Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

fruit wood ?'s

Posts

fruit wood ?'s

#1

fruit wood ?'s

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>or the wood of fruit trees.

Seems like every post about a fruit wood notes that it WILL split. Regardless of drying method.

OK. But anybody know why? The same thing does not seem to be the case with nut trees.

And then there is cherry.... :-) But American Black cherry is not a fruit tree, is it?

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: fruit wood ?'s

keith tompkins

>Hi Carol, Yes, black cherry is a fruit tree. I've turned apple, cherry, plum, mulberry, peach, and pear with good results. In most cases, I turned it while freshly cut. I know wood such as apple has a bad reputation, but I don't know the reason.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#3

Re: fruit wood ?'s

George Van

>Hi Carol, fruitwood or not,I have had great results drying cherry roughing to 10%/diameter and coating with Anchorseal. The results are the same as for maple or birch.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#4

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Carole Valentine

>For some reason they seem to be more prone to splitting from the pith and around the sapwood. It's not necessarily that they WILL split, just that a little more care needs to be taken sometimes. I think a lot depends on the particular tree and the stresses it has endured over it's life time. I would consider Black Cherry a fruit tree. I turn an awful lot of it and it seems that even the tiniest section of pith left in the log will result in cracking.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#5

Re: fruit wood ?'s

john lucas

>I think it's because Fruit woods move more but I have never looked up the specs to see if this is true. From my own experience they seem to move a lot more after turning than say oak or walnut. I generally don't try to save fruit woods in the round. I lose it to checking almost every time. If I get some I try to rough them out our turn them completely if at all possible. I have a peach log that was given to me. It was so badly checked already I've never used it. I may cut it up some day and use it for smaller things. I get a fair amount of apple and will almost always lose it if I don't turn it immediately.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#6

Re: fruit wood ?'s

John K Jordan

>>Seems like every post about a fruit wood notes that it WILL split.

I think there is much variation between individual trees and parts of trees. If the blank is cut from reaction wood, say from a limb or leaning tree or around a crotch, it may warp and crack where one cut from a long straight section of trunk will not. In my experience, a blank with irregular figure is a grab bag.

Some of the splitting people report might be due to the geometry of the piece, e.g., thin walls and thick base.

A week ago I had a nice bradford pear bowl crack only AFTER I soaked it in DNA - I think the evaporating alcohol accelerated uneven drying between the sides and the foot, creating increased stresses. A crack in the foot opened about 1/8" wide then closed over the next day to a hairline.

JKJ

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#7

Re: fruit wood ?'s

john lucas

>John I had a perfectly dry cedar bowl break apart one time when I tried to bleach it. The bleach soaked in so fast that the area that I was bleaching expanded and the dry areas didn't. It started blowing up in all directions and there wasn't anything I could do. If I try it again I'm going to drop it in a bucket of water first to let everything expand and then bleach it.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#8

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Roger

>Carol,

Go to upper left,click on articles, then on Woodcentral Articles, then Turning Tools and Techniques then right column then to Turning Apple Wood by Russ. Lots of good and accurate info. Good luck.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#9

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Sean Troy

>Fruit trees do tend to hold more water and loose water quicker than most trees (cracking) turn the walls evenly and past the pith (bowls)and there is no problem.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#10

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Russ Fairfield

>The problem with wood from fruit trees is that it is from fm fruit tree. These are load bearing trees whose load varies with the seasons, and that makes for some unique and interesting wood with unique and interesting problems. How interesting depends on where the wood came from in the tree, and how much sapwood is present.

"Reaction" wood will crack because of the internal stresses that are released when it is cut and dried. Reaction wood is caused by natural or external forces on the growing tree, and can be detected by an off-center pith, the farther off-center, the more internal stresses.

Fruit trees bear fruit, and the load causes a large internal stresses that we call "reaction" when they are released. The stresses are greatest in the crotch area and the base of the limbs, and less in the trunk. For this reason, the closer to the ground, the less likely we will have "reaction" problems with the wood. Reaction problems are excessive wood movement and cracking.

