Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT: making two faces parallel

Posts

OT: making two faces parallel

#1

OT: making two faces parallel

ILYA ZAVORIN

>This is mostly off-topic because it's not about turning. It's not completely off-topic since it deals with green wood.

I have a piece of freshly cut walnut (I think). My first inclination is to make something like a tabletop out of it. Since this piece was cut with a chainsaw, the faces are not parallel. This piece is between 3 and 7 inches thick and about 24" wide.

My question is this: can I make the faces parallel with a planer? I was told that generally such tools are not used on green wood, but maybe there are exceptions? Would you recommend any other way?

Thanks much.


img

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#2

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

john lucas

>I don't believe I would use a planer. I would use the chainsaw. You can cut away what you can and then use the bottom of the chain to sort of whittle away some more to get it close to level. Ideally a 3" angle grinder with 24 grit paper or an Arbortec blade would be safer and get you much closer to flat. If your careful and check it often with a straight edge you can get really close to flat.

After that I would go to the scrub plane and other hand held planes. If you don't have that option a belt sander with a lot of care can get you quite flat. The green wood will clog the belt but I've found that a file cleaning wire brush will clean the belts along with a crepe sandpaper cleaning pad.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#3

Steven Antonucci

Flat or parallel?

steve antonucci

>Since you indicate that the wood is not only thick but green as well, I don't know that you have much of a chance of getting it flat and parallel for any long term project. In addition, the stump has numerous piths that are likely to crack and split as they dry and shrink. I wouldn't kill myself getting it "perfect".

That said, I do agree with John that I would start with a chainsaw to get it close. I've seen folks who REALLY REALLY wanted something dead flat use a router with a large faceplate to level one side between beams, but I'm guessing that might take hours to get it all done...

I'd be happy with close enough here...

Steve

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#4

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Thanks John. Things are rarely as simple as they appear at the first glance. ;-) I'll give it a try.

Another question: Before or after I make it parallel, how can I prevent checking while it dries? If this were a piece for turning, I would treat it with Anchorseal, but this is different. This piece is too big for boiling. Can I soak it with something? It's not that thick and it's end-grain, so I may be able to completely fill the pores.

Thanks.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#5

JL

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

JL

>John's suggestion of a 4 1/2" angle grinder with a 24 grit disk does work somewhat - but you will clog your paper like there's no tomorrow. Some different things to try:

A router carriage with a big bowl bit. This is a mostly flat bit with up curved wings. It is good for smoothing large surfaces.

A smoothing plane with a toothed blade - works great especially with a #4 or a #4 1/2.

You can try with a chain saw if you make a jig to hold your material and a slot for your blade to ride in.

Your piece will probably crack. I've had some luck in preventing the cracking with Poly Vinyl Alcohol in solution. I think I was using a molecular weight of 5000 or so. It really interferes with finishing a piece afterward though.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#6

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>If you need the two sides parallel, I'd rough down one side with a chainsaw and finish off the best side (or both sides) with my Makita 3 hp plunge router on rails, riding on another set of rails (2 x 4s)--using the biggest, sharpest bit available.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#7

Re: OT: Power Plane

Steve in NC

>I have had success using a portable power plane for similar efforts. I have a 6" Makita portable plane. Not sure if they are still made, mine is 20 years old.

I used the plane to get on side flat and then scribed a line around the perimiter to mark the other side. Worked slow with the plane until flat.

That said, I also feel it is likely to check and split as it dries.

Steve

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#8

That's what I'd do.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>A router and rails is probably the best method for flattening the piece, especially since it is all end grain.

Power planes don't work very well on end grain, even on green wood. You'd probably spend a day sanding away the damage caused by the plane. A hand plane will give a smoother cut, especially if you skew the plane so you are doing more of a shearing cut. Still, I'd expect to do a lot of sanding.

Soaking the piece in PEG 1000 would minimize the cracking. But PEG causes problems with many finishes. (I've used epoxy as the finish.) Craft Supplies used to carry PEG, but I thought I saw it in the close-out section a while ago.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#9

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

John K Jordan

>Do you know anyone close with a bandsaw mill? I've cut plenty of small pieces like that, usually the other direction for bowl blanks, but once you get it clamped to some boards and put on the mill it should cut without problems. You can make one cut, then flip it over and the second cut will be perfectly parallel to the first.

JKJ

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#10

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

bill Crommett

>I have preserved 12 inch diameter Oak slabs with PEG 1000 and used a wax finish with good results. The secret to PEG 1000 is the timing. Too little time in the PEG bath and the slab will check. Too much time and the piece will not be able to hold a good finish. See the interview with Moulthrop on the link from a couple of days ago.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#11

Re: Flat or parallel?

john lucas

>The router works perfectly. I did that many years ago. I had forgotten about that technique. It works very fast as well. You build a frame for the router that has long extensions. Set this on another frame that surrounds the wood. Use a bit about 3/4" in diameter. If you have a plunge router you can simply plunge the bit a little bit. If not you have to move the frame.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#12

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Bill, where can you buy it? When I did a search on the web, I found a lot of links of the type "Miralax-Polyethylene Glycol Laxative Formula", but is this stool softener really what I need? ;-) Thanks.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#13

JL

PEG is PEG

JL

>no matter where you get it - but it may be pricier in this form. Like the poly vinyl alcohol, it may cause finish problems.

You might see if there is a "house brand" version (such as CVS, Rite Aid or whatever your local pharmacy is). Do NOT use ethylene glycol antifreeze. You want a polyethylene glycol.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#14

You want PEG 1000

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The stuff used to stablize wood is PEG 1000. The 1000 is the average molecular weight of the polymer. It is a waxy material and moderately hydroscopic (likes to absorb water) which causes problems with most finishes.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#15

Stabilizing the wood

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Pentacryl seems to have replaced PEG-1000 for stabilizing wood. It is available from Woodcraft, Craft Supplies, etc.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#16

Re: Stabilizing the wood

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Thanks Brian. DO you know if it has the same issues as PEG with application of finishes?

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#17

Re: Stabilizing the wood

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I'm not aware of any finishing problems with Pentacryl, but it has been 5 or 6 years since I tested it. I probably wiped down the surface with water or mineral spirits first. I used a wipe-on oil finish (probably Formby's Tung Oil). I did a with and without test on the two halves of a birch crotch. The Pentacryl greatly reduced the amount of wood movement but the wood lost much of its chatoyance.

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#18

Re: Stabilizing the wood

John K Jordan

>I talked to a wonderful woodturner last week who said he treats all of this bowls this way. If I remember correctly, he soaks for 6 months or so. His finishes are great.

JKJ

Re: OT: making two faces parallel

#19

Re: Flat or parallel?

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Years ago, my first woodworking project was a work bench, the top of which was made up from a large glue -up of hard maple end grain boards. And I actually did construct a big rig from I beams with a router on a sled that rode along the wood surface. It worked well -- but by no means was it good enough. So I had to resort to much sanding, planing and scraping anyway. Part of the problem was that I was really a beginner and didn't know how to construct the fixture very well. Today, I think I would be much more careful about choosing the materials with more stiffness and lining things up more carefully. It's not the worst idea if you don't have access to a professional with the right equipment.