Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Do You Care How Long It Takes?

Posts

Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#1

Do You Care How Long It Takes?

charlie belden in san jose

>If you're a production turner, or a pro demonstrator, or going to do a demo at your turning club - How Long It Takes is important.

And that can give you the impression that in order to become a good turner you have to be fast.

But if you think about it, production turners pro demonstrators and a club members that do demos at a club meeting - have probably turned piece dozens if not several hundred times. And demonstrators realize that time is important because audience attention spans are about an hour, hour and a half max.

So when it takes you two, three, fouror ten times as long to turn a piece similar to one you saw demonstrated, regardless of how well the piece turns out, do you feel like you SHOULD have been able to turn it in a lot less time? Is The Need For Speed important - if you have no intention of doing a demonstration?

Personally, How Long It Take is the antithesis of why I turn. I want to get to that place where time disappears - and better yet - everything else but the turning disappears. WHAT I end up with when I drop out of that place isn't all that important. If it's surprisingly nice - that's a bonus. And the idea of turning basically the same thing a dozen times when there are so many other things to try turning doesn't make sense to me - except maybe for turned lidded boxes ; ).

So what about you? Do you aspire to creating master pieces - in about an hour?

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#2

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

arkie

>Rarely do I commune with a piece of wood in some altered state, to return and discover that something has happened. It's not a totally foreign concept, it just doesn't happen often. More often, I am seeking to make something, and part of my quest is for that elegant and simple efficency where everything comes together to achieve that goal.

If you watch someobdy who has been a good production turner for 20 years, or a master of one of the oriental arts, you'll understand what I mean by elegant and simple efficiency.

That directly affects how long it takes, although that is not the goal.

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#3

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

john lucas

>Charlie I like your statement about time disappearing when you turn. I think that is a very good thing. As far as turning the same thing over and over. It's really fun but it depends on you attitude. Last year I turned 50 ornaments for a special order. At first I was dreading turning that many but when I really got into it I found that there were all sorts of interesting things to keep it interesting. When I turned the ball part I found that very small changes made a big difference in the appearance. It was interesting and very insightful to learn this.

the finials offered the same sort of thing but in a different way. I did concentrate on the shape but also how I was turning. I found I got faster and faster because I was duplicating the movements. At the same time I was fine tuning the design with each one. I started trying to see if I could get cleaner cut to save time sanding. It all started to be a game and became quite interesting.

Now I turn ornaments much faster which actually allows me to play more because I don't waste as much time. It's still fun but I have much less fear of the tools. Repetitive turning is one of the best things you can do to improve your skills.

All of this has a downside. The more I turn the more ideas come to me and the more I need to turn. I will never have time to turn all of things my mind comes up with.

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#4

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

Donna Banfield

>"Do you aspire to creating master pieces - in about an hour?"

No, and I don't expect to. If I'm attempting to re-create a turning that I saw someone demonstrate, I will spend as much time figuring out how it was done. I don't care that it might take me 10 times longer than the actual demo or the amount of time that demonstrator takes to produce that turning in his/her shop. I want to know how to do it, and figure out the process. I'm not planning on selling that piece, so the first ( or second, third and fourth ones, etc.) are all about the process and discovery.

That same principle holds true when I am figuring out a new process of my own. I don't keep track of the time, nor am I in a rush to 'get r done'. The journey is more important in that circumstance than the end result.

That said, once I have developed the skill necessary to competently create the piece, and have found that there is a market for it, I will keep track of the time I spend, to determine whether it is something I can make for a profit, or whether I should reserve that type of turning to those which I give to close friends and family members. And in that case, the amount of time spent is irrelevant.

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#5

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

Texian

>Interesting post John. I rarely turn more than two of the same thing, so I miss out on the benefits of repetitive turning.

The visualization of the end result is what drives me, but I work slowly (compared to others, I think). After days (instead of hours or minutes) on a particular piece (especially sanding and finish work), I tend to tire of it and find self thinking about how to make the next project. Probably a character fault, as focus and the will to do all the work are required to carry a piece all the way to "masterpiece".

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Yes and no.

steve antonucci

>Do I care how long it takes? Yes and no is my view.

Yes- I care about being able to work well and efficiently with whatever tool is in my hand. No- I do not use a stop watch to measure that efficiency.

Yes- I care more about the results than the time spent. No, I will not let something leave that doesn't measure up for time constraints.

Yes- I care about "maximizing" my enjoyment in the shop. No- I don't measure it in "units made per hour".

The one thing I will never do is "production work". Aside from not being that fond of repetitive tasks, I never want to have to account for my time in the shop in $$$/hr.

If you saw the 4 projects on my bench right now, you'd know that I don't really care how long it takes... :-)

Steve

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#7

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

Fog Tanner

>I would have mixed feelings about the question. When I was younger I worked in machine shops running where speed and quality was everything. I would make 1000 of the same thing, yet each one was if it was the only one I had done. Even though it was repetative, there was always the challenge of making each match the print within tolerances. It was actually enjoyable and a challenge the faster you could go.

I do some production turning from time to time for the fun of it. I will make a run of 100 toothpick holders for which there is no deadline and I will give away. But, I do them as quick as I can and as well as I am able. They are in a way practice with the tools. They are also each a journey of their own as each is a little different shape - yet similar. It is a joy watching the shavings come off, yet the aim for each cut is to improve upon the last. In looking at the reach for speed, I looked at how long Raffan had been turning and our age differences and figure I will be able to catch him in pnly about 30 years - we will both be dead by then.

