Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Posts

3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#1

3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Steve Russell

>Hello to the group,

I just got a new 3M AS-400LBC PAPR respirator and have a few questions for users of this powered respirator:

1.) Do you use the clear overlays on the face shield?

I have been using them, but find they are less than ideal for many reasons. The adhesive line is visible in your line of sight if you look straight out from the face shield. :-( Also, since the adhesive is only on the top and sides of the overlay, shavings and dust get under the overlay from the lower edge and eventually block part of the visible area. Do you add supplemental adhesive on the lower edge to prevent dust from getting in between the overlay and the front of the face shield?

2.) I've already replaced one of my overlay sheets and I found that some parts of the old adhesive line remain on the face shield. What do you use to remove the old adhesive before applying a new overlay? Solvent, heat gun?

I have been using an adhesive remover called Motsenbocker's LIft Off which has worked well thus far to remove the old adhesive, but it has to soak on the area for several minutes before it comes off. The bottle does not mention it can be used on plastics, but it seems to work so far. Once the area is clean, I polish the shield with Novus Plastic Polish to remove any scratches and then reapply a new overlay.

What do you do? Do you prefer to replace the front shield when it gets too scratched to see clearly, or monkey around with the overlays?

3.) I purchased the Smart Charger to charge the battery. How long does it take to recharge your battery if it is dead, or close to it? The manual says it should take ~ 8 hours, but mine has been taking closer to 9 hours before the light on the charger comes back on showing it is fully charged. Do you have a second battery?

4.) I also purchased the hearing protectors that mount on the side of the helmet, since my air compressor is located in my primary studio space. Do you use these at all, or do you think they add too much extra weight? One good thing is the hearing protectors reduce the perceived fan noise... Since I wear my unit non-stop all day long, that has made it more comfortable by reducing the constant drone of the fan.

5.) Do you use the Tyvek closure under the face shield (that closes around under your chin) or the rubber one? My Tyvek shield is already showing signs of wear, so I ordered the rubber one but have not installed it as yet.

6.) How long do your filters last before needing replacement?

Thanks for any help and assistance you can offer. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#2

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Fog Tanner

>Been using Airstream for several years now. I haven't worried too much with the adhesive at this point. I use the overlays and may worry about it later.

I will use mine for about 13-14 hours at a time and put it on the smart charger. It is normally charged by the next day. 9 hours is not unreasonable for a battery pack of that capacity. I try to keep it on trickle when not in use and will be using it before a 30 lapse. That is the upper limit for a trickle charge. The 9 hours will drop after the first few charges, and in time as the capacity drops go back up.

Can't help you with the hearing protectors. They would interfer with my Rock and Roll so I didn't get them. My dust collector is 8 feet away, but not as loud as my compressor which is about 40 feet away. They also don't let me hear some of the sounds from the lathe, that are sometimes a sign of trouble.

I use the Tyvek and bought extras. The rubber seal is too hot here in Texas in the summer, which is most of the time except for our one week of fall and three days of winter and one week of spring.

I check the airflow to see when the filter needs replacing. It will vary depending on if I am doing a lot of really dusty wood or a lot of green wood. Keep the prefilter cleaned and it will help with the motor and filer life.

I don't turn without mine. I wear it all the time at the lathe - which can be up to 14 hours a day. I find it comfortable and another layer of body armor at times. It is worth having some extra parts, like filters, Tyveks and overlays on hand. Some of those I buy by the 10 pack - like the Tyveks and overlays, just one extra filter.

Good luck with yours, your lungs and sinus will be much happier - I know mine are.

Fog

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#3

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Steve Russell

>Hello Fog,

Thanks for the information... Glad to hear that the extra time to charge the battery is not a cause for concern. I listen to music in the studio as well, but I can still hear it when wearing the hearing protectors. When I don't think I will need them, I simply flip them out of the way. They nest on the side/back of the helmet for the times you don't need them.

Have you ever heard about modifying the inlet of the helmet so you can attach an organic vapor cartridge? There was a bloke some time ago who posted a note on another forum about a mod he made to the helmet so he could attach an organic vapor cartridge to the inlet screen. That way, he could wear the unit when finishing to protect against solvent fumes.

