Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

(Another) finish question

Posts

(Another) finish question

#1

(Another) finish question

ILYA ZAVORIN

>I turned a salad bowl from a piece of honey locust and was planning to apply salad bowl finish to it. After I was done turning and sanding, I was blowing dust off of the inside of the bowl and noticed that it was coming through the pores on the other side. Which is what should be expected from honey locust, I guess. My question is this: is salad bowl finish a good idea in this case, or should I use something else? Do I need to apply many more coats than I would to a less porous type of wood? Do I need to do anything else to ensure that I will be able to actually put a salad in this bowl? Thanks much.


img

Re: (Another) finish question

#2

Re: (Another) finish question

GaryG in MD

>Hi Ilya,

I just have to tell you that the mental image of you blowing through the bowl made me laugh. It must have been a bit of a shock. How thin is the wall?

I don't have the answer, but I can't wait to hear them.

Hope to see you at the next meeting for the Keith Holt demo.

...Gary

Re: (Another) finish question

#3

Re: (Another) finish question

John K Jordan

>>...image of you blowing through the bowl

At a recent demo by a guy with a really great name (John Jordan), he forced compressed air into the opening of a soft maple just-hollowed form. I was surprised to see the quantity of water that bubbled through and ran down the outside. He said this method helped dry the inside of the wood quickly and prevent fungal staining.

I don't know about Ilya's porous wood either. Epoxy is fairly impervious but I've never made a salad bowl.

BTW, Ilya, from your picture the wavy bands of latewood pores are characteristic but it seems to have fairly small earlywood pores compared to honeylocust I've seen. Most had several (3-4) pores between each major ray but the pores were much larger - probably just natural variation. Also, the interrupted rays look odd but I'm guessing the surface in the picture was on a slant from the true endgrain. Hey, if you want naturally impervious wood, try black locust! (Or osage orange, white oak - pores solidly plugged with tyloses) If you get time, I'd love to see a picture of the whole bowl. If it's like some of the honeylocust I have the figure can be beautiful.

JKJ

Re: (Another) finish question

#4

Re: (Another) finish question

john lucas

>Almost all wood is porous to some extent but woods like Red Oak and Honey Locust are some of the worst. I would not do anything different than you always do unless you want the piece to hold water. All wood has these straws, or Resin canals. In woods like cherry they are very small, in woods like Walnut and mahagony they are larger and woods like Red Oak and Honey locust are quite large. Like John said you can blow water out of all of these. I have also see John Jordan do this and it's how he keeps the sap wood in cherry and walnut so white. He says the moisture in the wood promotes fungal growth and will darken the sapwood very rapidly if left wet. consequently he blows the moisture out while it's being turned. It's cool to watch. It's also amazing how much moisture is still in the wood after you've turned it to 1/4"

Another consideration is what will the bowl be used for. I would be more worried about food stuff being stuck in the pores of the wood and would use a thicker finish to fill these. If it's a show piece or they will simply use it to put fruit or candy in then just about any finish that is easily cleaned will work.

cutting boards are probably the most abused and they use wax finishes for those but they also aren't supposed have a shiny appearance like we do with most of our bowls. The surface is also frequently cleaned and rewaxed by a good chef.

Re: (Another) finish question

#5

Re: (Another) finish question

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Film-forming finishes will fill and seal the pores after a couple of coats. A seal coat (or two) of shellac or lacquer would also seal the pores and you could use any top coat on top of that.

I'd use a couple of coats of a wipe-on varnish or poly (Waterlox, Salad Bowl Finish, etc., etc.) Even a Danish Oil finish would work.

The one thing you don't want to use is a mineral oil finish.

Re: (Another) finish question

#6

Here's the bowl

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Hi John,

Thanks for the info. Here is the whole bowl, no finish yet.

~4" H X ~11" top diameter, basic "beginner's" shape, nothing fancy


img

Re: (Another) finish question

#7

Re: (Another) finish question

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Brian, thanks for the info. Are shellac and lacquer food safe?

Re: (Another) finish question

#8

Re: Here's the bowl - Neat bowl ILYA

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>ILYA,

I took some Honey Locust chunks from a neighbors tree after it was felled and have been curious as to what it would look like on the inside, how to finish it, etc. You have given me an inside look on what to expect.

Ray

Re: (Another) finish question

#9

JL

Re: (Another) finish question

JL

>Shellac and certain forms of lacquer have been used as food coatings for many years (melts in your mouth, not in your hand).

Anyway, most if not all, finishes are food safe when cured.

Re: (Another) finish question

#10

Re: Here's the bowl

Texian

>Ilya,

That wood is beautiful! It belongs on a display shelf, not covered with salad.

Re: (Another) finish question

#11

Re: Here's the bowl

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Thanks Texian. The wood is truly beautiful. I got really lucky: when I was just getting into bowl turning about 2 yrs ago, my neighbor cut down a large honey locust tree and I got as much wood as I could because I did not have any at that moment. Since then I've collected a lot of free wood from people who wanted to get rid of their trees, but I did not see another honey locust. I guess it's pretty rear here.

As for displaying it... The bowl has developed a couple of long hairline cracks that are noticeable. So the bowl is probably not good enough for a display case, but certainly good enough for a dinner table.

Re: (Another) finish question

#12

JL is right

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The biggest users of shellac are the pharmaceutical and food industries. But shellac is not a durable finish for a bowl that will be used. You need to top coat it with a durable finish like a wipe-on varnish or poly. Be sure to use de-waxed shellac.

All of the modern finishes that are available at the consumer level (i.e. hardware store, etc.) are food safe when fully cured.

Re: (Another) finish question

#13

Re: Your locust bowl drying

GalenV

>ILYA

The only geen wood I have for starting to turn bowls is honey locust.

