>My 10 yr old computer is running slower and slower plus strange things happen from time to time. I got an email from reg soft about a program called "Registery Mechanic" with a free scan. I ran the scan and of course it found a lot of things it says need "fixing". Does anyone have experience with this or similar programs and is it worth $22.00. I'm not a computer geek and fear running such a program will only make matters worse.
>If your computer is 10 years old, assuming it was a standard off the shelf unit, you can replace it with one four times as powerful for under $300. I'm only suggesting this as an alternative to spending uncounted hours futzing with an old out of date piece of hardware. The bottom line is how much your time is worth to you.
>I have yet to find software that equals restoring a workstation back to it's factory state. If this was a customer's workstation, I would agree with John and replace it.
If you prefer to continue using XP, make sure you order a workstation from Dell or HP that has been rolled back to XP. If you purchase a Vista machine from a box store, it is highly unlikely you will get XP to run on it due to driver incompatibility.
You can also find XP machine deals on tigerdirect.
>To reply to your actual question. Yes I have used Registry Mechanic. Yes it will identify items in the Registry that can usually be safely deleted. I believe it is worth the $$ if the registry is the actual problem. If you use it be certain you go to options and have it set a restore point BEFORE you hit the repair button that way you can go back. You might also go to programs/ accessories/ system tools and run the defrag program. A "big" registry usually is most noticeable when you boot up.
>First check to see how much free space is on your disk drive. XP will slow down when the free disk space drops below 25%. Adding Memory is the one single most improvement. Also scan your macine with a spyware type software. One that has a free demo is super antispyware.com software which will work for 30 days before you need to buy it or delete it.
>It might help but cleaning up the registry to cure performance problems is like viruses, often blamed but usually not the problem.
A 10 year old PC is really past it and a replacement is probably a good idea. Even though you can get boxes for a low cost it is surprising how the cost mounts before you get one out the door.
My experience also says the best thing to do to pick up performance is to reformat the disk and reinstall the OS and the applications you really need. It is not unusual to have a bunch of no longer used junk installed. If you take this route make sure you have good backups of your data and that you know where your installation CDs and any needed serial/license numbers are.
If you are having strange problems, memory (RAM) may be the cause.
PCs assume memory is working properly. There is no parity or error-correction in normal PCs. Memory is easily checked by downloading the free Memtest86+ program from www.memtest.org . Note the .org in the address; the current version is V2.01. It is best to let it run for several passes or better still, overnight.
>Tom, I also have a dinosaur computer and tried the registry fix for $30. As far as I'm concerned the repair served no visible purpose and I am going to get a refund. Not the same company as you mentioned and from past experience, the reinstall of your operating system and getting rid of Symantec or other bloated antivirus software and restore your computer better than the cons and scams that are promoted as restoring your sex drive to that of a sixteen year old and regrowing your hair, etc! Good Luck!!
That was what I was about to write, with conditions. When a computer that used to be fast slows down it is either from too much junk loaded (usually in the background), insufficient physical memory to run certain (possibly bloated) apps or concurrent apps which can cause the OS to swap out to disk, or some type of cycle-stealing "malware".
If newer software is run on older hardware, the higher memory requirements may force more swapping than older versions. The slowdown from swapping can be compounded by the slower access speeds of older disk drives or insufficient swap space. A sign of excessive swapping is disk "thrashing" where the drive access light constantly flickers. You can sometimes minimize the problem by optimizing your pagefile (virtual memory) space. The system should warn you if you are getting low on virtual memory.
Note that optimization experts recommend keeping the initial and max vm size numbers the same. (system, performance options) This prevents problems with the system trying to increase VM size and running into problems on a nearly full or fragmented disk drive. BTW, for speed, I always run the pagefile on a second physical drive separate from the OS.
Look at the task manager in XP and see how much physical memory is available, then at the commit charge numbers to get an idea of the memory usage. Check this just after booting and again after running awhile. You can look at the memory usage, page faults, and VM size columns in the Processes tab to get an idea of which applications are eating memory and swapping.
