>I have been struggling through the learning curve on video production. Here is my first. It isn't very good but I needed to at least go through the whole process once to see where all the problems are. I've been a still photographer forever but I've never even owned a video camera so I'm having to learn the entire process.
I'm using Pinnacle software and the book really sucks. I'm having to just click on things and try to figure it out and for a computer idiot that isn't the way to learn.
Let me know what you think and if you have any suggestions. Bear in mind that I shot the video myself from a tripod while doing the turning. That in itself lead to some really funny out takes that children should not be allowed to hear.
I definitely plan to do a better job on the next one.
>Hello : My wife got me a hunter tool and the first time I tried to use it I had a huge catch and have never used it since. I want to learn how to use it. I just watched your video and have a couple questions. How high do you have the tool rest? level with the center of the bowl, higher or lower? It appears you have the hunter tool pointing slightly upwards, is that correct? Thanks in advance Jared
>John, I think your video was done very well. You demonstrated the cutting action of the tool effectively and your dialogue explained what you were doing. Excellent!
>It could be something on my end, but the video itself looks horribly jagged. Maybe the compression that you tube does? none of the lines are straight, like anti-aliasing is turned off.
>Good video overall - I had problems with the quality also. Plus, I watched and listened to the entire session but did not hear the questionable language you promised! :) Charles
The video is pretty good. Your narration is much better than that on most turning videos I've seen, both in the delivery and the audio quality. The audio on the opening shot is not good - you need either a shotgun mic at the camera or better, a lapel mic. If your camera will take a separate microphone input, I have a shotgun mic around here somewhere you might try. That existing audio could be fixed a bit with levels and noise reduction and perhaps a bit of filtering. You might slow down just a touch in the delivery of that segment.
The camera angles are very good and clearly show the action. From the closeup it is hard to see the "shallow cove" mentioned. Perhaps a deeper cove would show up better. If we want to be picky, you might try adjusting the light in the opening segment just a bit to minimize distracting light reflection from the glasses.
The horrible aliasing (seen in the stairsteps on diagonal lines) makes me think there is something more going on than compression artifacts. Did you significantly resize the original or change the aspect ratio? The codec used will also make a big difference but I don't know what's best to use these days.
If you can make use of it, I have professional video and audio editing equipment here at the house. I haven't used it since I retired but I suspect everything still works. I can do titling as well. (I used to do video productions both on and off the job, many with 3D animation.)
I also have the Vegas+DVD video editing package here (by Sonic Foundary), never opened, if you want to try it. It has a video editor, dvd production software, and a dolby 5.1 surround sound encoder. :) (hear that tool cut!) I haven't looked at this manual but Sonic Foundry has been known for their excellent documentation.
BTW, I made some more handles for some of my hunter tools last week. I love those tools, for inside, outside, endgrain, small hollowing. I especially like the one with the 5/8" tapered shaft. I am having problems with the carbide chipping on two of the tools. I don't know why since I'm careful not to let them touch anything else.
>John, Great first video. Who knew you were/are such a young, fuzzy looking guy. Some stuff about compressed pixies that others wrote. Meanwhile I thought the content was excellent, demoed and narrated in a clear and understandable fashion. Could not tell what the first two tools were from the picture, have the #3 and #4, could not tell how the "rotators" work from the picture. Been using mine in shear scrape mode, and will try riding the bevel a bit more. Thanks for showing us.
>I'm cutting approximately on the center line or slightly higher. It's not real critical as long as your rubbing the bevel. If your doing the scraping cut then it needs to be at or above the center. The tool rest is a little lower because I'm short and my lathe is tall. The camera angle is quite high so it would be difficult to see exactly where I cut.
>John I used the in camera mike for the opening sequence. I have a headset mike that I used for the rest. I'm going to work on interpreting the book and learn now to improve the audio, or at least edit it better.
I appreciate the offer for the video equipment but I think I have all I can handle for now.
>Texian On the next video I will demonstrate hollowing boxes. On these you are forced to go from rubbing the bevel on the bottom to shear scraping on the side. The only way to get around this would be to change to a #1 tool mounted sideways in a bar so you could rub the bevel as you go up the side. I've done that on vases but I get a clean enough cut on boxes to just sand those.
>John, since you are a college, get some of the art students help out with the editing or even the shooting of the video. Haven't had a chance to look at it yet. When things slow down a little here at work, I run it. Nice 'seeing' you again.
>Nice video-wish I could actually see what is happening. Very "pixelly" on this computer. I know you are working on it though.
I've been curious about these tools since you first started talking about them. I had a less-than-wonderful experience with a different carbide-insert type tool and have shyed away from the concept. I have some older Craftsman carbide tools that work OK as scrapers but don't really cut well. The newer carbides are much finer grained though.
>The pixelation can be reduced by changes in the lighting and the software.
A lot of the pixelation is the software and how it handles bright light, edges, and rapid movement. You said you were using the Pinnacle software, and it is bad about pixelation. If in doubt, it will pixelate. The only editor that is worse is Roxio. These less expensive software give you a lot for your money, but there are a lot of things they don't do very well. When I used Pinnacle, pixelation was a constant battle, but it all but disappeared when I started using the Adobe Premier. That is the difference between a $100 software and an $800 software that does essentially the same thing.
There are several things you can do to work around the inadequacies of the Pinnacle software. Lighting can help eliminate pixelation. Everything you knew about lighting with still photography is just as important with the video picture, but it may be more important because everything is magnified by 30 frames per second, and it isn't as easy to Photoshop the bad stuff out of the picture. You can do a few things after the fact with the Pinnacle, but it doesn't do it very well, and it takes up a humongous amount of storage space. Since the Pinaccle wants to pixilate bright lines and outlines, you should be doing everything possible to soften the image outlines and get rid of the bright spots. Direct lighting has to be avoided is favor of a softer reflected lighting. I use umbrellas and scattering filters, to essentially do the same thing as a light tent would do for taking a still photo. It all gets in the way, and it gets hot in there, but it can be worked around.
Always use manual focus and exposure. Set the focus for the maximum sharpness of the object or area being taken. Do this when it isn't moving, and it will be OK when you are running. The first problem is that the auto-focus doesn't do very well on spinning objects, and it will do funny things that will lead to the software pixelating the image. Manually set the exposure to take any remaining glare off of the bright spots on the object. Over exposure can cause pixelation in the software. You can't always judge the exposure on the camera screen because it will usually be brighter on a larger screen, and after it has been processed through a photo editor. That means you will have to take a few test runs, and process them to see what happens, and then use those exposure settings on the camera. You will most likely discover that the pixelation goes away when you are a little bit on the dark side.
The other thing that helps is camera distance. For taking video of wood spinning in the lathe, it helps to take the video with the focus as close to wide open as possible, and moving the camera in close to frame the picture, rather than using the telephoto. I have no idea why this works, but it does.
>Russ Thank you very much. Makes perfect sense. I was using manual focus but did not try manual exposure. I'll work on that. I've printed off your advice and will give it a try.
Hope to see more instructional clips from you in the future as this kind of video really helps a new truner. May not go out and buy the Hunter tool but good to know about.
When all the bugs are worked out only thing I missed is tool rest height. I assume set for tool center on center of turning. Missed if tool is held flat when you talk about shear scraping or if handle up a little.
What is up next? Turning lidded boxes, hollow forms, finials or just a practical lathe tool application to turning form type?
Great job if your first video on line. Remember to smile cause your having fun!
>John, I read this article a while back and have spend the last week trying to find the link (well not the whole week). It's not common knowledge, but Youtube can also upload hight quality videos. See the link low. Hope this helps with your future video tutorials.