Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

BowlSaw

Posts

BowlSaw

#1

BowlSaw

Richard R. Steussy

>2 Nested Bowls from 1 Bowl Blank. That is the ad I posted here Nov. 10. 293 views and no responses. Why? Can you give me a feedback on why no one is interested in saving money or making a matching set of bowls? Thanks. Dick

Re: BowlSaw

#2

Steven Antonucci

Honest feedback

steve antonucci

>I'm getting a McNaughton for Christmas.

No doubt that you have a neat little device, but it seems very limited in what it can do. It appears that you do get a second small bowl out of an expensive piece of wood, but I question how many people want to make bowls that size and general shape?

I have cored beforehand with a homemade rig, and safe to say, I stopped doing it when I began turning Northeast species from my local area. There's absolutely no shortage of wood, once you know where to get it. The McNaughton will be used to make cored matched sets, but I don't know what I would be able to do with two small bowls?

If I turned exotics, it might be a different story...

Steve

Re: BowlSaw

#3

Re: Honest feedback

john lucas

>I believe Steve covered it from my point of view. Interesting device and I suppose with the right piece of wood it might be worth saving the middle. My main objection to all the coring devices is that you are limited in the shape you get. The shape you show is not one I generally make. I prefer more sloping sides.

I learned to core from Rude Osolnik many years ago. He used a straight boring bar and cored a cone out. This wastes more wood than your saw but still has the same limitation in that the shapes you can get out of both pieces are extremely limited.

I don't turn expensive or exotic woods and can usually get anything I want for free so I don't see a need to core. If I was turning large ebony chunks you can bet I would be looking at all the coring systems.

Re: BowlSaw

#4

Re: BowlSaw

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>I never saw the ad, and can't find it now. Where was it?

Re: BowlSaw

#5

Re: BowlSaw

Ron in Drums PA

>Richard, would you like me to give an honest review of the tool you sent me?

Re: BowlSaw

#6

Re: Honest feedback

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I too will echo What Steve and John said.

Re: BowlSaw

#7

Re: BowlSaw

Greg Haugen

>I agree with Steve and John. The size of bowls that is made for, are small enough I often times don't core them because by the time they get to that size there is 2-4 bowls bigger and it's just the remaining piece left over. About 4 swipes with a bowl gouge and the bowl is done anyways. The shape that is shown isn't one that I make. An addition, there's a new Mcnaughton that is made for the Mini lathes.

If the wood is free or expensive, to me doesn't matter. The point in coring bowls can be "cost effective" more out of an expensive piece of wood, flat out production-it's alot faster to core three bowls than to be changing out blanks and gouging it, or "ecological" more bowls from a single piece of wood. Can't anything with shavings-I can with bowls. The main issue with the "saw", for me, is the size and shape.

That's my honest feedback.

Greg H.

Re: BowlSaw

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Honest feedback

Brad Vietje

>Me too -- and well said.

I have a McNaughton system, and need to get the smaller knives, so the idea is of interest to me. If a similar bowl saw device can produce more varied shapes, especially if some curved blade design would work from the top (rim) down, it might hold greater appeal.

I like the concept, which is an ingenious design, but those are not shapes I like much. While even local woods can be cored just to save wood, which will become a more and more valuable fuel and natural resource in the near future, I don't have any shortage of wood, and only rarely buy my raw materials. My problem is getting to the wood I have stockpiled before it rots.

Since I'm pretty big into organic gardening, I have endless uses for the huge piles of shavings that come from a day of roughing bowls -- which I haven't had time to do in about 18 months!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: BowlSaw

#9

Re: BowlSaw

JohnKyler

>What I saw looks like it could be a real tricky.

Other systems have rests that keep them from pulling out of you hand.

I dont remember anything with this that might keep from the twist in your hand?

John

Re: BowlSaw

#10

Re: BowlSaw

Richard R. Steussy

>Yes. Either the tool stands on its own or it is useless. Thanks for your frankness. Dick

Re: BowlSaw

#11

Re: BowlSaw

robo hippy

>Richard,

I have all 3 of the coring systems that are out there. Looking at yours, I can't see any advantage it has over the others other than being able to go small, and the Micro system from McNaughton does that, and like others have said, in a shape that I use. For production turning, I wouldn't core one that size. If I have mounted the blank with a face plate, there will be screw holes in it. If I have mounted by drilling a recess, the recess will be very close to the bottom of the core. The main time saver on the coring is on turning the outside of the cores. You already have the basic shape, all you do is touch it up a bit, make the final cut, then reverse to core again. If I am using a very special piece of wood, I would again use the Micro McNaughton. It is more to the shape I use. Interesting idea, but not a tool I am would buy.

robo hippy

Re: BowlSaw

#12

Re: BowlSaw

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Dick,

It's largely a matter of design and aesthetics, regarding what makes a bowl a bowl.

Many beginning turners (maybe the majority, including myself when I was starting out) turn a straight-sided, "doggie-dish" style of bowl with the intention of getting every bit they can out of their block of wood.

If they are bitten by the turning bug and keep going, they sooner or later develop a sense of design awareness. From reading books and magazines, looking at websites, seeing the work of fellow turners and getting design advice from our peers, we find that a bowl shape with a curved profile looks so much nicer--it's more "bowl-shaped". We look back at our early attempts and chuckle, or wince, at our lack of design sense.

Your tool is great for turning straight-sided containers. It is everything you say it is, and a very good product for what it does. And there is a place for that shape of turning, even in the Art world. (OK, I hear the snickers and guffaws from the peanut gallery LOL)

Keep going with your tool, but don't expect to get rich with it!

Re: BowlSaw

#13

Re: BowlSaw

John K Jordan

>I plan on testing it this weekend. It looks sturdy and well made. At first look, I have some ideas for a couple of modification I think would make it more useful.

JKJ