Know what programs are being loaded and run in the background. I use a little free application called Startup Control to examine and manage such programs. Temporarily disable everything you don't need and see if that helps. I also go through the list of Services for the computer and disable all that are not needed. This can take a be a bit tricky and require some research to avoid causing problems, but can significantly reduce memory useage and increase speed.
if the slowdown is caused by too much junk loaded and not by insufficient swap space AND if you don't want to purchase a new computer, reformatting and reloading the OS is a good option. Assuming no hardware problem, if you reinstall the computer will run exactly as fast as it did when it was new.
HOWEVER, if you then load MS updates and nearly any software written more recently, the computer may just slow down again. Much of the software written today is bloated and inefficient, both in memory usage and execution speed. Since it far is cheaper to write inefficient software, many developers rely on the soaring speeds and memory in the newer machines to hide sloppy programming. Memory is dirt cheap now, so if you do keep the same hardware try adding as much as your motherboard will take.
Did the computer come with another OS and you installed XP later? XP was released in 2001. If you loaded XP on an older machine, it may have been stretching the machine at that time. Two of my primary computers (including this one) are older than that and they are still running great and plenty fast. (I'm running Win2K on both of these.) I am extremely paranoid and careful about what software I install and even more careful about what gets loaded in the background. (Running 3D graphics and video editing software requires squeezing every last drop of efficiency from the computer.)
>Tom, one thing no one has mentioned as a possible culprit is a failing hard drive. When you start getting some bad sectors, it will also really slow things down. If this came on fairly suddenly and your computer is clean...no malware or viruses and is lean on applications (no memory-hog apps like Norton that run on startup)... you should consider this a possibility only because of potential data loss. Back up your data NOW, while you can. You don't mention if you have the original drive in the computer, but 10 years is definitely pushing it. They are delicate mechanical devices and they do wear out. My computer is a 9 year old Dell and I have been through 2 hard drives.
>>My computer is a 9 year old Dell and I have been through 2 hard drives
Hmm. My experience is a quality hard drive should last much longer than an average of 3-4 years. Back in the mid '80s we had problems with the bearings going on Seagate drives, but none since then. The head never touches the platter in operation so spot damage is unlikely unless the drive has a high impact while it's running. For many years I kept between 4 and 7 machines running constantly as part of my 3D graphics work. At one count I had around 20 hard drives going at once. I have not lost a drive on any of my machines since perhaps the late '80s or early '90s.
I've found two things that can cause premature failure: too much heat and too many on-off cycles. On my workstations that are packed with drives and memory I add extra muffin fans blowing directly across the drive. Some cases are sorely lacking when it comes to heat management. I added five extra fans and baffles to my main dual-processor workstation. This should NOT be necessary in a quality consumer machine that hasn't been modified.
The biggest thing (IMHO) which kills drives (and other components) is turning the machine off and on and off and...
--- Every time you cycle power components expand as they warm up then contract as they cool. This can cause microscopic cracks to develop in things like weak silicon or copper traces.
--- Every time the drive powers down the heads contact the platter in the "landing zone" on most drives. (A few years ago IBM has developed a better way but I don't know how widely it is used in current drives.) Although the heads are designed to crash land and take off from this zone, there is still the chance of some wear and tear. Another thing that cycling the power can do is loosen things in sockets like chips and memory.
--- In addition, a machine that stays on and warm tends to inhibit the corrosive effects of normal humidity on tiny contacts.
Over the years I have miraculously repaired many machines by simply reseating all of the chips and connectors! This gave me hero status once when technicians had worked for several days trying to fix a 1/4 million dollar computer system.
My policy: never turn off the computers unless necessary! If there are issues with AC power, run the computer on a good UPS. I've had UPS units fail but can't remember the last time I had a computer failure of any kind. The longest I can remember running one machine without powering it down was about two years. This one has been running for months since my last UPS failure. I went over six months one time without even rebooting!
If concerned about the power usage, check the wattage. Some computers use less than a light bulb. To me, paying for the power is far cheaper than the cost and incredible pain of fixing and restoring the computer. Keeps the room warmer in the winter too!
