hunter tool vs eliminator
joe zarnitz
>are there any noteworthy differences between these two tools---tks,joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
hunter tool vs eliminator
joe zarnitz
>are there any noteworthy differences between these two tools---tks,joe
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
ponch
>I hope the hunter tool, I just ordred one today!
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
Mike Jones, Redding, CA
>Joe, I think the most noteworthy difference is in the shaft. Eliminator offers a heavier and longer shaft which allows controlled cuts deeper into your turning.
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
Greg Haugen
>Hunter provides a lot more options in tools. Sizes, and shapes, and continues to develop new tools to add.
The Eliminator has "flats" on the shaft for a given angle, that's fine and dandy but I don't think one angle is the "magical" angle for all cuts on all woods, and doing something different could be a little more difficult compared to a full round shaft to work with all angles.
Also, Mike Hunter is one of the nicest guys you could ever meet. Service after the sale is a big plus for the Hunter tools.
I do not work for Hunter Tools or get anything from them. They make great tools and treat people right.
Just my 2 cents...........
Greg H.
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
Mike Jones, Redding, CA
>I have no vested interest in either tool or the company that sells them. Joe's question..."is there a noteworthy differnce between them" and I believe the answer would be "the shaft".
Now, as has been discussed on this forum in the past, I'd like to lay to rest the myth that the flats on the Eliminator shaft will somehow interfere or restrict the presentation of angle of cutter to wood. The Eliminator shaft is as round (on the bottom) as the Hunter, and can be rolled on the tool rest in precisely the same way as you might with any round shafted tool.
Mike Hunter might make a custom tool the length and diameter to match that of the Eliminator, and in that case then I would say the most noteworthy difference might be just the price.
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
Michael Stafford
>I have not used the Eliminator so I cannot say if there is a difference between it and the Hunter Tools. As Greg said, Mike Hunter makes a complete line of tools for a variety of applications. I have most of them and use them in almost every box project I turn. I find the Hunter swan necks to be highly effective in creating smooth undercuts in my boxes with undercut bodies. I have a #1 swan neck which is a sweet little tool that will clean up any tear out in undercuts that might be left in my boxes. Mike turned the handle for this one himself and it is one sweet little tool.
Mike has also created a #5 tool which is a 5/8" shaft tapering in the last three inches to a #3 cutter which is 3/8" in diameter. This is a cutting machine. It extends the reach over the tool rest and has the mass and heft to remove wood in a hurry without any chatter.
Recently I was deep hollowing some hard maple with a lot of figure. Long strand poured out of the body of the box with this tool and it was hypnotic to watch the effortless cuts that were being made. If there is a problem with the Hunter it is how easy it is to remove too much wood.
I have no financial interest in Hunter Tools. I have been fortunate enough to help Mike test some of his tools and have been using them in one form or another for almost a year now. I like them. I use them.
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator *LINK*
Fred Holder
>I suppose since I wrote review articles on both the Hunter Tool by Mike Hunter and the Eliminator Tool by Jack McDaniels it is appropriate for me to make a few comments. Both tools are superb. Why? Because they both use the same very sharp carbide cutter.
The Eliminator tool is especially easy for beginning woodturners to use, because of the flats that help one to apply the tool at a 45 degree angle, which is where it likes to cut best. I am a friend of Jack McDaniels and appreciate what he is trying to do to bring tools that will work for inexperienced as well as experienced turners.
I have been very pleased in working with Mike Hunter, as several have said he also is working to provide tools for every woodturning need. I personally commend both of them for bringing these great tools to the woodturning community.
Their tools greatest work is on end grain hollowing, but they will also turn complete bowls and I've done that when testing them. I personally use both tools interchangeably, but I do like the small Eliminator tool with the 1/4" or smaller cutter, for small boxes it is very hard to beat.
You will not be wasting your money if you purchase either the Hunter tool or the Eliminator. They are both great tools.
More Woodturning Website
Re: Wait a minute here Mike, are there ......
Jamie Donaldson
>....flats on the bottom of the Eliminator shaft or not? Your contradictory statement doesn't make that clear to those of us who haven't seen or used the tool. I personally wouldn't want any flats that interfere with my rolling of the shaft to find the "sweet spot" while cutting.
Re: Wait a minute here Mike, are there ......
Mike Jones, Redding, CA
>>>>".........flats on the bottom of the Eliminator shaft or not?"<<<
Jamie, the flats are milled in such a way that the bottom of the tool shaft is round, while the sides have "flats" that extend from near the bottom to approximately the mid-point of the shaft diameter.
A technical writer could describe this better than I, but in the meantime, please take my word for it...I roll my Eliminator over the tool rest with the same ease that I would roll a gouge until I am all the way over to 45 deg. at which time the "flat" stops the roll.
That said, once you have worked with it for an hour or so, you find that the sweet spot is most often perfectly aligned with those flats, (45 deg.) and so the NEED to roll is almost a moot point. I say almost, because I know that I do roll it in certain circumstances, and typically use the cutter in the horizontal position to trim the nubbin off the very bottom.
Those milled flats can be helful, especially when turning deep and blind, because there is no guessing about the angle of your cutter way down in there.
Maybe one of the photographers here could to take a picture that shows the bottom better than the pics in the catalogs.
Re: Wait a minute here Mike, are there ......
John K Jordan
>>...because there is no guessing about the angle of your cutter way down in there.
To address this with the Hunter tools, I draw a line down the top of the tool shaft so I can better judge the angle when the cutter is hidden.
JKJ
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
Barry Elder
>I do not own either of the brands mentioned but the difference appears to be:
1. Some people prefer the Eliminator tool
2. Some people prefer the Hunter tool
3. Some people like both equally
4. Some people don't like either
quite profound - are you a politician? :)
John K Jordan
>
Re: hunter tool vs eliminator
Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan
>And some people don't care. . .