Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Posts

Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#1

Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Philip Morris

>I have recently downsized from a Oneway 1640 to a Jet 1220VS. With the Oneway, I turned a lot of larger pieces from green wood. I used a Oneway Stronghold chuck with several sets of jaws.

I am interested in turning smaller scale boxes, hollow forms and maybe a few smaller bowls. I have noticed that the Stonghold seems a little overkill for such (BTW, I already had a 1 x 8 insert for it).

Will its size cause problems or limit my ability to turn smaller?

Should I learn to work around it or downsize it also?

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Richard Allen

>The lathe can esaly handle the Stronghold chuck. The Stronghold chuck is a well made chuck.

The Talon chuck has a particular jaw size which is well suited to making boxes from 2x2 stock. The #2 jaws on the Stronghold can hold round stock from 2x2 stock but just barely. The Talon #2 jaws are perfectly sized to working with 2x2 stock. There are other chucks which work well with 2x2 stock.

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#3

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have a Stronghold chuck and 2 Talon chucks, all with different jaws. For small turnings I much prefer the smaller Talon chucks.

Wally

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#4

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Fog Tanner

>I have a couple of Strongholds with different jaw sets. I can go down to 3/8" and have used them to turn small 3" bolws with a 1" x 1/16" foot. I have also used them for boxes and other small scale projects.

But, these days I use either a Vicmarc VM90 (lever operated) or VM100 (key) for some of the smaller things, like boxes. I still use the Stronghold for the small 2"-4" bowls due to the jaws.

I can't see getting rid of the Stronghold now, but it would not hurt to have a second chuck - you can never have too many. And with all the sales going on now, you can pick up a small chuck at a decent price. I am going the other way, saving up for a VM150 as I still turn some large pieces...

Fog

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#5

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Bill Howatt

>I have both Strongholds and Talons. Even though I have a 20" General I often turn pieces that you could easily do on your new lathe and some much smaller. The Stronghold works fine but there are some cases the Talon is a little less intrusive for some cuts and my hand/wrist.

I would try the Stronghold and if it is a problem I'd get a Talon as well, budget permitting.

I would rather change chucks than jaws.

Bill

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#6

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Philip Morris

>Richard,

I have experienced what you described with the Stronghold just barely able to grab the tenon after rounding a 2 x 2.

I do have the spigot jaws for this chuck, which grab as small as I want to turn. However, when you open them up enough to grab a 1.5 - 2" tenon, the sides of the jaws protrude way beyond the body. Such a situation scares me when working close to the chuck.

I guess I will play with it some and see. My understanding is that if I decide to go smaller none of my jaws will fit, even if I go with a Oneway Talon or Scroll chuck.

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#7

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Ron Hardy

>I don't have an answer about your chuck but what is the status of the Oneway 1640?

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#8

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Philip Morris

>Hi Ron,

Sold it to a friend who was wanting to upsize.

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#9

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Ron Hardy

>Thank you-- I had to ask since that is one of the ones I am considering.

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#10

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Philip Morris

>Ron,

My reason for sale had nothing to do with the lathe (other than the fact that it increased in value). A great machine, just more than I needed.

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#11

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

Rick Allen

>Yes the jaws, keys, spindle insert, everything about the Talon is different from the Stronghold. The Talon operates in the same way as the Stronghold. Same style spline key. Same direction of turning to tighten and loosen the jaws. The Talon will operate and feel very much like a small Stronghold

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

#12

Re: Should I Downsize My Chuck, Too?

robert davis

>i have a stronghold and talon..stronghold can do everything i but i use the talon for smaller stuff. just seems to fit better. had the stronghold before the talon was available.