Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Yet another BowlSaw review

Posts

Yet another BowlSaw review

#1

Steven Antonucci

Yet another BowlSaw review

steve antonucci

>I spoke with Dick regarding my impressions of the tool, and my feedback. Even though it is less that a "strong positive" review, Dick ecouraged me to post it here. Here goes (unedited):

Firstly, I received your BowlSaw via the mail a couple of days ago. It came well packaged and intact. When I opened it, my first thought was "this looks like a prototype". The handle from the garden center with the sticker still on it needs to go, since it cheapens the entire look of the tool. I'd either sell it unhandled or with instructions on how to make one for it.

That aside, I looked in my shop for a small piece of wood that I thought was a good candidate for coring. I settled on a 4.5" x 4" dried cherry bowl blank. Once it was in the chuck, I used a parting tool to create the groove necessary. By the time I was wide enough to insert the tool, I had a 2"x 1.5" core left for my inner bowl. The tool cut much easier than I would have guessed and the core came out with no fanfare. Confidentially, I could have also undercut it with the parting tool and popped it out with finger pressure.

My initial thoughts were that the idea is very good, but the execution is still missing something. If I were you and trying to improve upon this device, I would most likely start with a flat bar stock and bend it to a somewhat curved profile like the conventional tools before brazing the tip or attaching it with screws or something. By making it a flat bar, you'll still have the rigidity in the vertical plane, but a much smaller entry cut. You might also want to look at having the blade attach to the head at less than 90 degrees. I think that both of these things will increase the use of the tool without sacrificing safety or changing the cost to manufacture it too much.

If this is unclear, please let me know and I'll make a drawing and e-mail it to you.

Unfortunately, I don't think this item has a lot of use or will generate a great deal of sales volume. It has limited use in it's current form, and I don't think too many people are looking for something like this.

[End e-mail]

So, like many others have indicated, it does work, and considerably better than I would have guessed. I think my experiment was based upon what I had on hand, directly in front of me, and a larger blank would have yielded a larger core. I was surprised at how quickly the core came out and how little rotational/twisting forces there were, and how easy it was once I had created an entry hole.

Would I buy one? Nope. Does it work as advertised? Yes, and probably better than advertised.

2 cents- may not be much in this ecomomy, but it beats a stick in the eye.

Steven