BTW, I do turn off the monitors. LCDs are not as bad as CRTs, but they are still prone to slowly degrading in brightness and color. I had one expensive ($950) LCD monitor fail in the last year but I took it apart and fixed it - guess how, by reseating the internal connectors!
BTW, the photo below is of the 'dungeon' where I worked from home, perhaps 7-8 years ago. I used KVM switch boxes to access other computers connected to these monitors (still using two of those computers). I later dropped the big CRTs for new LDCs. The extra monitors are primarily for video work. Those on the back wall (not turned on) were cocnected for security cameras so I could see who was coming to the front door during the day. I had a sign on the entry for visitors "This Mess is a Place"
>I never turn off my computer...only the monitor. First one to go was a Seagate, second one was a WD and the third (on another machine) was a 2-month-out-of-warranty Maxtor. I have had a ton of clients lose their hard drives and I tell them never to turn their machine off unless they are going away for a long time or we have a bad storm (even if they have a UPS). With several of them I have taken a Sawzall to the cabinetry they used as a computer station to give the box some air. I don't think the newer hard drives last as long as the older drives. As people demanded more capacity and more speed (at low prices) it seems the life span of drives decreased. I am also wondering if the manufacturers haven't started building in a "dooms day" on every drive!
>Its all in the bearings. On real disk drives, the large platter models, they used better bearings than those found on the current rash of "disposable" drives. The IBM 3380 actually used the same bearing as on some model Mercedes Benz truck.
The first disk drives I worked around were the IBM 2311 and the last of the large platters was the 3390. Some of the models in between were designed to run at 104 degrees - but that was a constant internal temp. As the shops grew larger the only off time was during scheduled maintenace periods or hardware upgrades. Normally the disk drives were up and spinning 24/7 for months on end. During all that time, I have only seen one bearing failure - where the bearing actually was screaming. We were able to copy the volume and have the HDA replaced without loosing anything. But even then it did not sieze up.
The reference that John made to the alternate IBM had to the landing zone was a patented substance they coated the 3350 platters with. The read/write heads would actually rest on the platters when they were powered off. I beleive that was used on the 3340/3344, 3380s and 3390s. Of the PC drives I have taken apart, I never found a coating like that on them, just bare platters like the 2311/2314/3330 (1960s-1970s).
Sadly today, the real disk drives have been replaced with a different type of device that uses arrays of the same cheap disk drives they use in PCs. They have controllers which emulate real disk drive geometry so the operating system thinks it is talking to a real disk drive. They have the same failures as does your PC, the main difference is the controlling hardware had builtin error reporting and when error counts reach a threshold, they will migrate the volume to an "spare", swaps out the logical access path, and then call home to have a CE come out and replace the failing drive. The drives are still junk, but at least they are closer to what they are worth.
I have worked on large IBM mainframes and real operating systems since '66 and it has been an interesting and mostly fun journey. It used to be that you couldn't trust anything that you could pick up or wasn't water cooled. These days, you can't trust anything that isn't freon cooled.
>My main p.c. is a HP lap top. It is usually on from six in the morning until around nine or ten at night. Is it better to power it down or just put it into sleep mode? Also, I've heard about some sort of cooling pad to set under it. Do you know anything about them?
>Laptop is a bit of a different story, the drives are designed to operate powered on all the time, but the drive itself sleeps more and designed for less duty cycle.
I would say though that todays drives are designed far better than their predecessors and for greater than 1,000,000 power on hours.
I thought I was bad that I go through two systems a year, trading up, never had a computer I used for more than a couple of years.
But powering up and down you computer daily will have little effect on the hard drive life. Picking it up and slamming it down, that will kill the hard drive.
>those 2311 packs...and all the rest. I still work with IBM mainframes. My day job is being a Mainframe Support Technician. My team supports more than a hundred systems on 11 IBM z9 and z10 mainframes, and that's just at Corporate. All our DASD is still genned as a 3390. Of course, 3390s are long gone.
>The only time my laptop is turned off is when I reboot it after an update, or windows gets funky. Any other time (at night, while I'm at work, or when traveling), I hibernate it. I've been doing this for 3 1/2 years so far with no problems.