Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Steel City Lathe-any good?

Posts

Steel City Lathe-any good?

#1

Steel City Lathe-any good?

Wayne Leach - NW Ontario

>Hi All,

I need a small lathe for my 5th wheel for when I am down south for the winter.

I saw the 10" Steel City VS lathe and wondered if anyone has experience with this before I commit to purchasing it?

Thanks for any info.

Wayne

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#2

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

JohnKyler

>I turn on one for DEMOs, and for the money it is hard to beat.I like the Jet 1014vsi but at twice the cost, the Steel City is a bargain.

I will say the fit and finish is not as nice as the Jet, but again for the price.... It works just fine.

They have a granite bed on the way and should have one to review soon.

John

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#3

Granite Bed Lathe?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#4

JL

Re: Granite Bed Lathe?

JL

>Steel City is going a lot for granite nowadays. They have their granite bed table saw which is a beautiful thing. They also have a granite flywheel on a 14" band saw and a granite fence on one of their jointers. I can see using it on all three. You want something heavy and machined to a close tolerance. Cast iron needs time to season. I have some qualms about having a granite bed lathe though.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#5

Re: Granite Bed Lathe?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Me too. I would be having qualms about using granite anywhere where flex is better than break.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#6

Re: Granite Bed Lathe?

Ken

>I can't comment on the lathe ,as I have never even seen one,but I have delt with there service dept about a warranty on another one of there tools and they are great to deal with.That means a lot to me when buying anything.I have seen them on ebay and just out of curiosity,I looked at there feedback on this lathe (before posting this)and it seems the folks who have bought it really like it.As said before,you can't beat the price.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#7

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Wayne,

Where South do yoy winter? We have kids in Texas and get to the gulf coast for a few weeks every winter.

John

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#8

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Wayne Leach - NW Ontario

>John,

Thanks for the reply. I have a Jet 10" Jet non VS at home and hope that the Steel City vs has as much power as that so I can do the odd bowl to max diameter? Mostly I will do smaller boxes, shakers and things.

I would shy away from Granite until it proves to be of benefit though!

I think I will order one Friday as I am getting tired golfing everyday (never thought I would admit that)and miss playing on the lathe. There is plenty of hardwood around the campground and golf course to keep me busy for a looooong time.

All the best,

Wayne

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#9

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Wayne Leach - NW Ontario

>Hi John,

We spend our winters in Georgia just outside of Americus. Thats about 3 hours drive south of Atlanta.

We tried Texas many years ago and thought it was too windy-but it's not much less here. I think the global weather is changing?

All the best and Happy Thanksgiving,

Wayne

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#10

Re: Granite Bed Lathe?

Wayne Leach - NW Ontario

>Ken,

Thanks for the input-good service is certainly a big bonus. Looking forward to getting back to turning as I have more time in the winter for sure.

Happy Thanksgiving,

Wayne

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#11

Rob Wallace

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Rob Wallace

>Wayne:

To answer your question (...not about granite-bed lathes), the Des Moines Woodturners have one Steel City Lathe and several Jet minis. It was discovered that the #2 Morse taper in the spindle of the Steel City lathe was cut several thousanths out of center, and accessories used in the taper did not run true. The company (Steel City) was contacted about this problem with the spindle, and they sent a replacement spindle. The replacement was slightly better than the original spindle, but was still enough out of true to make it unusable. When the company was contacted again to resolve the problem, and asked what should be done next (return the lathe, await another replacement spindle, etc.), the response was to "Put the lathe under your bench". Not my idea of cheerful company service.

You get what you pay for, and in this case, it can be no further from the truth. I would recommend that you NOT spend good money on a Steel City lathe, even though the "bargain" seems too good to pass up. Should you get into the situation we are in with the Des Moines Woodturners, you will be frustrated, disappointed, and perhaps without a usable lathe.

In my experience, it's hard to beat a Jet mini (either 'standard' or variable speed) for a compromise between value and quality. IMHO, they are better than the Delta Midi (LA200) in overall quality - (I personally own a standard Jet Mini AND a Delta Midi, in addition to a 2 HP Jet 1642) - I do all of my off-site demos and small items on my Jet mini - The Delta Midi gets moderate use (I got a great deal on a brand new, in the box, LA200 for $125, which is the only reason I own it!). You may also want to consider the somewhat larger "new" Jet 1220, which has several improvements over the well-established Mini, including additional swing, spindle lock, carrying handles, etc. but also is heavier if portability is a consideration.

Think twice about the Steel City lathe, and you might be well-served to consider other options.

Happy Thanksgiving!

Rob Wallace

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#12

What do you mean, granite?

Allen Neighbors

>Are you talking about Granite, the stone?

Are you talking about Granite, the coated metal... like the old-type pots and pans?

Just curious. Thanks

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#13

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Bob Ingram

>While you are wintering

Why not come over to Columbus to the Bi-City Woodturners...

