Chris Krohn------WebKitFormBoundaryAAiMAAGnAAQsAA+
Chris Krohn------WebKitFormBoundaryAAiMAAGnAAQsAA+
Guest
In the market for a bandsaw
Chris Krohn------WebKitFormBoundaryAAiMAAGnAAQsAA+
>Hey all,
I am trying to set up my woodshop, particularly for woodturning. I am contemplating many different brands and sizes. Craftsman 14" 1hp 8" resaw $559, Rikon 14" 13" resaw 1 1/2 hp $800, or the Jet 14 6" resaw $749 1 1/4 hp. I am leaning toward the Rikon because of the hp and the resaw capacity, or the Craftsman because of the price. I plan on doing a significant amount of turning and am tired of trying to cut circles with the chainsaw.
>I've got the 18" Rikon and I've been happy with it. I've used the 14" Rikon and I think that it is a pretty good bandsaw. The smaller Steel City bandsaws are also pretty good. My friend, Mike, has the 16" and he's been very happy with it.
>I've pushed an awful lot of wood through my 14" Delta with riser blocks. Of course, my saw is 10 years old and from the days when Delta's were still made in the USA.
I recently went through the same exercise to replace/complement my 14" Delta with riser. The Delta is great but even with upgraded springs and other parts larger chunks of green wood pushed it's limits, and I cut a lot of that.
Note that for cutting bowl blanks round, the Delta with riser is fine - you can cut up to around 12" thick and with a 3/8" or 1/2" blade it does a fine job and it's a lot cheaper. I'd recommend a spring and tension arm upgrade. However the Delta is not up to cutting a large number of green log sections into turning blanks, especially in harder woods.
After reviewing cost, features, and testimonials I ordered an 18" Rikon and am using it now. With a 3/4" x 3-4TPI or a 1" x 1.5TPI blade it is wonderful for thick green wood - the Delta is no comparison.
Pluses: the quick tension release, great table, gear-driven trunion angle setting, good fence, plenty of power, rack-and-pinion height adjustment, cast-iron handwheels, straight cuts, reasonable price.
Minuses: no foot brake, guide adjustments, tension meter.
One weakness of this saw is the guide adjustment - it uses Carter-type bearings guides. To adjust you loosen a socket screw with a hex key, slide a bearing, then retighten. Micro-adjustable guides would be nice. The lock screw on the lower rear thrust bearing is especially hard to reach, but I made a long 5mm hex key with a handle which took care of that problem.
Like most saws I know of, the tension indicator is not accurate - it measures distance rather than tension. I mounted one blade that had been made about 3/10" too long and the indicator said I was tensioned properly while the blade was still flopping around! This doesn't bother me much since I check tension with a Starrett tension gauge.
Instead of the tapered pin you find on most 14" saws, Rikon uses a bolt with a wing nut to align the table at the slot. The problem is when dealing with this you have to juggle the bolt and washer on top and a spacer and wing nut underneath the table - a pain. I fixed this by supergluing the washer to the head of the bolt and supergluing the spacer to the wingnut. This is much easier with just two parts rather than four.
I don't like the miter gauge that Rikon sells for this saw. The angle scale is no where near accurate. Fortunately it's cheap, slides well, it's easy to modify, and it's better to set angles with a protractor anyway rather than trust the scale on one of these. If doing a lot of precision angle cutting I'd build a sled or buy a good aftermarket device.
Another issue is the table insert - Woodcraft didn't have replacements and I can't find them on line. However, it didn't take long to chuck up and turn a stack of thin plywood disks on my lathe to make a bunch, complete with tapped holes for the adjustment set screws. I like this idea of cheap do-it-yourself throwaway zero-clearance inserts, especially when making gobs of stringy green shavings and cutting off slivers that can get stuck in the wider slot in the stock insert.
If you buy one of these (or any saw for that matter), check the tightness of all the bolts. While setting up, the saw the heavy cast-iron tension handwheel poised above the table fell off and bounced off the toolrest and table and onto the floor! The bolt had loosened - I probably had checked every fastener in the saw but that one. To prevent this from ever happening again I'm going to file a slot on the shaft which will at least catch the wheel if the bolt ever loosens again. A little locktite on that particular bolt wouldn't hurt either.
I initially had what I thought was too much vibration from the saw at the table - the motor, belt, and wheels checked out OK. Finally, a ran across a note in the Iturra book that reminded me to check the footing against the concrete floor. Although I had driving in some wooden wedges between the base and the floor, I made four feet from slices of hardwood and rubber pads and after I slipped them under the edges of the base and that made all the difference - the vibration is gone.
BTW, I did have a big problem with the first saw I got but Rikon sent another one out the next day, directly to my door. The warehouse messed up and accidentally shipped a saw that had been stripped for parts! (Note that the warehouse is an independent company contracted by Rikon.) Imagine my state of mind when after all the waiting, hauling, unloading, unpacking, and setting the saw in place I opened the top door and found it was missing the upper wheel! Then I noticed it had no lower guides. Or trunions. Ack! While trying to get it straightened out with Woodcraft, Rikon discovered the error and called me at home to make it right. I'll bet the warehouse company won't do THAT anymore since this cost them a lot of money.
>Personally, I would get a saw that is designed for 12 inch cutting or more. A 14 inch saw (which for some reason means the throat depth and not the cutting height) with a riser block can do the job, but it is under built and under powered for production work. I have a Laguna 16HD which cuts 16 inches high and has a 4.5 hp motor. I can abuse it, and it still keeps on cutting. It more than paid for itself in about 3 months. It is faster than a chain saw, and safer I think. The blanks are much more consistant and balances, so you save a lot of roughing out time on the lathe. Get the biggest and best you can afford.
>How tall is the Rikon 18"? I think I may be stuck with max of a 14" BS because of the low ceiling in my basement shop. Worse luck for me (even if the Rikon would fit in my shop), like Powermatic and Jet, Rikons still aren't sold in Canada (at least, not under the Rikon label).
Mine is 74" The specs say 76" but they might be counting a lifting eyebolt that can be screwed in. It comes bolted to a pallet maybe 4" tall, but I was still able to move it into my garage with a forklift and I don't have tall doors.