Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Posts

recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#1

recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Dick McNeill

>About to buy a hollowing system, hoped I could get some recommendations or a consensus of which would be the best.I have a Jet 16-42 lathe with a one inch tool rest. I would like to do segmented vases & hollow forms up to 12-18 inch heights using a laser to determine the wall thickness. Jamieson? Derry? Elbo? Kelton? others? Thanks.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#2

Dick Hines

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Dick Hines

>I have both the Jamieson and the Kelton. Of the two I like the Jamieson better. There is nothing wrong with the Kelton but the Jamieson is not as bulkie.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Lyle Jamieson

>I have just done a write up on Hollowing system features for Fred Holder and More Woodturning Magazines Q & A. I am biased and think the Jamieson system is the best. But why?? I compare features without naming names. It sounds like a Jamieson ad so I dont know if it is appropriate for this forum. Let me know if anybody wants to see it and I will cut and paste it here for you. Or send it to an individuals personal email address.

A miner issue. For all supported hollowing systems the jet 16-42 must have a custom made tool rest post made in order to do hollowing. The 16-42 stock post is too high. It will not lower enough to cut on the center line in the botton of hollow forms. Lyle

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#4

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Greg Haugen

>Dick,

I'm unbiased and this is what I've learned. I know three people who "had" the kelton rig, they "had" it since they sold it because they didn't like it. It seemed to "bind" on the rig a lot. Don Derry does make a larger system, the common system is smaller and even fits on a mini lathe. When it comes to the Jamieson, you'd be hard pressed not to find one in at least half of the turning shops. You don't see many for sale, can't really say that about the rest of the systems. It's very versatile, user freindly, and does the deed. One system I'd look into is the Monster System, www.monster-wood-tool.com They have a system that's close to the Elbo but with a few more benefits.

I know people like the Jamieson system and I think the Monster rigs are worth looking into.

With all of this said, I still prefer my Stewart system.

Just my 2 cents.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#5

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

James McClure

>Dick,

I have several different set-ups if you want to come by sometime. I have spent WAY too much money over the years and I can show you what has worked for me and what hasn't. Sometime after the GGAF would be good, just give me a call.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#6

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Steven Kubien

>I haven't used other systems but I really like my Jamieson rig. Set-up is easy and it doesn't take much room to store. The laser rig is simple, solid and easy to adjust. Replacement cutters are easy to come by (just 3/16" tool bits) and the Hunter option is also really nice. Lyle's dvd on hollowing is great and touches on issues relevant to other turning as well. Add to this the fact that if you've got problems or questions, Lyle will take time to walk you through them and you've got a great rig with great back-up if you need it.

A little more than 2 cents....

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#7

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

robo hippy

>I have the Monster System, and love it, but it is not suited to going over about 8 inches deep. I have the Kelton hollowers, and love them, but don't have the rest of the Kelton hollowing set up. I had a D type handle made, and use it for my deeper hollowings. I love the carbide discs (Eliminator for me because they fit in my big rig, and my Monster) for clean up cuts. I tried hand holding on some deeper forms (8 inches and deeper), and it is too much arm work, the captured systems take a lot of effort out of it. The Monster is literally finger tip pressure to cut with, and has an excellent laser.

robo hippy

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#8

JAMIESON

robert davis

>

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#9

Homemade. Save a bundle. :o)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#10

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Dick McNeill

>Thanks for all the info re: hollowing systems. Looks like I'll go with the Jamieson system although the "Monster" looks good too.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#11

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

David Holley

>To Lyle Jamieson I need to know the proper height of the tool rest post for the jet 16-42 for your hollowing system.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#12

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Bruce Smith

>Check out the five part survey that Lyn Mangiameli did for Fred Holder in Woodturning magazine. He did an excellent review of all the hollowing tools, he left no stone unturned. It was published in the July, August, Sept./Oct.,November,and December 2004 issues of More Woodturning. If you can't get you hands on those five issues, seems to me you can view them on the More Woodturning site. By the way can anyone tell me where Lyn is as I haven't seen him on any of the turning forms lately and as well no articles written by him.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

Lyle Jamieson

>The back rest should be set at 16 inches or on the center line. If you like going in small holes set the back rest 3/8 below your lathe center line. This puts the 3/4 boring bar directly on the center line.

The front rest can be set in the early stages of turning someplace close to the center line or above center slightly...never below center!! Close is good enough for most of your hogging or hollowing process. When you get to the bottom of your drill hole and need to clean up the inside bottom of your vessel you need the cutter to be EXACTLY on the center line. This is where the 16-42, stock, tool rest will not go into the post of the banjo far enough to get you on the center line. Either grind the #@%$# out of it so it will go down or go down to your local welding shop and get one made for around $20.00-$30.00. In my opinion I would strongly suggest the latter. The high tool rest will be an obsticle for other reasons not just hollowing.

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig?

#14

Re: recomendation for a hollowing rig? *LINK*

charlie belden

>Been a few new hollowing systems since 2004.

The attached link is to a compendium of captured hollowing syststems I put together while looking for one to buy back in May of this year (2008).

I still haven't gotten around to using the Mini-Monster much since I purchased it. I've put together a page on first impressions and have since loaned it to a fellow woodturner and asked for his written evaluation.

I think many reviews of tools done by the owner of the tool may be biased - "I bought it so it's better than anything else out there at the time.". Perhaps reviews by non-owners, who've had a chance to use the tool for a couple of months, may be a tad more objective.

charlie belden


Captured Hollowing System Compendium