Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Bowl Profile

Posts

Bowl Profile

#1

Bowl Profile

Barry Turner

>I was reading about someone describing the profile of a bowl the other day. It went like this........walls a little thicker at the rim.......thinning along the side.........then thicker again at the base. For the most part, I have always aimed for a uniform wall thickness throughout, with the exception of a little extra thickness in the base. So, am I doing it wrong or what? Thanks.

Re: Bowl Profile

#2

Re: Bowl Profile

Ralph

>That reads like it's Richard Raffan, I know he has described that type of profile in his work

Re: Bowl Profile

#3

Re: Bowl Profile

john lucas

>Barry It's all about the look. Not about how thick or thin anything is. If it looks right and feels right in the hand the it is right. I shoot for something like evenly thick but sometimes you have to leave the rim thicker to make it look right. The same is true for the bottom. Sometimes I will leave the bottom a little thicker to make the bowl steadier.

On green bowls that I think might be a problem I leave the bottom a little thinner so the thickness of the foot equals the side wall thickness. This reduces the chance of checking in the bottom.

Re: Bowl Profile

#4

Re: Bowl Profile

Dick Coers

>Raffan does talk about this in his new book. Often though, he is also talking about beads or other decoration on the rim when talking added thickness there. Talking about added thickness without using numbers is also problematic. Maybe we're only talking a 1/16" more? That would still be a thicker wall.

Re: Bowl Profile

#5

Re: Bowl Profile

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Barry, I've always felt that the appearance of the inside of an open bowl is just as important as that on the outside of the bowl. By changing the inside "profile" you add additional interest to the piece. This, combined with a nicely rounded inside bottom can sometimes greatly improve the overall appearance of the piece.

In my classes I encourage the students to play around with profiles, inside and out....part of the fun of bowl turning.

Wally

Re: Bowl Profile

#6

Re: Bowl Profile

John K Jordan

>Barry,

I've read several "pros" who mentioned the same. As Raffan says, a little thicker at the base and at the rim can give the piece a better feel. It's a subtle thing, but as you move and rotate the bowl you can sense the moment of inertia and feel the difference in balance. Raffan recommends periodically cutting a bowl that "feels great" in half on the bandsaw to analyze the shape. So far, I haven't had the guts to do that.

I often make bowls with the top and bottom thicker than the middle because I like the way it looks and feels with my fingers. The one in the photo thickens rapidly from the rim, thins at the sides, then thickens at the bottom for a smooth curve above the foot. Works for me.

I was watching a DVD by Jimmy Clewes the other day and he said something similar to others: the outside shape is the single most important thing concerning form. The most important thing about the inside is to have a continuous pleasing curve with no unwanted flat spots or inflection points. He pointed out correctly that most people have the biggest problem at the transition between the sides and the bottom. The thickness in that area is not as important as the shape and feel.

The inside can be an entirely different shape than the outside, extreme or subtle, and the eye can be tricked. I have one goblet that is turned quite thick near the bottom but due to the thin edge and the shape of both the inside and out, the wall thickness looks much thinner overall. You can feel the difference, though. I did it that way on purpose since the wood is a lightweight basswood and if it was too thin overall it would blow over in a breeze.

I have another oddly-shaped bowl I did when I first started turning that I think is "successful", whatever that means. It has a thin rim, looks lens-shaped on the outside with very thick walls (a bit like a flying saucer), and thins at the bottom, the inside much smaller and more traditionally bowl-shaped. Since I was a beginner I had some "knowledgeable and experienced" turners either laugh out loud or shake their heads in pity at my obvious ignorance of the rules. Since then I've seen some very similar pieces by well respected turners - almost looks like they copied my design! I'd say do what looks and feels good to you and the heck with what anyone else says is "right".

JKJ


img

Re: Bowl Profile

#7

counter example ... the inside

GaryG in MD

>Barry,

For a bowl of "nearly equal" thickness, what you say is true -- a little extra weight in the rim and base is recommended by many masters.

Per other comments, there is no "rule" that a bowl has to be thin or of nearly-equal thickness.

I've been working on one where I have an outside shape that I like and an inside shape that I like -- they just don't happen to be the same shape. So the bowl could be described as "heavy". I'm ok with that. Here's what I'm talking about. It's silver maple with some curl and some ambrosia and some birds eye and a branch inclusion. The existence of these features is one reason I decided not to hollow the inside out any further. I like it the way it is.

Actually, I'm thinking about putting a translucent green wash on the outside and leaving the inside natural. I'm trying to decide how to handle the rim. Natural? Gold? While? Black? I'm open to suggestions.

...Gary


img

Re: Bowl Profile

#8

the outside... 

GaryG in MD

>


img