Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

Posts

Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#1

Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi Folks,

I'm back with more problems for you to help me solve. I finally got back to a hollow form that I roughed out of a green piece of poplar about five months ago. It is now pretty dry and I want to finish turning it. I had no trouble turning the green wood (except for the poopy smell of the wood), but am now having lots of trouble with catches when I try to cut the end-grain at the bottom of the vessel.

My first problem involved a major design changed when I accidently cut through the neck of the vessel :-) I guess you can't go too thin with poplar. I got some blowout when the wall was still around 3/16" thick.

Before:


After:


This "design change" was actually a blessing in disguise because it let me see what I was doing inside the vessel and troubleshoot a few things I was having trouble with, particuarly removing the "nub" that formed at the centre of the bottom.

I'm using the Kelton hollowers and the problem I have is that I can not seem to cut the end-grain at the bottom of the vessel at all. I just get a big catch. It's not too bad right at the centre, but as I move towards the outside, particularly at the transition to the side, I always get a big catch.



Any advice other than this is probably too hard a project for a guy with my amount of turning experience?

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#2

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

John K Jordan

>GolfSteve,

In my limited experience with poplar and other soft woods such as spalted soft maple, that seems rather typical. You can cut the end grain cleanly with a sharp gouge but can't get the gouge in there. One thing I've done on boxes and cups and such is soak the wood with sander sealer and let it dry to toughen up the wood before cutting the last. Sometimes, I have to do this more than once if I cut away my toughened wood layer.

But I don't do many hollow forms (save that for the other guy) so someone else may have a better solution.

JKJ

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#3

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

Don at Central Illinois

>I will admit that I haven't tried it, but a hook tool is supposed to be excellent for endgrain where you can't get to it with a gouge. I know there are plenty of different hook tools out there. I know somewhere on this forum is a way to make your own. I just haven't made the time to purchase or make one yet. Good luck.

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#4

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>A lot of turners don't realize the importance of cutting with the grain. If this is an endgrain turning you should be cutting from the center out. I don't know what kind of hollowing tool you're using, but a sharp scraper blade, lightly cutting from center out, will clean up a lot of the tear-out that you're experiencing. When you go against the grain the tool pulls out wood fiber ends creating a torn surface.

Wally

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#5

Just my 2 cents.........

Greg Haugen

>GolfSteve,

Soft grain requires a sharp tool and a gentle touch.

Here are a few tips for end grain hollowing in general;

End grain hollowing the best cut will come from cutting from the center out.

Try to cut on the center line or barely above, too much above will be a little more agressive; below center line - um...really bad things happen.

Hone the tip to create a fresh burr on that Kelton edge. Need a sharp tool. Before the "final pass" I'll hone the tip-if it's "dull" or not. I want the sharpest edge I can have for the final passes.

I'd assume you're using the straight Kelton to get to the bottom. As you cut from the center out tilt the tool in the direction your cutting to about a 45 degree angle. This will create a "slicing" sheering scrape. A cleaner surface as well as less catching possibilities.

One issue sometimes people have is that they don't know when exactly they'll get to the bottom with the tool. So they're sliding the tool in and hit it before they expect to and far too hard. Catch! If this is an issue, when the lathe is off use the straight tool like you would a depth gauge. Pull it back slightly and mark the tool with a marker where the neck touches the tool. Since this is just slightly shallow of the true bottom as you feed the tool in and you've gotten to your mark on the tool you'll know you're almost there. Gentle as it goes the remaining depth.

Hollowing directly on the flat end grain requires a light touch. Too much force and it will grab the tool.

Hope this helps, any other questions just holler.

Greg H.

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#6

Re: This is an ideal application for .....

Jamie D

>...the #5 Hunter tool, a straight shaft that allows the cutter to be turned "anti-clockwise" for shearing the end grain very cleanly. I use it both in my Stewart handle and a Jamieson D rig with stabilized outrigger if needed.