IIRC, he used a standard OVC from a 3M half mask respirator and made a silicone adapter to allow it to fit over the inlet screen. I can't find the posting now, but I may have it bookmarked. I know 3M has a similar unit that also filters organic vapors in addition to dust, but it is quite a bit more than the dust only model. Thanks again and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#4

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Steve in NC

>Steve

I have been using mine for about two months. Like Fig, I also do not turn without it.

I use the clear overlays. I replace mine about every two weeks. I tend to be more careful now when finishing however in order to try to keep the overlay cleaner. I posted a question a few weeks ago about cleaning the visor and received several good suggestions. You may want to search for it.

My Tyvek is getting a bit dirty but not at all worn. You must have a very abrasive face (LOL).

I would think carefully about any modifications. If you truly need organic vapor protection, you should use equipment designed for that purpose.

Steve

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#5

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Fog Tanner

>Steve,

I think that is the model 600 that is for vapors too. I was under the impression that it was just different filters but as I had no need for that I didn't look any further. I gnerally don't use my airstream for any finishing, using a dual charcol filtered respirator instead. It worked for all the years of spraying various aurtomotive paints, which aren't too kind to the lungs, so all the wood finishes are easy.

I have used the "smart" type chargers since around 1980, when they first became available. They are really the only way to for rechargable batteries. The one you have will put a "charge" current to the battery which is more than the normal C10 rate. C10 is 1/10 the rated capacity, this would be a 50mil chargae rate for a 500ma battery. A C3 would be you normal fast charge and there are some batteres that are rated at C1 or the full capacity of the battery.

Using a constant unregulated charger would normally nuke the battery at the higher charge rates. The smart chargers monitor the voltage and will either shut off until the voltage drops below a certain level and then hit it again. When fully charged they will go into a trickle or C50 rate. I have 4 of those types. There are some others that monitor the voltage and reduce the charge rate until it gets to a "charged" state and then revert to a C50 rate.

The biggest problem you have is thermal runaway. It is always best to charge your batteries in you house where it is cool. I do have some that have an external themral sensor to compensate for the atomospheric temperature, so I can charge batteries when it is over 100 outside. The charging process will introduce heat in the batteries. The heat will lower the internal resistance, and the battery will take more of a charge, which in turn build more heat. This cycle repeats until the battery either vents or detonates. This is a problem with the higher charge rates on a "dumb" charger. It was a lot more fun before they put vents in the cells. Once they vent you just loose capacity. Before they would detonate and you didn't have to worry about them anymore.

You should also keep your batteries charged and not let them drop below the critcal level. For the nicad type, that would be all those batteries that were drivitives of nicads and still refered to as such. For the "1.5" volt cell, that was 1.1 volts. Fully charged the cell was around 1.53- 1.54 with the normal voltage around 1.48 for the majority of the load cycle. When they drop below 1.1 volts per cell, you can get polarity reversal and the pretty much does in the battery back. The cell(s) that has reversed polarity will drain all the charge from the other cells. Charging is no different, the one cell will take all the charge. All those lines you have heard about draining the pack flat and then charging are a quick way to ruin a $275 battery pack.

All that "stuff" about memory went away back in the '70s. You can use the battery as much or as little as you need and they will not develop a "memory" of how long they were used. That is normally the line you hear about draining them flat is to eliminate the "memory". You mostly hear that from somebody that sells batteries or find it in the instruction sheet since they have batteries as a replacement part.

Fog

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#6

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Steve Russell

>Hello Fog,

Thanks for the great information... :-)

A question or two. I'm a little confused... You mentioned that you want to try and keep the battery above the critical level and not let it run flat before charging. How can you run your battery pack for up to 14 hours? Won't this make the battery run down to a very low point, perhaps below the critical level?

If I run my battery all day long ( 12 - 14 hours ) will the battery be dropping below the critical point before it gets charged at night? Do you use multiple batteries and switch them out to prevent any battery from getting too low?

