Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Best captve hollowing system?

Posts

Best captve hollowing system?

#1

Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>Hi all,

I've been out of the loop for a year and now I want to get myself back into turning and woodworking. I'm in the market for a captive hollowing system and I'm looking for opinions on which to get. I currently have and like my Don Pencil system and also use the Woodcut Proform tool with it but I'm looking to expand to larger projects an would like to try a captive system.

For now I'm not looking for bang for the buck, I'm simply looking for the best system.

I've looked at the articulating arm systems, Kelton, Jamieson, Clark etc and have read Lyn's articles on all of them.

I am kind of leaning towards the Clark specifically for the feature of being able to unlock the bar and change the angle of the cutter because I think that would more closely replicate a non captive system. But I don't know, I'm really undecided on this.

So if you have some time to post your opinion on systems I'll greatly appreciate it.

Thanks

Bill

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#2

Re: Best captve hollowing system? *LINK*

john lucas

>This one is worth looking at.


http://www.monster-wood-tool.com/

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#3

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Bill there a number of really good systems. Your best bet would be to find turners near you with different systems and go try a few.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#4

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>John,

Yes, I've looked at (as in via the internet) Monster, Kobra, Elbo for articulated rigs.

Also Clark, Monster, Jamieson, Kelton and a few other captive gate type systems.

Barbara, yes, trying them out would be the best but I really don't know any turners around here and my work schedule has me out of town mon-fri most weeks so meeting new people is tough. How far is Remlik from Fairfax anyway? ;)

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#5

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You are in Fairfax? I thought the NH after your name meant New Hampshire. I am about 2 1/2 hours from Fairfax. If you follow 17 South you will see Middlesex County, that is where I live. Remlik is near Urbanna.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#6

Re: Best captve hollowing system? *LINK*

Paul Zerjay

>Bill

I really like stubby's laser design. Instead of a dot, its more of a circle, and you expand it, much like a flashlight,to match the shape of your cutter.


http://www.stubbylatheusa.com/cgi-bin/index.py

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#7

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>Barbara,

I live in New Hampshire but I travel to Fairfax like 3 weeks a month for work....hence why I say I'm never home during the week.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#8

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>Paul, STOP pointing me at that site...you'll make me want to trade up my lathe too :)

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#9

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Wow, that is one heck of a commute!

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#10

Re: Best captve hollowing system? *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Hello Bill,

When I was in Australia in 2006, I visited the Vermec factory and was introduced to a number of their tools. I was very impressed with their Ultimate Deep Hollowing System and ordered one when we returned home.

Of the various stabilized hollowing systems, it is by far the easiest to set up when you want to hollow. I also uses a carbide cutter similar to the Hunter Tool and is designed so that you can work on either the right side of the hollow form or the left side.

As far as I know, no one is importing them into the United States at this time, but you can order direct from Vermec's web site.

Incidentally, I own most of the stabilized boring bar systems on the market and they all work very well.


Vermec's Web site

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#11

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Cyril Griesbach

>Bill, I have the Kobra and I'm very happy with it.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#12

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Paul Waddle

>I can see you have them all,but once again,which one is the BEST? The election is over-give us the straight scoop,you can certainly add " in my opinion".

I am still shaky on what the lazer;does it shine through the work when you set the thickness? If you follow the dot,are you making the inside contour same as the out side?? Lastly,is there a U tube or dvd on this type of hollow from turning. Thks very much, and since you have most of the systems,I''accept your word as gospel. pw.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#13

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Jerry from near Lapel In.

>www.youtube.com search for Kobra Deep Hollowing Systems watch video 1 and 2 . This may help.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#14

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>Thanks Jerry, I've already watched Youtube and other sources for Kobra, Monster, Elbo, Clark and I forget which others and that's the problem....they all look good.

Of the Articulated it makes sense to me that Kobra with the shorter arms and extra knuckle would be most natural to operate.

The Clark with its ability to allow for rotation of the cutter when necessary looks great.

The Jamieson and similar look good as well although that style seems the most restrictive of the captured systems.

The Kelton looks less restrictive than the D handle style.

The Vermec is interesting though it seems to lack the ability of the rig to prevent rotation so it would be much like using my Don Pencil except vertical movement is restricted. I'd also like to see more info on bar size with that system.

So, seems I have a lot more research ahead of me :)

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#15

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Texian

>Paul, I set the laser about 1/4" from the cutting edge of whichever tool is in use. The outside of the work piece is already turned to finished size and shape, so when the laser dot reaches the edge of the work, I know that there is 1/4" wall thickness at that point. The goal is to create a uniform wall thickness, and avoid making the inside larger than the outside. Hate when that happens.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#16

Vermec?

john lucas

>I'm not familar with that system.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#18

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

john lucas

>Texian is correct. You do have to adjust the lazar to keep it perpendicular to the wall of the work. If you leave it in one place you end up making some areas too thin and you make a funnel out of the bottom.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#19

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Steven Kubien

>That about sums it up. One thing to know about lasers (at least my Jamieson which I am really happy with) is that you need to adjust it as you are working different areas of the inside. You don't keep the cutter in the same position when working the top, middle or bottom and you need to emember to move the laser at the same time. Simple enough, unless you forget. DAMHIKT

Steve Kubien

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#20

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Paul Waddle

>When the lazer touches.... Does that mean when the lazer touches the out side of the vessel? You then know the wall thickness is the distance you set the lazer from the cutting tool? Sorry to be so thick... pw

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#21

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>Paul,

This video is a good demonstration of using the laser.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8B8HG5tLM04

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#22

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Paul Waddle

>THANK YOU! Now I understand-actually very simple,when the laser is no longer shining on the side of the hollow form,one knows this is the set dimension thickness of the wall.... Those demos sure to clarify... thks,pw.Whoops,not through yet;why would one turn on the other side of the hf? Would you reverse the lathe(wouldn't the chuck come loose) while turning? Or would yu turn the tool upside down(then the cutting pressure would be up? I'm gone...

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#23

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Bill Esposito, NH

>Paul,

While I've never done it, I believe you would reverse the lathe and cut on the other side to get rid of tearout. The chuck or faceplate would need to be locked on...usually accomplished via an included set screw in face plates...not sure about chucks.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#24

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Steve Worcester

>Personally I think it matters greatly what depth (and sometimes width) of vessel you feel, on average, you would be making.

D bar systems (like the Jamieson) will also benefit from a greater diameter bar, as well as greater diameter boring bar. At the same time, if you were to just do smaller vessels, a 3/4" bar may be too large.

I have 3 rigs, all D shaped, and an adjustable gate system to allow mine to use 1" diameter tool, down to my most commonly 1/2" tubing which uses 3/8 bars. Mostly using the McNaughton bars, but have most of them for when I need something just for a few cuts.

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

#25

Re: Best captve hollowing system?

Ed Karch

>Bill

There are at least 200 turners within 20 miles of Fairfax. Drop me a note and I can connect you with any hollowing system user near Fairfax.