Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Footed Hollow Form Question

Posts

Footed Hollow Form Question

#1

Brad Vietje

Footed Hollow Form Question

Brad Vietje

>Hi All,

I'd like to open a discussion of form related to attached feet on hollow forms.

We've probably all seen discussions about attached lids, collars and finials, but feet don't seem to have inspired as much discussion.

I have a nice piece of Black Cherry burl that I've hollowed right on the pith, as the burl wrapped all the way around a small trunk. Since the pith passed right through the foot, I decided to drill a 3/8" hole right out the bottom, removing the pith, and then turned away all of the foot except a 1" diameter peg (tenon) with the hole running through the center. I sometimes do this when I turn something on the pith, and want it to be able to dry and shrink w/out cracking.

When this is air dry, I plan to mount it between centers and true up the little tenon, and attach a foot in a contrasting wood, and probably a finial on the top, as well. I'm currently thinking of a fairly exotic looking foot, probably both turned and carved, perhaps like those of Jack Fifield.

I've turned contrasting feet for bowls and vases, but never a hollow form, so I don't have a good photo to share, but can post a pic later of the hollow form as it sits. Has anyone got opinions about great vs dumpy form and any pic's to share? I'd like to collect some thinking about what works, and what doesn't, and why.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Jack Fifield Feet *LINK*

Brad Vietje

>I really like the work of Jack Fifield -- first brought to my attention in 500 Wood Bowls. Here's an example of his great work, and a link to more. My Cherry burl HF is similar in shape, about 9" tall, and I would probably go for a shorter foot, maybe one that curves away from the HF more at the top, and carved to leave a number of curved shapes at the top of the foot.

Whatcha think?

Brad


img

Jack Fifield Turnings

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#3

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

john lucas

>Excellent idea, we haven't discussed this. I think a foot or pedestal must be considered very carefully. Many years ago when I was doing segmented work decided to add a foot to a piece. I took it to a symposium. It was critic'd and torn apart. Actually she complimented me on the technical work and finish but said the foot doesn't match the rest of the vessel. When I got home and looked at it more critcally I realized she was right. I put a foot on it without really thinking about the shape and how it relates to the flow of the rest of the piece.

I'm definitely not an expert on this. I have put feet and pedestals on things and sometimes they work and sometimes they look like I added them just to add them. I often wish that I could draw better so I could sketch out designs but in wood this only partly works because you also have to look at the grain and figure in the wood as a design element also.

I'll be interested in what others have to say. I think the feet should follow the form of the piece. You also have to consider how the foot affects the mass of the piece. Does it make it float or does it anchor it to the surface. Does the foot interrupt the flow of the lines or does it chop the lines.

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#4

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

Texian

>Excellent advice from John. Have done a few HF's with pedestals (very nice ones IMHO), and even my wife dislikes them.

If you have a great looking burl in progress, it will benefit from having no additional enhancements. Turn off the small "foot" and plug the hole.

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#5

Steven Antonucci

Just another opportunity to screw something up :-)

steve antonucci

>The more "layers" you add to a piece, the more difficult it is to do it right. Not saying that you shouldn't try to put it on a pedestal, but I'd expect to miss on the first few (dozen) before giving up or getting it right.

I was talking to Michael Mocho over the summer and he describe making "parts" and filling a box with all of these various components. He uses the parts like Legos to assemble ideas before he works on an actual project. If I was going to start putting tops and bottoms on vessels, I'd probably do the same. Whatever you do, the top and bottom must not only match the overall form, but each other as well.

And that is just another chance to mess things up :-)

Good luck and post for us when you get there...

Steve

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#6

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Brad, this is definitely something that can stand conversation. It sounds like John has a lot of good insight on the subject. I really like the simplicity of the example of Jack Fifield's work you show. The flow of the piece is not interupted by the attached foot and kind of completes the curve to the bottom.

I have never added a foot to a piece, but do look at as many as I can from other turners. I am amazed how many I see that just don't work, more than those that do. When the do work, though, they really work well. I don't think there is much middle ground with them.

In my mind, I think that, for a foot to work, it has to be handled kind of like a finial. It should continue the flow of the piece to it's terminus, whether at the table or in the air.

keithz

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Footed Hollow Forms -- Stuart Mortimer?

Brad Vietje

>Hi All,

I guess I should have searched a little more for good pix... While I really like Jack Fifield's work, I was thinking of a more subdued and shorter foot than the PIC attached earlier -- some other shapes are found at his link. I'm thinking more along the lines of footed hollow forms like Stuart Mortimer's, but maybe a little taller with a little carving...

I'll try to post an example for discussion. Thanks to Andi Wolfe for the photo.