Roughing bowls is much like production turning in speed. But, I still find the time to practice cuts which will be used later in finish turning. Each one is a new adventure and a lesson to be learned. It is up to the individual as to how long to dwell.

These days I spend most of my time in offcenter work, where even going fast is still slow. Each piece is a new journey, even though the path was traveled many time before. Each piece of wood brings a new discovery in the way it reacts. There is a process of finding the best way to cut that piece and then perfecting that as best you can, knowing that the next will be a little different. In these forms I find a bit of a pardox, speed versus the challenge of turning a single blade fan. There is a rush to get to the basic shape and then the majority of time consumed in all the little problems and small cuts when the walls get thin. This creates a problem as there is "what if" and "if I change that" time and the rush to finish to get to the next one.

The day job is programming and problem solving, where speed is everything. I have worked on problems which took me less than a minute to resolve. But, I have also worked on projects which ran into months of 18 hour days and seven day weeks. In either case you run flat out as if there is no tomorrow, as there is always a new problem when the current little issue is solved. There is a certan amount of passion that drives the quest for the answer, and each problem is looking for an answer. So each one is a passionate quest into the unkown. Einstien once said that the most beautiful thing we can perceive is the unkown. From that point of view each problem or piece of wood is beautiful, for they are both based on the unknown. Were it known, there would be no problem and piece of wood a bowl.

At times I look at wood turning in much the same way, there is always one more piece to turn - each with its own little mysteries and journeies to be enjoyed. But as qucikly as they are finished, a new one will appear to keep the mind active. While not for everyone, for some it keeps the mind active and learning past "our years", for when you quite learning or loose the passion for life the only thing left is the grave.....or a government job.

Fog

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#8

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Charlie, I have done more demos and taught more people than I can remember, and the question about how long anything takes almost never comes up. When it does, it is usually related to how long a wet piece of wood is going to take to dry. Occasionally I will get a comment about how fast I am making a particular cut, but very rarely do people equate time with money except on internet boards. Of course, when I do a demo, I explain that I am there to show the process, not how well I can make something. And the process is artificial when it comes to time, because there is lots of stopping and starting, extra talking, stories, questions to answer, etc. On top of all that is using equipment which is not as familiar as that in my own shop.

There are more important criteria when it comes to selling this stuff. First and foremost is sales and marketing ability. If you don't have that, you ain't selling much of your stuff. next comes quality of the piece. Yes, there are still people out there who care about that and can tell the difference. Speed eventually figures into it, but it is not the driving force for a lot of people in the woodturning community because they aren't doing this as a race. They are doing it for fun. Actually I lied. I do get comments on speed, and most of them reflect what I just wrote. This is for fun, and if it is not relaxing, it ain't fun anymore. And that reflects your own expressed sentiment.

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#9

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>I personnaly don't really try to turn fast. I agree with you that the process is almost important as the end product. That said, I find that the more I turn the less time it takes me to finish a project. Things like experience and muscle memory really do pay off.

John

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#10

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

John K Jordan

>Since I'm probably the slowest turner alive today, I hope I never get to the point where the time matters.

JKJ

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#11

Ric Taylor

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

Ric Taylor

>I don't care how long it takes to finish a piece, I invest however much time is necessary to achieve the results I desire.

Certainly I envy those in my club who show up at every meeting with two or three gallery-quality pieces. It would be nice to be able to do that. But first of all, most of those folks are retired, so my priorities are different. I don't try to turn out the volume of anyone else, and I don't try to make what is currently popular or in style. While other club members are making what they learned in the most recent guest-turner demo, I'm quietly progressing on the list of goals and things to complete that I have in my mind.

I complete maybe three or four projects in a year, and although I wish I could do more, I'm satisfied with the quality of what I have done, and that is what is most important for me. There are a number of galleries that have expressed interest in carrying my work, but since my volume is so low, I usually decline. I don't want the pressure of filling an inventory. However, I will lean more in that direction after I retire, but only to the extent that it is fun for me.

My projects are earmarked for my home or gifts for special people. There are occasional commissions and sales, but most of those requests are turned down. I don't want the expectations of other people hanging over me. Life is too short.

In the end, everybody had to do what is fullfilling for them. If you start bending to unwanted outside pressures, it is no longer fun or satisfying.

Ric

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#12

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

john lucas

>I think your right. I do the same thing on projects that I'm not as quick. Hollow vessels are a good example. I don't do a lot of them so I'm basically pretty slow. Maybe fast compared to some but slow compared to the people who turn them all the time. Consequently by the time I get one finished I'm tired of it and want to move on. this makes it hard to perfect the form because it might be a few months before I turn another one.

We were discussing finding your style at a symposium one time and someone asked John Jordan how you find your little niche in the turning world. John's answer was you have to turn, turn , turn. When you turn enough you start to find what interests you. Then you turn a lot of these and you start to move in a direction that is more personal to you. This is when it becomes your own work.

As hobby turners most of us don't turn to find a niche, we turn to have fun. Some of us turn to try to find a voice and some of us turn to play with tools and some us turn just to see the shaving fly. All are valid, its such a wide ranging hobby.

The question you have to ask yourself is where do I want to go with this. If the final result is to become the next turning rock star, then you'd better get in the shop and make shavings as often as possible. If your final result is simply to make gifts for friends and family then do whatever you desire, it's your hobby so have fun.

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

#13

Re: Do You Care How Long It Takes?

bill Crommett

>A point not discussed is important for me. I like to turn fast enough to complete a step before this aging mind forgets where he is on the plan and what the next step should be. Now, What was I going to say next ?