December's meeting is coming up soon

We meet on Mondays at a local shop

E-mail me at freedomhouse@cschq.org for more info

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#14

Re: What do you mean, granite?

JohnKyler

>Yes, the stone.

The rep is working on getting one for us to try.

John

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#15

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

JohnKyler

>Re SC I would get it resolved. I have had assembled a lot of tools and they all have trouble in a run of tools once in a while. And the service afterwords is what makes the difference. Steel City has always resolved any problems that either I have had at work or for customers.

I would say that the Regional Rep for SC needs to get involved.

Let me know, I will even track one down if you want to try to get this resolved. I'm in Golden, CO so my rep might not be the one for your area. But I would be happy to get the right one for you.

I have turned pens and bowls on the SC lathe at work and there was no problem with the MT.

John

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#16

Richard Allen

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Richard Allen

>Jet has been making the mini lathe for 10 years and they have sold many thousands of those lathes. That mini lathe is still highly regarded. The best service a tool company can provide is to make tools which don't need service.

Do yourself a favor, get the Jet mini.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#17

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>The Steel City and Jet minis are both equally good lathes, according to Bart,the machinist and mechanic in our club who runs our beginner's turning courses and maintains the fleet of milni lathes the club had amassed over the years. The first time a Steel City milni was shown in Ottawa, at the Ottawa Wood Show (which is on this weekend) Bart was there helping the club set up its display on the Thursday night. He asked the Steel City rep if he could have a close look at the lathe. Next morning, when everyone came in to finish the set-up, there was Bart, with the lathe completely disassembled, measuring everything with his micrometer! The Steel City rep was panicking because the show opened at noon. But Bart had everything back together well before it opened, and the rep sold six lathes on the basis of Bart's recommendation. We cannot get the Jets here anymore, so the Steel City has become "the" small lathe to buy. As for Delta and General -- good lathes if you do not mind ongoing maintenance. Luckily, we have Bart. They are in constant need of repair. Now, they are being used by beginners in a classroom setting, so they get more abuse than one owner would give them. But the Jet and Steel City lathes do not need this level of attention.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

keith tompkins

>I purchased a Rikon 12" midi as a "demo" model for $200.00. I couldn't beat the price! However, the Jet is probably the way to go...it has a proven track record.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#19

JL

Steel City Equipment

JL

>My experience with Steel City has been with my cabinet saw (5 hp industrial) and 8" industrial jointer. I've not had any complaints with either. I have looked at other pieces of Steel City equipment - but more in passing, as I already have most, if not all of my major equipment. I have a friend who bought the SC 16" bandsaw a bit over a year ago. He really likes it. It may take a year or so to get the lathe questions/quality control settled. Steel City does have good customer service and tech reps. They stand behind their products.


img

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#20

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Wayne Leach - NW Ontario

>Rob,

Thanks for the info-gives me more to think about.

I want something inexpensive that I can leave here in my trailer but certainly don,t want to put up with something that does not have accuracy.

Will take more time and get something decent.

Wayne

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#21

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Grant Wilkinson

>Wayne:

Since your last post said that you were still looking, I would strongly advise you to look somewhere other than Jet. The big problem with Jet is that, as a Canadian, you will not be able to get parts or any kind of support from Jet. You can buy one in the US, have it legally shipped to Canada, but Jet won't help you at all if you need parts. I've been through a lot of hassle with my Mini, and if I had to do it again, I would not.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#22

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

JohnKyler

>Rob,

I contacted our rep from Steel City today.

Please give me contact information for someone from your club and I will have him contact them.

My experience with them is far from what you describe and I feel certain this issue should be resolved if you give them and I a chance.

John

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#23

Re: Steel City Equipment

Steven Mellott

>I've used the Steel City VS mini lathe for about 8 months to make pens, bottle stoppers and other small objects. I've been very happy with my purchase, but have never used another mini-lathe, so I can't compare it with the products offered by other companies. For $250, I think it is a good value.

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#24

Rob Wallace

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

Rob Wallace

>Hello John:

Thanks so much for taking the time and effort to do this! I will send the information to you for the guy who has been working on this to you in a PM e-mail. He's the President of the Des Moines AAW chapter (I think he has also been away for Thanksgiving). It would be great to have this problem resolved so we can use the lathe in our turning classes. I have already forwarded him the URL for this WC thread and your e-mail address, and I hope he has received the message OK.

I very much appreciate your personal interest and involvement in trying to get this situation resolved. The vast majority of turners are really outstanding people, and you are a perfect example of one!

Rob Wallace

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

#25

Re: Steel City Lathe-any good?

JohnKyler

>Rob,

I have not had any contact from the person from your club on the lathe.

I have also sent you two emails with my info, did you get them?

If you send me the information for this person I will pass it on to a Steel City Rep. to get this situation resolved.

John