Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

bad smelling wood

Posts

bad smelling wood

#1

bad smelling wood

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Can you take a guess at what wood I managed to pick up somewhere: it is distinctly yellow, has dark grey, almost black bark that's reasonably smooth, and which peels off without too much difficulty (sort of like very tough orange peel would) and smells like manure.

Re: bad smelling wood

#2

Re: bad smelling wood *LINK*

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>Could be ailanthus...(tree of heaven)...It stinks, has smooth bark, and turns yellow when exposed to the air.


http://www.nps.gov/plants/alien/fact/aial1.htm

Re: bad smelling wood

#3

Re: bad smelling wood

pat28

>Our timing is incredible... Last week, in a pile of wood scraps of mixed origins that I purchased, I came across a piece of local wood that has high figuring and smelled like an old cow as I cut and turned it. I will try to upload a picture of the ornament I made with it. I first thought it was oak, but oak does not smell that way... So, if your wood was a local species and not an oexotic one, we probably hit the same thing... Any input will be appreciated...

Pat


img

Re: bad smelling wood

#4

Re: bad smelling wood

John K Jordan

>eliot d,

This summer I cut a small tree that had distinctly brilliant yellow wood and the worst smell I've ever encountered - worse than ailanthus but in a different way. From the leaves and fruit it appeared to be buckthorn according to my references. I cut some blanks anyway. The wood on the outside of the blanks faded to pale yellow in a few months. I didn't turn or finish any so I don't know if that would have slowed the fading.

But Mike is right about ailanthus - the trees (bark, leaves, branches, wood, saplings), or more specifically the male trees, stink to high heaven. Maybe that's why they call it the Tree of Heaven.

JKJ

Re: bad smelling wood

#5

Re: bad smelling wood

robo hippy

>Persimmon also stinks. Smooth bark on the outside, and the very heart was black (related to ebony). Smelled more like cat pee on old tires. Smell never went away. I have gotten a lot of trees that were smelly, mostly sour from starting to rot, except cottenwood which smells like some one threw up on it. Have gotten maple and myrtle that smelled like a horse stall.

robo hippy

Re: bad smelling wood

#6

Re: bad smelling wood

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Thanks for the responses. It's a local wood; so it's not the tree of heaven. Now that I think more about it, I think I can find the fellow who gave it to me so I probably can find out what its is, after all. IF I find out , I'll post it.

Re: bad smelling wood

#7

Re: bad smelling wood *LINK*

John K Jordan

>robo hippy,

Persimmon does not have smooth bark. The bark is distinctively checkered, a bit like dogwood but with bigger blocky checks and deeper furrows between. The bark is dark grey, looks nearly black in the woods. The wood has a distinctive smell but I've never thought of it as smelling bad. I've never seen the jet black heart wood bigger than a pencil, usually smaller. We have many persimmon trees on our farm and the fruit is falling like crazy right now. All the animals I have except cats (horses, goats, lamb, chickens and dogs) LOVE the persimmons.

eliot d:

I don't know where you live, but ailanthus trees are widely distributed over most of the US. The trees were brought from China and planted because people thought they looked "tropical". They got out of control and are now considered an invasive species. References say they will grow where almost nothing else can get going. I removed a row of ailanthus trees behind my barn and they send up seedlings like crazy. For several years I pulled up trees starting all over one field since the goats and horses will hardly touch them. They grow very fast - the new-growth "twigs" on a tree will grow perhaps 5 ft per year. The bark is light grey (usually looks a little whitish to me) and lightly furrowed, almost wrinkled, not something I would call smooth although smoother than many trees. The wood is soft and looks like it would be stringy on the lathe but I haven't tried it.

JKJ


ailanthus distribution

Re: bad smelling wood

#8

Re: bad smelling wood

Mark Williamson

>It wasn't wood but it was the most fowl smelling stuff I have ever turned! LOL My stepdad is a farrier and he sent me some farley thick cuts of some hoof that came off of a clidestale. imagine taking a clump of hair and mashing it into a pile of horse poo. Then light it on fire! Yep, THAT is the smell that filling up my shop and ran me out! LOL Despite the smell, I was able to finally get a couple of mini's turned. Who knew, horse toenail turns out pretty! he he

Mark

Re: bad smelling wood

#9

Re: bad smelling wood

John K Jordan

>>...imagine taking a clump of hair and mashing it into a pile of horse poo

Maybe that's what makes hoof trimmings so tasty to my dogs.

JKJ