Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT: Slide Scanners?

Posts

OT: Slide Scanners?

#1

OT: Slide Scanners?

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

I am looking for information on a slide scanner to convert a LOT of slides to digital images. If said slide scanner worked a iMac, that would be even better! If not, we can do it with the PC. I honestly don't even know what types/prices are out there, so am open to all suggestions or ideas. The one thing I have heard is that you get better pictures from a dedicated unit versus one that is also a flatbed scanner.

The number of slides we have to do makes having a commercial company do it for us impractical.

Any ideas?

Thanks!

Mike

I guess this could even be quasi-wood related in that my wife's father took the pictures and mixed in with all those vacation and family pictures are ones of him at work. He worked for a company that manufactured laminate beams for churches, high end houses, etc. So there is a slight wood connection!

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#2

I use the discontinued Dimage Dual IV

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#3

Re: OT: Slide Copier? *LINK*

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Good question Mike, as I am looking for the same thing.

From what I can tell there is an additional option beyond the flatbed scanner and the dedicated slide scanner.

There are also devices that I'll call photo-tubes. The tube is mounted on the threads at the end of an SLR camera lens and it has a bracket to hold the slide on the other end. With back-lighting of your choice (not provided) you can take a (presumably digital) picture of the slide. Some seem to have a 10X lens, while others do not seem to have any optics, only the tube and slide mounting bracket.

The link below is an example of the type of device I am referring to.

These are relatively cheap ~$50 and fast. You just need to mount, snap the picture, and then change to the next slide. I imagine that with a reasonable lens (macro lens perhaps?) and any average DSLR camera that this would cheap and fast. What's not to like about that? I've read that someone averaged less than 20 seconds per slide. Once stored in the camera you can deal with pics as you normally might.

I do not know of any quality comparisons for the various types of devices. I am guessing that this particular device is the type of thing I will try since I have the camera and access to the lenses already.

Henry


Slide copier for Canon DSLR cameras

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#4

Re: OT: Slide Scanners? *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Hello Mike,

I use a Hewlett Packard Photo Smart S20 scanner that will scan slides, negatives, and small photos of up to 4"x5". Resolution for slides is up to 2400 dpi. I believe I purchased mine form Office Depot. I just checked and apparently they are still available. I purchased mine several years ago when people were still sending in slides and photographs with their articles. I still use it occasionally and consider it an important part of my photo handling equipment. It is not the fastest scanner in the world, but it does an excellent job of scanning slides. I think it is just as fast as a flat bed scanner. I don't remember what I paid for it, but it is likely more expensive today than when I purchased it.


More Woodturning Website

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#5

Re: OT: Slide Copier? Quality *LINK*

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Mike:

From the little I have read on the Photo.net forum (linked below) dedicated to scanning, a dedicated film or slide scanner is considered the best quality. It comes at a price that i am not likely to pay - I expect I'd try the slide-copier option for under $100 first.

Henry


Photo.net forum on scanning

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#6

Re: More info needed for the correct

Jamie Donaldson

>....answer, and what do you intend to do with these scans? If for making large prints, then a dedicated scanner with Digital ICE would be the best choice, and they are in the $300 and up(some WAY up!)price range. If just for family records, then a variety of flatbed scanners will do a nice job for under $300.

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#7

Re: More info needed for the correct

bill Crommett

>I recently saw a slide scanner advertised for around $99.99 but I forgot where the add was, but it seemed a bit out of place for a slide scanner. If I find it again, I will post.

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#8

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

John K Jordan

>Depends on your budget. For slides I prefer a dedicated 35mm scanner. I bought a Nikon that does a wonderful job on both slides and color negatives. Unfortunately, it was not cheap (around $1000 if I remember correctly), but it sure does the job. BTW, I bought and returned two other brands of slide scanners before I got the Nikon. I wouldn't waste my time with a flatbed scanner with a slide attachment unless the quality has improved tremendously in the last few years (or if I didn't care much about the quality.)

The direct photo technique is also a pretty good way to go for slides and a lot cheaper. You can even roll your own with a good macro lens (with a flat field and minimal distortion) and a good even backlighting. Note that a lot of mounted slides are not flat so you have to be careful about depth of field.

JKJ

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#9

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

GalenV

>My son still has an HP Scanjet flatbed scanner and I think they still make one in that line with the back light and frame for 35 mm slides.

I used it and it did make GOOD images but when you say you have a lot of slides I will say that it is SLOOOOOOOW. His was over $200 at the time and not sure what they would be today. With luck maybe faster.

At work we paid to have a lot of old job site slides converted and paid a lot of money for the work but when we got them back we found a lot of the images where not clear and never had it done again. I guess they were not scanned at high enough resolution to project for presentations and they claimed they thought they were just for archieval.

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#10

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

Jim Terry

>Mike, I have been using the Canon CanoScan 8800F for a little over a year and have scanned over 1000 slides with excellent results. This is a flatbed scanner with an insert for slides and film that works. It will scan 4 slides at a time at up to 9600 dpi. It came with Adobe Photo Elements 5 and ArcSoft Photo Studio software. Price was about $200 at Best Buy. Jim

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#11

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

DaveG

>I did this a few years back when I was given several box of slide from my childhood days. I used HP flat bed scanned with the slide holder that came with it. It did a good job but what I found out was that many of the slides had a low resolution. The scanners resolution had a higher resolution and dependent on what settings I selected I could count the dots.

I did some research, which I have since forgotten but from the time period of my slides the resolution was in the low 300x something. Anyway looking at a slide blown up on a wall they look good but when they were scanned in not so good.

I still scanned them in to keep safe.

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#12

Resolution issues with cheap scanners

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>You will find that the resolution for those $99.99 scanners is only about 1800 ppi at best. That might be barely enough to create a 4x6 print.

keithz

Re: OT: Slide Scanners?

#13

Thanks!

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

Thank you all for the great information. This will be very helpful.

Thanks!

Mike

With 5000 slides to go through, looks like it will be a long Christmas break in Apex, NC!