Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Steussy's BowlSaw Review

Posts

Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#1

Steussy's BowlSaw Review

Ron in Drums PA

>I already own a McNaughton and started using it on a 1236 when everyone was saying that is impossible. I'm willing to try things that people say can't be done. I now own a 3520 and still using the Mcnaughton

Last week Dick made an offer on WC to send out a free BowlSaw to anyone that was interested in giving it a try. I took him up on that offer and received the tool Monday.

Here are my initial views based on using the tool once. It works. I believe the maximum core I can get out of a blank would be about 5" by 2" deep, give or take a couple of 1/8". If you like bowls with large flat bottoms and square sides this tool will give you just that.

I find coring with the McNaughton easier than removing the insides with a bowl gouge. When I core I don't usually don't bother with core smaller than 6". But thats me and not a reflection of any tool.

To start I needed to cut a recess/groove about 5/8" to 3/4" wide and about 2" deep. While this is doable, its more work than coring with a McNaughton. The sawing part of the BowlSaw is pretty easy and goes quickly. One plus is there is no setup on the BowlSaver compared to setting up the McNaughton

The quality of the manufacture, on a scale of 1 to 10, if I was to be kind I would give it a 7. The handle is too short, I still see the spur marks on the end of the handle. It looks like it has a 3/4" bore that goes about 1.5" into the ferrule, then a 1/2" bore goes a little deeper. The shaft on the tool is 3/8". I consider this a major concern.

I feel comfortable in saying that this tool works, but I will also say it is very limited in what it can accomplished. I prefer nicely curved sides. On a McNaughton and on a good day I can get 4 bowls out of a 12" blank, although most times I just get 3 if I used the smallest section. Another nice thing about the McNaughton the blanks come out in the shape I prefer.

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#2

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

Sean Troy

>I'll be trying mine this week after finishing some other projects. If one is to turn the bowls with the verticle edges for some sort of project, the core can also be used as jam chuck material and or waste blocks.

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review *LINK*

Rob Wallace

>Interesting to read your review Ron!

After looking at the tool's structure on-line, and the shape of the bowls that it has the capacity to do, I am not interested in making bowls of this shape (ever), especially when this small; what can really be gained from coring in this manner is questionable. I'll stick to the Mc Naughton system, which works very well and has much more latitude in bowl shape possibilities.

It is assumed that this bowl saw must be used with dry wood blanks only....it doesn't expressly say so in the instructions. I'm only guessing that if it were used on wet wood blanks that there would be a major "clogging action" (...unrelated to dancing!) in the narrow kerf left by the saw blade. Can any one of the testers of this tool confirm that it is only for dry wood blanks? Has anyone used it on wet wood?

I have issues with a right-angled tool being trapped in a revolving bowl blank when (not if) a catch happens. I have seen relatively thick sawsall blades bend quite easily when hitting dense areas of wood; although, in fairness, the Bowl-Saw's blade doees't reciprocate. IT STILL is subject to bending when it hits a knot or other aberrant dense grain, and whether this will force the blade to bind in the kerf of the rotating bowl blank is still up for discussion (or testing). I don't agree at all with Fred Holder's assessment that "there is no danger" in using this tool, simply because catches happen in woodturning. Although there is danger in ALL aspects of woodturning, my first impression is that if the the blade binds at the bottom of the blank in the kerf, the tool, its handle, etc. will be fixed at the outside edge of the bowl and will whip around as the blank rotates, assuming it can get past the toolrest. Not my idea of fun. Having stalled a lathe with a McNaughton coring knife, I can only image what the situation would be if a right angled tool blade gets caught in the bottom of the bowl, since it likely can't be backed out as easily as a coring knife can...

Do any of the testers have experience with the blade binding?

In reading the instructions at the link provided, it says to start cutting the kerf by hand rotation, and then "Jiggle switch on and off to continue the cutting action". Unfortunately my lathe switch does not "jiggle", and I would be reluctant to go about starting and stopping the motor through the variable speed controller and magnetic starter.

