Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Posts

suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#1

suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Ken Langenberger

>I want to make quick work out of cutting larger bowl blanks. Confused on what horse power range for a 20 inch bar. I looked at all of the Stihl and Husqvarna choices.Any model recommedation?

Thanks

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#2

I suggest ... *LINK*

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>the Stihl MS 361 for good power and durability. I have one and do not regret my choice. I have cut up large red oak logs and it handled the load well. Check out the link.

Ed


Stihl MS 361

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#3

Re: I suggest ...

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>I also have one of these saws. Excellent piece of equipment and well suited to a 20 inch bar. I run an 18 inch bar on mine, and it cuts through oak like butter. Lots of power.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#4

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw *LINK*

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Ken,

Chainsaws are like lathes. Everyone has their favorites. But, that being said, here is the one I use for most of my bowl work. Plenty of power and has served me well for the last two or three years.

Best wishes,

Dave


My Saw

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#5

I also have the,

Leo Van Der Loo------WebKitFormBoundaryAT7EtOOiupH

>Stihl RS 361, with both a 18 and 24" bar, I love that saw, it's a real workhorse, my son alo has one with a 18" bar, it does everything he needs it for and then some.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#6

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Darryl

>Hi Ken, I also have a Husky and it does what it is called upon to do. Decided on a Husky because of a lack of support in this area for the Sthil. You can only get service for the S from a dealer I am told. The Husky stuff can be serviced by any small engine shop. My 2 cents.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#7

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

John K Jordan

>I have a Stihl 361 also and put a 24" bar on it. I got it only for times when the Stihl 250 with a shorter bar was too small for the job.

I would not like to have the 361 as my only saw. I far prefer the smaller saw since it is lighter, easier to start, easier to handle and control, and I consider it safer, but it's hard to beat the big one at times. I used it once to cut up a 48" white oak for a guy so he could get it out of his yard. The 361 has PLENTY of hp for the bar.

JKJ

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#8

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Barry Irby

>Both Husky and Stihl make great saws. Either of the two mentioned will do what you need and do it well. The deciding factor should be the service. Which one has the best service available near by. Can you get the saw repaired or tuned up or a chain sharpened on your schedule, not so much theirs? Which service shop makes you feel more comfortable when you walk in? (I have a Stihl and like it)

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#9

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Cyril Griesbach

>Ken, I'm not going to argue with any of the suggestions so far but if the Stihl 361 seems like more money than you want to spend then consider the MS 290 Farm Boss from Stihl. I've got two of them with 20" bars and they have done all I've ever asked of them. One is nearly 15 yrs old and has the old designation of M 029 I believe.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#10

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Ken -- I have the Stihl MS390, "top model of the mid-range saws" according to their website, which makes it a step down from the MS361 recommended here by others, which Stihl rates as "professional" with essentially the same specs of bar length, weight, cc's, and horsepower. The 390 does have a decompression button, a big help to me. I very happy with it and hope it's the last saw I ever need.

I'm using Stihl's hi-tech oil and fresh hi-test gas to help keep it going as long as I can.

Our local dealer has all the Stihl stuff on sale today, one day a year, if you can make it to Chestertown MD by 4PM.

Good luck with whatever you get--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#11

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Tommy Holmes

>I've got this same saw and it is a sweet little saw. One reason I chose it was the weight. It weighs eleven pounds but has plenty of power.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#12

Brad Vietje

Orange or Orange and White

Brad Vietje

>

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#13

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Barry Turner

>I have a Stihl 361. It's the low end of Stihl's pro grade saws. It works great for cutting bowl blanks. No comparison to to Poulan, Homelite and McCulloch offerings from Lowe's and Home Depot. I know, I've tried to use them all.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#14

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

Ken Langenberger

>Looks like that still 361 is very popular with wood turners for shure I will check it out and the others. Thanks for the input

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

keith tompkins

>Yep, and for good reason! BTW, Stihl makes their own bars and chains...nobody else does, to my knowledge. They make a billet-bar with removeable nose...sweet! My 028 Super (19 years old, pulls a 20" bar with ease) just won't die so I can buy a new 361!

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#16

New chainsaw story ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>I am still laughing at (with?) the man who asked about chainsaw recommendations, was told of the MS361 by us WC'ers, and he bought one. Then he wrote about his first cut. He was using a log support consisting of two X's and a crosspiece. He put a log on the support, fired up the new saw, and he applied the same force he had used to saw with an old chainsaw and a dull chain. The new saw went right through the log and through his support crosspiece - yep, he sawed it right in half!

I get a laugh every time I think about this. [grin]

Ed

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#17

Re: New chainsaw story ...

Barry Turner

>I told you that 361 was a good saw........

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#18

Re: New chainsaw story ...

John K Jordan

>>...he applied the same force he had used to saw with

>an old chainsaw and a dull chain. The new saw went

>right through the log and through his support crosspiece

I'm glad this turned out to be a humorous story instead of a serious accident report. Not being in constant control of the tip of the saw is a leading cause of kickback.