From what you said, you don't want to run the battery down all the way and then charge it, since this is not good for the battery. Since the batteries for this little bugger are close to $300.00 I want to keep them fat and happy... What should I do? Get several batteries and swap them out after a few hours of use? Thanks for you help on this, I really want to take care of this puppy. :-) Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#7

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Fog Tanner

>Steve,

12 hours is pretty much the upper end for that size battery. The 14 is by turning off periodicly for inspecting pieces and mounting blanks, etc. Even at 12 hours, you are not running the battery continiously which allows some recovery time. But, should you have worries, you can always place the pack on charge during lunch breaks. The AS200 would be closer to 8-9 hours, but the AS400 has a 5000+MA (5 Amp) battery pack. This is how they get the extra run time.

I used to profile all my batteries to get and understanding of how long they would last and if they were loosing capacity. I have a meter which places a load on the battery. I would record the starting voltage and the duration for each tenth of volt change. The five volt battey packs I used for racing when fully changed measured 5.3 volts (1.325 per cell). Within 3-5 minutes they would be at 4.9 volts (1.225 per cell). They would stay at 4.9-4.8 volts for 90% of their usable load time. Once they dropped to 4.6 volts (1.15 per cell), the drop to 4.4 (1.10 per cell) was faily quick usually within five minute. I would stop after 4.6 as the voltage/time after this was not really usable.

At a contest, I could check the voltage and know if I needed to change batteries or not. I also recorded all the times in a log book and knew when the battery was loosing capacity and it was time to change.

When it comes time to replace the batteries, I will get a set of Sanyo cells and rebuild it myself. Last time I priced those size cells, it would be less than $60. I had also thought about doing the same thing to make an extra pack, but have not had a need for one yet. There are some denser cells used in aero-space that have higher capacity for the same size and would yield even longer run times. I have used them before, but their only problem was they were more susceptable to vibration than the normal cells.

Should you elect to rebuild you battery pack, Sanyo cells are the best unless you get into the aero-space cells. Buy the industrial cells and not the comsumer versions. Get the ones that have solder tabs and a C1 charge rating, which means they will take more abuse than you are likely to throw their way. The solder tabs are for assembling them.

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#8

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Steve Russell

>Thanks Fog!

Do you think it would be beneficial to put ice packs on/near the battery pack when you are charging it? I charge my pack inside, but I do notice that it gets rather warm when charging for a long time... Since heat is one of the enemies of batteries, are any strategies to reduce it when charging worthwhile? Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#9

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

Fog Tanner

>Steve,

If you were charging at a C1 rate, iceing down the pack would help. It it normal for them to get a little warm when charging, but lethal if they get too hot to touch. I have actually seen some packs get pretty close to that when being hit with a C3 or C1 rate for a few minutes. But even at a C50 rate the batteries will get a little warm. At a C50-C100 rate, they will be room temperature. Also, the batteries in the pack are an industrial battery, either C1 or C3 rating and will take quite a bit of abuse.

If you are charging indoors you will be fine. I would just stay away from charging in your studio in the summer if it does not have AC. The charger I mentioned with the external temperature sensor is for charging outside and I have used it in Dallas when the temp was over 100 with no problems.

I think you will be fine with what you are doing, I have been charging mine after every use and leaving it on charge (trickle) until the next time I use it. If I was not going to use it for more than 30 days I would take it off around the 30th day. But, I am back to having fun now and it is getting used and charged everyday - nothing like turning at 2 in the morning.

It is several years old now and I expect to get five to eight years out of it before I need to rebuild it. Typical usage is about 1000 charge cycles, where a charge cycle is running it all the way down to the minium voltage. Since I never run mine flat, I get more than the 1000 cycles. My recommendations are aimed at what will give the maximum reliable battery life, You can certainly charge in the heat, but your battery life will be less. And while no one will get killed, its still a $275 battery pack.

Good luck,

Fog

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...

#10

Re: 3M AS-400LBC PAPR Users- A Few Questions...---

Steve Russell------WebKitFormBoundary+48Vzcg3RwAdD

>Thanks again Fog!

Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP

The Woodlands, Texas

------WebKitFormBoundary+48Vzcg3RwAdD9nB