Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

McNaughton Hollowing system

Posts

McNaughton Hollowing system

#1

McNaughton Hollowing system

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I just ordered a McNaughton Hollowing system that will allow me to use my Kelton hollowers on my Jet Mini.

Anyone have any experience with this system they would care to share?

Thanks in advance.

keithz

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#2

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

Paul Waddle

>Is this similar to Lye Jamiison hollow form boring and howllowing? pw

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

Lyle Jamieson

>No,NO No, The Jamieson and Kelton are very different. Every componant is different. The cutters, the laser system and the backrest. You need to use both to see the differences. (The only similarity is they are not hand held, or blind hollow turning.)

Since you purchased the Kelton already, and for any Kelton owners here is one quick tip to try to get it working better. Use parafin wax on all sliding/moving parts...OFTEN!! Lyle

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#4

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

Greg Haugen

>Keith,

Are you talking about the "mini" Mcnaughton bowl coring system that's new and made for the mini lathes or are you talking about the actually Kelton Hollowing rig for hollow forms? You mentioned "Mcnaughton" and "Kelton", yes they're the same company but the terms are used for different tools.

If you're talking about hollowing, I haven't heard "good" things about the Kelton "rig". The only rig I've heard people like on a Mini for "hollowing" is Don Derry's system or Monster Tools' Mini Monster.

Greg

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#5

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

Paul Waddle

>I take it thats an Emphatic NO??? Lighten up Lye,only kidding. Just found out about this type of hollow turning last wk an it really is interesting. Next thing you know,a camera will be placed with the laser,AND a form with a duplicator to follow the contour... Have a happy day,dmt.

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#6

I didn't know it, but a Jamieson is an option too.

Greg Haugen

>In the previous post, I didn't know a Jamieson would work as well.

It's interesting, we hear good and bad things about most systems out there. I've never heard anything negative, not even "neutral" about the Jamiesons.

Greg

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#7

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

robo hippy

>I have all the Kelton/McNaughton hollowing bars/cutters and love them. They work easiest for me. I do prefer switching bars for different cuts to adjusting a larger cutter bit on the end of a bar. Just more efficient to me. I have never tried their bar set up though. I already had a 'D' bar made, so got the adapters. I also have the Monster hollowing system, and love it. I don't particularly like the cutters that come with it, and had an adapter made so I could use the Kelton cutters in it. The Articulated system is so easy to use, and perfect for a mini lathe. I did try hand holding a hollowing tool a few times, and found the captured systems much easier to use. Less manual labor, and the vibration is absorbed by the tool, not you.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#8

Thanks everyone...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>If I find I don't like it after I get it and try it out, I'm not out a great deal as I got cheap. And, if that becomes the case, I'll continue checking out other hollowing setups for my Jet mini.

keithz

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

#9

Re: McNaughton Hollowing system

Joe Flemig

>Keith, Kelton tools are great. I use them a lot. They tend to come from the factory with a too aggressive bevel angle on the cutting edge. Consider grinding them to near 80 degrees with a relief secondary bevel. Also, do not sharpen the tops of the cutting edge - only the bevel side. The cutting steel is a thin laminate on the top of the cutting bar. If you look close you can see this. Just sharpen the bevel face of the tool. Joe