JKJ

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#19

Re: New chainsaw story ...

Stuart Johnson

>Well it didn't feel unsafe and the tip was not engaged. Yep, it was me.

I had two blocks with landscape timbers to hold the log. The end result was no more than cutting the log in half except the bottom half was the landscape timbers. But you are correct in it could have been a terrible accident waiting to happen. I had a larger saw with way more power than my old Sears piece of junk. I obviously didn't have complete control or I wouldn't have gone through my stand. Since the one surprise cut I think it is much safer because I'm letting the saw do the work and not fighting it.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#20

Re: New chainsaw story ... *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Stuart,

With a name associated with the story I'm even MORE glad it was an anecdote rather than an incident!

For those new to chain saws, what I meant by the tip control comes from strong warnings in some of my books. There have been accidents where the operator cut through one piece only to have the tip touch something else behind. For example, you are limbing a tree and cutting through one limb when the tip accidentally touches another limb that you didn't even see because it was below and behind the first. If the tip touches just wrong, of course, you can get a violent rotational kickback, over in a second but with horrible possible consequences.

I've developed a healthy respect for chain saws and tractors, either of which can maim or kill in an instant. When we moved to this farm I read everything I could find on different ways to get killed on a tractor - you might be surprised by some of them! Same thing for chainsaws, felling, and logging - my current list of ways to get hurt turned out to be far, far more extensive than what I could have ever imagined in the beginning. If I can't imagine it, how could I guard against it? (I lost a good friend a few years ago to a tree accident - he was doing everything right but ran into something that I never imagined possible - sadly, a new one for my list.)

One inexpensive book I found very helpful for those interested in such things is "The Good Woodcutters Guide" by Dave Johnson. Note only does he pound safety into the brain but has loads of good information on sharpening and maintenance (and why not to get into the business of cutting trees for a living!) He describes graphically some accident cases, for example how people have reacted instinctively to a kickback and ended up gutting themselves as the saw rotates around and is pulled down through their chest and stomach. I try to avoid that one.

After reading that book I started wearing chaps and was far more aware of hazards like widowmakers in the woods, coastdown times, and the importance of proper footing and stance. (And soon after I got them, my chaps somehow got a small cut through the outer fabric right at the thigh. Ack.)

One thing I've been thinking of lately is how to design a device that would help cut up short blocks. Your method of using timbers is what I use and I've seen several other good ideas, but imagine something that could hold an irregular chunk or log section securely, then guide the saw through the cut. Not only would the cut be straighter, but it might be safer as well. I devised a clamping board to hold chunks on my bandsaw mill (which is probably the best way to prepare big turning blanks), but more people have chainsaws than sawmills. :) I'm thinking of something like the inexpensive guide that will let a chainsaw cut crude slabs from a log, but modified with turners in mind.

Hey, that Stihl saw is great, isn't it! I don't use mine as much as the smaller one since with shoulder and wrist problems it is a bit heavy, but when I need it it doesn't let me down.

BTW, I watched a neighbor trying to cut a tree once with one of those old piece-of-junk toy saws that probably hadn't been sharpened since it was new. While running the saw he pushed it back and forth like a hand saw trying to get it to cut. I couldn't stand it so I took my saw over and helped. (Good rule - never lend a chainsaw!)

JKJ


The Good Woodcutter's Guide

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#21

Stuart, I share John's ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>concern for your safety and my relating of the story was supposed to be a subtle way of warning the inexperienced of the power of an MS 361. Now that you have had the 361 for awhile, how do you like it?

Ed

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#22

Re: Stuart, I share John's ...

Stuart Johnson

>It is a great saw. Like I said earlier I think it is much safer to use than my older saw. I don't use it that often but when I do I take the time to put on my chaps and eye protection. In my opinion the danger came from not having any idea about the change in power. Sort of like going from a Yugo to a Ford 250. I doubt if I will ever get over the feeling I got from cutting through a Mesquite log and the stand with absolutely no effort.

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#23

Re: New chainsaw story ...

Rich Egan

>John:

I have an upright H-frame bearing press I use to hold logs while I rough them to shape. The hydraulic ram bites down with plenty of pressure, and that log isn't going anywhere. I just have to be careful not to hit the frame with my saw!

Re: suggestion for a new 20 inch chainsaw

#24

Re: New chainsaw story ...

John K Jordan

>Rich,

Do you have a picture of this in operation? (or maybe I can look up "h frame bearing press" for a picture.) I didn't think of using hydraulic clamps - is it hand or power operated?

I imagined something that also constrained or guided the saw. Somewhere (was it here?) I saw a rig made of steel that a guy was using to shave slices off a burl. The saw was fixed in place and rotated around a pivot. But I don't think that particular setup would work too well for turning blanks.

A while back Dick Parr and I cut up a big truckload of turning blanks on the Woodmizer. (picture) This method was nice because the kerf is thin and it's so quick to cut out the pith and end up with perfectly parallel top and bottom.

JKJ


img