Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Dust collector can

Posts

Dust collector can

#1

Dust collector can

Philip Duffy

>Will someone give me 2 cents about owning a dust collector with a can on top vise the bag? Is this something I should have done a long time back? Is the noise reduced? I have a Jet and it works but it seems to me the performance could be improved. Thanks for all inputs. Phil

Re: Dust collector can

#2

Re: Dust collector can

arkie

>I've got a 1 1/2 hp Jet with the cannister on top. I bought it several years ago out of concern about the fine dust escaping the 30 micron cloth bag on my previous DC.

It seems much improved in that regard, though I have sealed the cannister to shroud connection with duct tape due to leaks that developed after a couple years of use. The cleaning handles on the cannister seem to work well.

There have been at least a couple design iterations since I bought mine, but would prefer a good cyclone if circumstances permited.

Re: Dust collector can

#3

JL

Re: Dust collector can

JL

>The replacement of the bag with a filter does have advantages - less really fine dust. With a double bagger, you have particles that are less than ~30 microns escaping the bag - until you get enough of a cake built up on the bag sides. Unless you buy something like Highland Hardware's shaker felt bags which supposedly have a ~5 micron size limit (less with caking). Before I graduated to a cyclone, I had a double bagger with the shaker felt bags. It trapped the really fine particles. I have some friends who have the canister types - they really trap the fine particles. IMO, the big difference is cleanup. They just replaced the bottom bags and they were good to go. I had to dump my felt bags on my compost pile or transfer to a plastic bag. IMO, you have less exposure to dust with the canister units.

My $0.02. I wouldn't trade my cyclone in for a canister though!

Re: Dust collector can

#4

Re: Dust collector can

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>I've got the Jet DC-650. When I got it, the only option was the bag on top. About 6 months ago, I switched from the bag to the filter. What a difference - the airflow increased by quite a bit, and it does a much better job of filtering the small dust. I fully recommend it.

Scott

Re: Dust collector can

#5

Re: Dust collector can

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I added one to my Gizzly 2HP aqnd replaced the bottom bag with a plastic bag. The differance is remarkable, Better air flow and much less dust.

Re: Dust collector can

#6

Re: Dust collector can

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Hi Jerome,

Can you elaborate on what do you have for a cyclone? Besides the lathe work, I do a bunch of architectural details and some furniture as well, and I really should have one in place years ago. Better late than never.

Thanks!

Jorge

Re: Dust collector can

#7

JL

Jorge, I've got a Super Dust Gorilla

JL

>2 hp cyclone. It adequately powers my DC system. It's there in the corner, behind one of my bandsaws. If I had to do anything different, I might think about getting a larger barrel - but then again, the sawdust adequately fills a 30 gallon bag - I'm not sure I want to deal with anything heavier.


img

Re: Dust collector can

#8

Thanks

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Jerome

That's a whopper!

Agree, 30 gals of saw dust is heavy enough for me too.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Dust collector can

#9

Re: Dust collector can

Texian

>Phil,

I got the can with my little 1 hp. Jet because of the 2 micron particle claim vs 5 micron for the bag. Have no basis for comparison. Just seemed like a good idea for a relatively few dollars more, knowing that the very fine particles are said to be the most damaging to the lungs. I do some segmenting, and every session at the table saw would cloud the shop air. My DC serves the table saw, 6x48 belt sander, and band saw (one at a time, of course). Still have the box fan w/ filter behind the lathe and extra filter in front of heater/AC unit. Certainly an imperfect scheme for the entire shop, but each component makes a useful contribution.

Bottom line is - get the biggest and best filtration you can reasonably, repeat reasonably, afford.

Re: Dust collector can

#10

Dust collector can

Philip Duffy

>This is what the real value of posting a question is; real answers from The Brotherhood of Woodturners! Thanks to you all! Phil