Every larger bowl like your 11" I rough turn and dry end up with large cracks on two sides of tenon and too deep to turn out. I soak in DNA and then wrap and store in my basement. The only ones that have worked are these smaller 6" to 7 1/2". It could be I do not soak the larger bowls long enough as this wood really holds water and the larger would be rough turned thicker. I do have one drying now that I left in for three days just to see if it will work. I hate waiting just to find the rough turned is no good.

Care to give me your secret?

Galen


img

Re: (Another) finish question

#14

Re: Your locust bowl drying

Texian

>Gaylen,

If your locust is as porous as Ilya's, and wet,you could try something that Micheal Mouse suggested to speed drying. Blow compressed air through the walls to expell excess moisture. Just a thought.

Re: (Another) finish question

#15

Re: Here's the bowl

Carole Valentine

>I'd say that is a darned good "beginners" bowl! Very nice form. The wood is really striking as well.

Re: (Another) finish question

#16

Re: Your locust bowl drying

GaryG in MD

>Galen,

Take a look at Steve Russell's web site -- he has a couple of articles on boiling. He's done thousands and says that saves over 95%.

...Gary

Re: (Another) finish question

#17

Here's a link *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Jim King also uses boiling. He says it is the only thing he found that works for some problem exotic (to us) woods.

JKJ


Steven Russell on boiling

Re: (Another) finish question

#18

Thanks guys

GalenV

>Thanks for the information. I do get Steve Russell's "Lathe Talk" and had read about boiling. Not sure that would go over real well in the rented townhome community that I live in. They are not real pleased at the chain saw running to cut blanks. Some are older than me and I guess I wake them from this daily naps. I'm not there yet!

One larger bowl rough out I did coat with anchorseal and it did better so maybe I just need to slow down the drying of the locust. Also trying to soak in DNA longer to see if that helps.

Would like to get some other type of wood as well.

Re: (Another) finish question

#19

Re: Thanks guys

John K Jordan

>Besides getting an electric chain saw, maybe you can acquire a turkey fryer and boil on the sidewalk outside. They'll think you are fixing supper. You probably know this, but to prevent a serious accident with scalding water don't try to boil a bowl that fits snugly into the container.

I tried an experiment with boiling vs soaking in DNA with some fairly thick roughouts and the boiling seemed to worked better than the soaking with my unscientific sample size of 1 each. It's possible this is because the DNA helps pull water out of the wood but may not change the normal shrinkage, while the heat of boiling can make the wood more plastic and allow it to equilibrate internal forces and perhaps shrink more gracefully. Or something like that, who knows.

I don't read about too many people boiling. Maybe because it's a pain in the process.

JKJ

Re: (Another) finish question

#20

Re: Turkey fryer

GalenV

>Wondered if I could pick up a turkey fryer after someone gets a good scare on Thanksgiving. Somehow a big open flame with a big pot of grease is asking for trouble. I guess the turkey is good if you know what you are doing.

On the chain saw I just cut fast and rake up the evidence the best I can.

I did a lot better living in the country! For Iowa there sure are a lot of city folk yet.

Today I looked at a 10" bowl, 3/4" thick, I soaked for three days in DNA and it has been a week wrapped in paper and I see it already has radial checks. At least not the big cracks I had by tenon and will just wait to see if I can turn them out.

To use the rest I just may try to turn as finished in green and see how it warps and cracks. My bowls just sit and collect dust anyway.

Re: (Another) finish question

#21

Re: Turkey fryer

John K Jordan

>>... a big open flame with a big pot of grease is asking for trouble

While dangerous for those who are mentally challenged, unable to read instructions, and lack reasonable adult attention spans, frying turkey may not be as bad as you think. The flash point of the oil is over 600 deg F. Turkey should be fried at 325-350 F so you have to do something special to start an unwanted fire. To avoid a disaster:

- Don't overheat, use a thermometer.

- Don't knock the thing over.

- Don't fry indoors or on a deck or near the house.

- Don't overfill and cause oil to run down into the flame when the bird is immersed.

- Don't fry a frozen bird and don't immerse quickly - force from the heat can shoot oil out of the carcase.

- Keep fire extinguisher handy.

- Keep children, pets, and drunks away.

But you don't have to wait for an accident - for bowl boiling you can buy one pretty cheaply from Walmart or such, especially after the holidays. Works great for water - I used mine last weekend to boil water for plucking chickens.

JKJ

Re: (Another) finish question

#22

Re: No turkey fryer, but I'll take ham

GalenV

>John

Not much of a turkey guy anyway. I'll take ham. But I do like chicken.

I have not had to pluck a chicken since I was 17 or 18. My aunt could grab a chicken by the head and give it a twist and jerk and pull off their heads. I tried that and they just ran around dizzy till she caught them again. I was demoted to dippin and pluck'n. pew!

Probably a lot safer eat'n back then over store bought today!

And I used a wire hook to pull the hens out of the nesting boxes to gather the eggs. Me and chickens did not get along other than at the table!

Where did those days go?

Re: (Another) finish question

#23

Re: Your locust bowl drying

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Galen,

I do have the cracking problem too. I got the wood in January 07, so it's almost 2 years old. I've stored the logs in my shed and in the basement; they're treated with Anchorseal. Still, in some blanks I have thin hairline cracks. In others I get cracks when I sand on the lathe and I apply too much pressure and the bowl heats up. Which is I think an indication that the blanks haven't properly dried. In yet another case, I bowl that I made about a year ago developed small cracks just recently, so I will have to refinish it. So I am not sure I am doing any better overall in terms of cracking than you. Still learning... I may try boiling a couple of blanks. Good luck! These 4 bowls look very nice by the way. I like the one in the upper left the most.