>I'm considering getting a Hunter and wondered which one seems most useful. I have a #1 for my Jamieson, but think a handled tool may actually be more useful. My tendency is to go for the bigger #4 with more reach. What is the opinion of those who have tried them (John Lucas)?? TIA
>In supported systems smaller is better because of the efficiency. The larger the cutter the more aggressive it becomes and it is hard to handle dangling out over the tool rest with hand held tools. It wants to take too much wood at a time. Smaller is better.
BUT the smaller cutters came with smaller shafts in hand held tools. Soooo the shaft size now limits the deapth you can hollow without vibration. Its a no-win situation. Jamieson has now a reverse angle carbide cutter assembly for the advanced turner that wants to use the tool as John Lucas showed, with the bevel support, but using the supported systems. Now we can go both directions to take advantage of grain orientation.
>I somehow "accidentally" bought six Hunter tools. (OK, I admit it, I'm a tool junkie.) They are the first tools I reach for for many cuts.
As Greg mentioned, the best to use depends on what you want to turn.
My hands-down favorite for larger things, inside and out, end and side grain: a 3/8" cutter on a thick 5/8" shaft which tapers down to 3/8". The mass and rigidity of the heavy shaft mounted in a large Monster handle is wonderful to work with - no vibration even at extended overreach. This tool is the answer to the "small cutter, small shaft, increased vibration" issue. I don't see this on Mike's web site but you might call and ask about availability.
My next favorites are the tiny 1/4" cutters on the straight and swan neck shafts. I use these to reach into small boxes, ornaments, and closed lips on bowls. The shaft is only 1/4" so you have to be careful to minimize the overhang from the tool rest or you'll get significant vibration. For these smaller tools, I used set-screw collets to make short handles with hollow centers so I can sink most of the shaft into the handle which helps reduce vibration.
I have one of the tools with a 1/2" cutter but I don't use it much. It will make a smoother cut but can make a more dramatic catch if you get too aggressive. I prefer the smaller cutters which leave a smooth surface with more small ridges in my inexpert hands, then clean up the ridges with a teardrop or shear scraper.
I would recommend buying them without handles and making or purchasing quality handles.
>I have all of the Hunter Tools except for a large swan neck that is in developement. And the #5 with the 5/8" shaft and #3 cutter is hard to beat for a variety of uses.
Of course I love the #3 swan necks for undercut boxes.
>....tools into my demo routines, and after using the #5 and #3 for the last 3 months I have yet to rotate the 3/8" cutters. Anyone who says they have a tool that never needs sharpening sets off my BS alarm, but these may become the exceptions! I mostly use the larger #5 for hogging out the bottoms and sides, then the #3 bent tool for undercutting the rolled rims where no other tool goes so well. Sweeeeeeet tools!
>Thanks for all the advice. It sounds like the #5 may be the tool to get for me. I just checked out Mike's website and a couple of the normal retailers. No one is showing the #5, however a #6 is showing on the Craft supplies. I liked the concept of a larger shaft coupled with a smaller cutter. Anyone know where to get a #5. Probably should just call Mike.
>If i could only have one Hunter tool i would go with the #5, it is very versatile. However i must confess i am a good friend of Mikes and i have the sweet job of testing all of his tools. I probably have more Hunter tools than Mike does and i am not giving up any of them. About the only time i have had to rotate a cutter is because i dropped the tool and of course it landed tip down.
>Bob, have you had any chipping otherwise? I've got chips in the sharp edges some of two of my cutters and I haven't dropped them. I don't even let the cutters touch anything but wood (as far as I know) and try to keep plastic protectors on the ends but I still have chips. Any advice? (besides keep extra cutters on hand :)
I have not noticed any chipping at all, any issues i have had with cutters were all my fault, i did learn early on how brittle carbide really is and i have since then put covers over the cutters. I found that using fuel line hose and/or heater hose from auto stores works very well. I cut into 2-3 inch lenghts and slide it over cutter and onto shafts.
>....with a bowl gouge, but some shapes require cutting in places that the gouge cannot reach. This includes forms with smaller openings and rolled rims that the Hunter bent tools accomplish with ease.
>I have been using Mikes carbide cutters for more than a year now and never have chipped one. They are very hard and therefore brittle and susceptible to chipping. I fine that the culpret is usually storage and the tip banging other tools while not in use.
>Mike I like the #4 a lot and it is my most used tool of that series but I now have a #5 and I'm starting to use it a lot. It is the same cutter as the #4 but a thicker shaft. The downside is I will probably put it in a bigger handle so it won't be as convenient for small boxes. I find the #4 with the wooden handle to be a really good balance for these size boxes and other work in general.