Clear skies,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Footed Hollow Forms -- Cindy Drozda?

Brad Vietje

>I also admire Cindy Drozda's work, which often includes both her famous finials, and attached feet, as well.

I would shoot for a beefier foot than Cindy's, which are pretty tiny, but I'd still aim for something fairly light. I'm aiming for something a little less refined and polished, too; maybe a floral-inspired opening to accept the turned Burl HF.

Here's an example of Cindy's very fine work, with apologies for the resolution of the photo, which doesn't do justice to her work.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#9

Brad Vietje

Cherry Burl HF

Brad Vietje

>Here's the rough shape I'm working with. I will probably refine this curve a little to make the "shoulder" a little more flowing, and lower the widest spot a little. This will depend on how it dries, as it's already 1/4" think.

Still green, wet sanded only to 320, and a little oil applied to slow down the drying process...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#10

Re: Footed Hollow Forms -- Cindy Drozda?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>While I admire Cindy's work very much, this one doesn't work for me. The pedestal is too small to support the rest of the piece. If I scroll down so that the pedestal disappears it looks fine. If I scroll up so that only the lower third of the vessel and the pedestal show, I like it.

I've been playing around with finials and pedestals for some time now. I haven't come up with a formula but I've come to the conclusion that it's very difficult to get them right. Especially the pedestals.

Wally

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#11

Re: Footed Hollow Forms -- Cindy Drozda?

john lucas

>While I admire Cindy's work I personally thin the foot is too small. The are terribly tippy. I had to photograph one for American Woodturner and Carl and I neither one wanted to handle it. She had it taped to a larger piece of wood. I don't think you should have to do that. Do you sell it to a customer and then tell them to glue it to the shelf?

To me this is kind of like making Trembleur's. They are really cool to look at but who would want to buy them. They are simply too fragile. I've had several gallery owners tell me that they won't buy fragile work. It's simply not worth the risk to the business to try and display and sell the work.

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Footed Hollow Forms -- Cindy Drozda?

Brad Vietje

>John,

I agree entirely. I felt her feet were a little too delicate, even from a purely aesthetic view, as looking impossibly small to support the shape above it.

I understand the desire to create irony in a piece, by creating a foot that's strong enough to carry the actual weight of the piece, which is much less than the viewer expects, but much too delicate to carry the weight we do expect. Then there's the balance created when the form is sized to carry the volume, or visual "heft" of the piece, and that's where her feet make me uncomfortable. (Actually, I've never met her, and I'll bet her feet are just fine! ;-) I wonder if this tension between the actual and expected is what Cindy is trying to do. I think its legit to aim for some irony or tension in a piece, which makes the viewer stop and look more deeply, and question a few basic assumptions.

I am planning to leave this HF a little thicker than my usual fare. I've had two very delicate HF's damaged in galleries -- one from being picked up and being surprisingly light (and slippery), and it fell on the natural bark edge; and another with a foot that was a little too small, and not stable enough. A little more beef and a little more heft will probably help -- along with a Don't Touch! sign.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#13

museum wax

Rick Allen

>Museum wax is often used to anchor valuable delicate works of art.

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#14

Re: museum wax

john lucas

>I have used museum wax when doing gallery shows because work is often on a pedestal or shelves with crowds of people around. Accidents do happen, but I can't imagine selling a piece to a customer and then telling them they need to use museum wax to keep it from falling over. I've also lost a sale from a customer who though my work might be too tippy. Not that I think you should make work with clunky heavy bottoms. The work needs to look right and I think that includes looking like it's not going to fall over with the slightest breeze. Just my opinion of course and you know how that goes.

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#15

Re: Footed Hollow Forms -- Cindy Drozda?

George Van

>Thank You Wally, you just gave me a new way to evaluate my pieces as well as others. Very simple and very effective!

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

#16

Re: Footed Hollow Form Question

Curt Fuller

>I've always had the idea in my head that when you add a foot, a pedestal, or even a finial it should compliment the piece you're adding it to by contrasting with it in some way. What I mean is if the piece is plain and smooth, the foot would be textured in some way. If the piece is light in color, the foot would be dark, etc. I probably got this idea from seeing some of Keith Burns' and Travis Stinson's boxes on a pedestal. I doubt they invented the idea but they're the ones that influenced me. The examples of Cindy Drozda's work are beautiful and she can make the most beautiful pedestals and finials. But at times the contrast in size between the large vessels and tiny pencil lead thinness of her pedestals makes them seem to fragile. I prefer something that has enough bulk to feel like you can pick it up without breaking it while being delicate enough to have a delicate look.


img