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#7

Re: This is an ideal application for .....

john lucas

>Jamie beat me to it. I think the Hunter tools are perfect for this type of cut. It cuts endgrain very clean

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#8

Steven Antonucci

I use blue tape instead of marker for depth

steve antonucci

>in addition, it helps to drill a depth hole to the final depth and cut until the hole is "gone". (center --> out, like others have said.

Steve

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#9

Re: Just my 2 cents.........

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Thanks Greg, your comments are very helpful.

I am using the straight Kelton scraper for the bottom end-grain.

I've made small end-grain goblets with good success. In that case I was using a gouge not a scraper, and the tool overhang was only 2-3 inches instead of 8-9"

Before I cut off the top of the hollow form, I did have the problem of not knowing exactly when I would encounter the end of the vase as I carefully probed with the gouge.

I experimented a bit with the lathe at slow speed, trying to figure out if angling the scraper would help. I did not have much success.

I did think that things worked slightly better when cutting below centreline, but I was not having much success so I may have mis-led myself.

I'll go back with a freshly sharpened edge, angle the scraper about 45� in the direction of cut, move from the centre out, and will work slightly above the centre line. And, if the planets align, I hopefully will not need to make any more design changes.

Thanks again,

Steven

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#10

Re: This is an ideal application for .....

John K Jordan

>I've found the Hunter tool to be a great help, but it can still tear out grain. I've got a piece of spalted maple on the lathe now that is turned entirely with the Hunter tools, just to see. The end grain in places in the bottom is torn as if I'd used a blunt scraper although I used very light cuts. It depends largely, I'm sure, on the nature of the wood - I think it's hard to say that any one method will work in all cases.

If the Hunter (or ring, termite, or hook) tool doesn't work, consider adding something to the wood. Besides the sander sealer, paste wax often works well. Super glue works the best but it sure takes a lot. I've even used water for small areas.

JKJ

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#11

Re: Just my 2 cents.........

Greg Haugen

>It's hard to find an application that the #5 Hunter tool wouldn't be good at!!! And this is definately one of them.

I love mine!!

Greg H.

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#12

Re: Aahhh Greg, read your post again. There is ...

Jamie D

>... not a clear statement either positive or negative??!!

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#13

Dick Hines

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

Dick Hines

>Don't get your feelings hurt because you cut through the hollow form. If you do enough hollow froms you will cut through a few. It does mess your day up when the top of your form is hanging on your tool and the bottom is spinning in the in the chuck. Sort of sounds like eggs breakig, doesn't it?

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#14

As in "it would be good at it."

Greg Haugen

>

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#15

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

Barry Turner

>Keep going.....its amazing how much difficult stuff you can do and do well........before you come to the realization you don't yet have the skills. Once I sorted all of that out, I kind of regressed for a while. Nice hollow form!

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#16

jim miles

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

Jim Miles

>Design change idea: After you have completed the inside- flatten off the top rim and rebuilt the "neck" with some contrasting color segmented rings. I like the ring or termite tool on end grain. I have one in a 3' long steel bar that does well that far over the tool rest. Ring tool does take a bit of a learning curve to like it.


img

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#17

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I certainly did not get hung up about it. In fact my first response was one of those "crap, I knew that would happen" smiles. This mistake turned out to be a blessing in disguise, because the new, larger opening allowed me to see a few things that I was doing wrong.

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

#18

Re: Problem with catching end-grain in hollow form

robo hippy

>Steve,

I got in late on this one. I was surprised that you are having problems on the transition area rather than the very center. It is the opposite with me. I do find the carbide discs to be better here than the Kelton hollowers. They present a better surface, and a bit more of it when at a shear angle (I use the Eliminator). Do be slightly above center, and a shear angle helps. Another problem might be with the straight Kelton hollower. You might be engaging the side of the tool when you come into the transition area as well as the tip. If you have done this on boxes, you know how that can catch from getting too much steel on the wood at one time.

robo hippy