Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Posts

Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#1

Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I'm looking for something basic, not too complicated to sharpen, etc.

Ray

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#2

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>My first hollowing tool was a Sorby Multi-tip Shear Scraper. It is a really tool to use to learn the technique. I have several more hollowing tools now, including a couple of the Sorby swanneck tools, 2 different sizes of Kelton Hollowers, and a Don Pencil Scorpion. My favorites are the Keltons, followed by the Sorby Multi-tip.

keithz

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#3

First and last. *LINK*

john lucas

>If I could only have one tool I would buy the John Jordan #1 3/4" hollowing tool. Or for about the same money the 1/2" set if your not going to turn large vessels. John's system is easy to sharpen, nothing to break and well designed. He designed these after 20 years of turning hollow vessels. They aren't fancy and are designed to do the job with minimal effort.

I've been using a homemade version of his tools for years.


http://www.johnjordanwoodturning.com/John_Jordan_Woodturning/Turning_Tools.html

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#4

Re: First and last.

Charles Watson

>I totally agree. John's are excellent and the ones I keep going back to if I'm doing freehand hollowing.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#5

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Carole Valentine

>I use Keltons, but I have not tried the Jordans and they look like they would be perfect. Someday, maybe I will have the opportunity to try them somewhere. The Sorby multi-tip is a "must have" in my tool kit for bowls and semi-enclosed forms but I don't use it for true hollow forms. For the style of hollow forms I do I need something with some curve to it and my openings are generally too small for that tool anyway. I have a Sorby Hollowmaster but rarely use it.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#6

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have a Sorby Hollowmaster but rarely use it....

Chicken....:<))

Wally

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#7

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Cyril Griesbach

>Wally, I appreciate your humor but it could be because Carole's vessels are too small to accept the size of the Sorby.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#8

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Carole Valentine

>The darn thing is just too big for the stuff I do Wally. I got it back when I had just the Jet Mini and dreams of turning bigger than 10" and before I got the big lathe and started turning tiny! LOL I don't have any problem using the Hollowmaster, although I do find it a little grabby compared to my Keltons.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#9

Dick Hines

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Dick Hines

>I use the Kelton tools if I my hollowing small things I have 3 set of knives. I also have the captured rig but it is on loan to a friend.

For the big pieces I do I have a Jamieson system. I like the Jamieson rig better than the Kelton. There is nothing wrong with the Kelton captured rig as far as hollowing goes but the Jamieson is smoother.

Your big decision is how big are you going to be turning. The captures rigs take all the strain off your arms.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#10

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Cyril, I was kidding Carole because she at one time had expressed a fear of using Armbrace hollowing tools.

Wally

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#11

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Carole Valentine

>And a BIG chunk out of your wallet! I guess when my tendonitis gets bad enough, I will have to do it. I used Barb's Jamieson rig when I was there not long ago. It was very smooth and I loved the laser setup but it requires a bigger opening than I like. I don't remember what size we had to open the neck up to but it was more than an inch...seems to me it was an inch and a quarter.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#12

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

arkie

>You might take a look at the elbo tool if you want to stay with small stuff in your old age. I saw it at Richmond and thought it a well thought out system for small stuff. I think it would be adaptable to tools small enough to do your HFs, but you might ask around.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#13

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

robo hippy

>I tried the Sorby multi tip, and got very discouraged. I made a captured system with the 3/16 hss bits in a roung thing where you could change the angles of the cutter to get to the curves. It worked okay, but you had to leave a fairly good sized opening to get that type of cutter into the hole. A friend of mine got the Kelton hollowers, and gave them to me to try out. I loved them. I was using them in the standard Kelton handle for the coring tools with a laser hooked up to it. This worked okay, but I was tired after a few forms. I guess if I worked at it, I could have gotten into shape for it, but I didn't want to do that. The captured systems require so much less effort. I bought the entire set of Kelton hollowers. I had some other hollowing tools that were swan (or goose) necked, so rather than get the Kelton caputred rig, I had another better heavier capured system made. Worked great, and I had the adapters so I could use all my cutters. I got the Monster articulated hollowing system, and had him make me an adapter so I could use my Kelton hollowers in it. I LOVE that tool. I don't really like his cutters as much as I do the Keltons, but the articulates system makes it so easy to hollow. An excellent laser pointer, and finger tip pressure to move the tool. I have also been using the Eliminator (carbide disc) for some end grain pieces. It isn't great for hogging out material, but gives beautiful finish cuts. Haven't tried the Hunter yet. I would prefer them unhandled to fit in my captured system.

robo hippy

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#14

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Stephen Mushinski

>If you are looking for hand held tools then I would also recommend John's tools. The small set would be an excellence starter set allowing 6 to 8 inch depth hollow forms. The keltons are also good but having used both I would only buy John's if I was going to replace them. I use a boring bar system with these also, so you are not wasting your money should you later want to use one of those systems.

The key is the angles and shapes are just what you need to do around the neck area and the body. Plus you just replace the tool bit when needed not have to buy a whole new tool.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#15

Ditto.

Ron in Drums PA

>I too use the kelton hollowers. First few years I used them as hand held tools. Recently I purchased the Monster from Randy and had him set up his rig for me to use the keltons. What an awesome combination for forms under 8" deep.

I highly recommend starting with the keltons and later, when the cash flow allows, to get the Monster.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#16

Thanks everyone !!

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

>I couldn't get back to the responses until just now. I appreciate all the input. Seems like a lot of you like the Keltons while others prefer the John Jordan's. A few use the Sorby's.....Hmmmm.

I checked out Jordan's and I have seen the Sorby's before. Never the Kelton's. I have to give this some thought.

Thanks again everyone.

Ray

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#17

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

Barry Turner

>My first hollowing tool was the Sorby multi-tip. It's a great tool to learn to hollow with. It now comes in a smaller size and in both straight and curved models. It won't work in all situations, but it's a great tool to learn with. The flat on the bottom of the shaft keeps it in the right cutting position.

I also have the 5/8" Keltons. I find them more than a little difficult to sharpen, but they work well. For me, grinding the Kelton's is a white-knuckle experience. Freshly sharpened, Kelton's work very well, though. I use them in a Oneway handle.

I have the small John Jordan's, They work really well and I will probably have to get the larger size at some point. Not only do they work well, but they are also easy to sharpen.

Finally, I have the Sorby Hollowmaster. It's probably my least used hollowing tool. I find it hard to control. It's certainly not my favorite.

I have not had a desire (yet) for any of the captured systems. I feel it's important to learn how to hollow free hand first.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#18

Suggestion

Ron in Drums PA

>

I also have the 5/8" Keltons. I find them more than a little difficult to sharpen, but they work well. For me, grinding the Kelton's is a white-knuckle experience. Freshly sharpened, Kelton's work very well, though. I use them in a Oneway handle.

A few upward strokes with a hone is all you need to sharpen Keltons.

Re: Suggestions for a 1st hollowing tool.

#19

Re: Suggestion

Barry Turner

>The diamond hone never seemed to be enough to get a good edge. I tried the diamond hone first, but could not get a good edge until I broke down and ground the edge. Maybe I was using a diamond hone with grit that was too small? Thanks for the sugestion.