm using a primitive CAD program to look at the proportions of one of her pieces - working out where curves start, end, and how the blend into each other, starting with a digital image of the piece. (see attached pic).

In the process of studying these pieces I'm learning a great deal - which I may, or may not ever use again. Then again . . . I guess I'm in the Steve Jobs camp - "If you're going to steal ideas - steal from the best". Actually, I'd rather see it as "Copying is the sincerest form of flattery.".

SO - have YOU really studied a piece you really found interesting, and maybe even "flattered" the maker by maing a copy? If so, got any insights from the experience you'd care to share?

charlie belden


img

Scroll Down To The Starfish Pieces

Re: Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#2

Re: Copying The Masters (long)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Graeme asked me for a trade. He selected one of my pieces. This is a pic of what he sent me. It's one of Graeme's starfish series. I think that I came out on the best end of the deal.

Jealous?

Wally


img

Re: Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#3

Re: Copying The Masters (long)

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Of course there is no way that I would try to copy that!!

Wally

Re: Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Copying The Masters (long)

keith tompkins

>Hi Charlie, By studying successful pieces, and analyzing them, you discover what makes them "tick". Notice the proportions on Cindy's piece...it is no accident that she is a master of form. Also notice how the form flows into the finial; one shape leads up to the next. The things you are learning from studying these pieces will stick with you, stored somewhere in your memory bank...you will draw upon them often. Nothing wrong with emulating someones work, but if you continue on the path you are on, there will be no need.

Re: Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#5

Re: Jealous....

Donna Banfield

>Absolutely!

And because I doubt that Graeme Priddle would want to trade turnings with me.

Re: Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#6

Re: Jealous....

Carole Valentine

>LOL Donna, neither Graeme nor Wally would trade with me either, but we should just keep working on it...maybe someday they will BEG us!

yeah...right... ;)

Re: Copying The Masters (long) *LINK*

#7

Re: Copying The Masters (long)

charlie belden

>Wally:

I think both of you made out in that trade.

Why not have a go at a Starfish? Two sets of centers, two intersecting tapering arcs, a little hollowing around a third center and you've got the form - none of that all that hard. (see attachment).

And the carving isn't like doing a fan shell or involute (?). Edges may not be as sharp ande crisp and the lines as smooth - but that comes with practice and familiarity with the tools and the wood.

A DIY version of Priddle's Wood Vaporization System was posted to an earlier thread so that's doable.

Burning patterns in wood isn't beyond most folks' range of skills - not as neat and tidy as Graeme's, but that also comes with practice.

The designs of the branded areas - well that's a bit trickier - but your Giraff experience should help a lot.

It's kind of fun to try something different. And you never know where that may lead you.

Keith:

It's so easy to chuck up a chunk of wood and start turning away - with no specific or even general idea of what the piece will be so the proportions and curves are searched for - often resulting ultimately in a much smaller piece that may have elements that work but not coherent - no flow. I wing it most of the time - and sometimes the results are nice - and sometimes they ain't. Getting both nice proportions AND nice curves is often a hit or miss proposition.

Looking at finished pieces done by others, it's difficult to see where the curves which make it up - where they start and end and how they flow one into another, or why a profile that doesn't look quite right doesn't work visually. But if you print a piece and get out a french curve and start studying the possible curves - things start becoming more apparent.

While some can "see" the curves and proportions I'm finding that studying nice pieces with a CAD program and trying curves and doing some measuring and calculating ratios is taking some of the mystery out of designs I find pleasing to look at.

I'm hoping that by seeing things like what I'm playing with - that it will get others to start checking out pieces and seeing and understanding things they may have overlooked - and use what they find on a future piece.