I think this is an interesting concept and applaud Mr. Steussy for his creativity. I don't think this tool will be on my "acquire" list any time soon...

Rob Wallace


Bowl Saw Instructions

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#4

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

Richard R. Steussy

>Hi Rob--I understand your concern with my BowlSaw binding and hurting someone. I've had it bind many times, but the "catch" stops the lathe, so there is no danger. I'll agree that the McNaughton system is better, but then it better be for the additional cost. I never work wet wood so I can't tell you how it would perform there. However, I am willing to send you a free copy of this tool for your evaluation. That's how much I believe in it. Whenever you bring out something as new as this is, there is always opposition and I understand why. Nobody wants to change how he does things. It takes an innovator to jump in and find out if there is a better way. Obviously the shape is limited with this tool, but I have been able to get tapered bowls with it by using a small 1/8" Hamlet bowl gouge. That lets me taper the insides of the parent bowl. Then I can match the shape of the "daughter-bowl" later. I'm convinced that you can't judge a tool till you try it. I've bought many, many tools that looked good and proved worthless. So I understand your skepticism. I appreciate your comments. I need feedback on this tool and you gave it to me. Thanks. Dick

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#5

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

John K Jordan

>>I've had it bind many times, but the "catch" stops the lathe, so there is no danger.

Richard,

Just curious, what kind of lathe are you using? Some lathes may not be easy to force to a stop. I use a Jet 1642 and it takes a pretty exciting catch to kick the drive controller out of action.

And what is binding - the shaft or the blade? If it is the blade, a custom blade with a much wider set on the teeth may help. And perhaps a break-away blade?

JKJ

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#6

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

Ron in Drums PA

>The blade on my tool was angled, about 87� to the shaft, does that make the kerf wider than the blade?

Would wiggling the the tool in and out slightly widen the kerf?

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#7

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

john lucas

>I agree John. I don't believe you will stall my Powermatic. I have stalled it but it took a 5/8" bowl gouge with a long handle and a very large cut. You can of course loosen up the belt so it will stall but how many people would actually do that.

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#8

wet wood test

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>I just successfully used Dick's bowl cutter on a 6" piece of mesquite burl. The wood was still fairly wet and I was able to take a nice 4" core out of it. The kerf did clog uo and needed frequent clearing. It took a fair amount of hand/wrist strength to cut out the piece. Maybe this is because of wet wood. It also did want to heat up so again frequent stops.

I will try a piece of wet hackberry this afternoon and report on that also.

I probably wouldn't use this for anything other than a piece of unusual or expensive wood. The core piece is just the right size for a small box or a box lid.

JohnV

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#9

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

Richard R. Steussy

>John--I'm using a Jet Mini Lathe since the 6" BowlSaw only does the 6" size. The jam is only occasionally when you introduce the blade into its kerf at the base of the inner bowl. It never gets off its tool rest. In over 40 sets of bowls it has never even got close to getting away from me. I actually think it is more dangerous to do a bowl without the saw. As for the clogging, I don't do wet wood, but sometimes the extremely hard woods would give me trouble and I'd have to relax the blade to clean the teeth. As to the comment on the Powermatic, my Nova 1644 stalls even when I get a small "catch", so I've never felt threatened by it even when doing 16" bowls. Dick

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review

#10

Rob Wallace

Re: Steussy's BowlSaw Review *LINK*

Rob Wallace

>Hello Richard!

You wrote:

"I never work wet wood so I can't tell you how it would perform there. However, I am willing to send you a free copy of this tool for your evaluation. That's how much I believe in it."

Our turners group is having our next meeting on December 7th, and it's a hands-on meeting where we'll have a number of mini-lathes at the meeting. I'd be happy to bring your BowlSaw to the meeting and have several of our turners of different skill levels put it through the paces. This will give it some exposure and enable some feedback to you on specific 'likes and dislikes'.

I can send you a mailing address, or you can find it at the end of my Gallery web page (see the link below). We'd be able to get back to you with comments and suggestions after our December 7th meeting.....thanks for the offer to test the tool!

Rob Wallace


Rob Wallace's Gallery Page