My counter to the "reaction" is to turn the bowl to a final thickness of no more than 1/4" when it is wet, regardless of its diameter; and as soon after cutting as possible. I wrap the wood in plastic if I can't get to it immediately. I let the bowl dry, using bags or whatever to slow the evaporation rate, and let it move and warp into what it will. Then I power sand with the wood stationary, after it has dried. It is usually warped way beyond sanding with the lathe running. I get some interesting shapes this way, and I will lose no more than 20& of the crotch pieces. I avoid the limbs.

I have had no success with either boiling the wood in water or soaking it in alcohol or soap suds. Theese did nothing to help me get a round bowl, and did nothing when the bowls is turned thin while it is still wet. The problem with getting a round bowl is that the high shrinkage means the bowl has to be left very thick, on the order of 25% or more of the diameter, in order to turn the oblong dried bowl into one that is round. That thickness is too much for anything that either boiling, alcohol or soap suds can do. I have found it much easier to just accept that the wood will warp a lot and work with the warp rather than to try fighting it.

The other problem with fruit trees is that they have a wide sapwood band to carry nutrients to the fruit. This sapwood is softer, a different grain structure, and a different (higher) moisture content from the heart, and those differences can be significant on a fruit tree. Having both heart and sap looks pretty in a piece of Apple wood, but the difference between them can cause untold problems when they are in the same piece. You have to be careful of the placement of the sapwood when it is mixed with heartwood in the same piece with any wood from any tree, but particularly so when the wood is from a fruit tree. It is best not to mix them until you have gained some experience with using fruit tree wood.

Most woodturners avoid fruit tree wood, and run from orchard trees when they are offered. The advantage of learning how to handle this wood is that you will have access to some beautiful wood that everyone else ignores.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#11

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Russ Fairfield

>A couple things about Apple trees.

Apple trees are the worst of all fruit trees because their fruit load is heavier, and the heavier load on the tree makes their internal stresses the highest of all fruit trees. Orchard trees are worse than random yard trees because they are hybidized and forced to bear a heavier fruit crop. But there will be some beautiful wood in an old orchard tree because of these very reasons.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#12

Re: citrus and nuts

Russ Fairfield

>Citrus and nut trees are somewhat different from the other fruit trees.

Nut trees don't need as much water to their fruit, so the sapwood band is usually narrower, and not as much of a problem. They do bear hgeavy loads so the internal stresses can be high, but usually aren't as much a problem because the mopisture content of the tree is lower than other fruits. Nut trees often have varying amounts of internal cracking when the wood is fresh cut.

Citrus trees don't have the sapwood problem because their structure is such that they are essentially 100% sapwood. However they can have large internal stresses from a heavy fruit load, and the high moisture content of the wood can cause sever cracking problems. However, citrus can make beautiful turned pieces if you learn how to handle it and what shapes are best for it.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#14

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Leo Van Der Loo

>Fruit and nut or berry trees do not need to split any more than most other dense wood, other than cross-linked grain wood, like Elm for instance.

The dense hard wood has less give than softer woods and the fairly weak grain-link will react poorly to stresses in the wood caused by differences in the water/sap level because of that.

So why do these woods split, because we don't take enough care in drying them, they don't split because they are wet or dry, but because one area looses moisture faster than the rest, so some will do away with the area and turn very thin, I give it time to dry slow enough so the moisture levels can stay very close to equal in the wood.

I have no more losses in my fruitwood than any other wood, if I do take care of them, and yes they do need better care and will split if that's not done.

And no the gimmicks like soap or alcohol or etc., won't help you, but time and keeping moisture levels surrounding the pieces will, slow down the drying.

Easily said ??

here are some pictures of Apple Mulberry Beech Plum, just to show a few.


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#15

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#16

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#17

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#18

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#19

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#20

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo------WebKitFormBoundaryeZNwOyXUAsY

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#21

Re: fruit wood ?'s 

Leo Van Der Loo------WebKitFormBoundaryeZNwOyXUAsY

>


img

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#22

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>These are all lovely! I don't currently have any fruit wood in my stash. I just wondered why that particular admonition always seem to accompany fruit wood.

Russ' explanation made a lot of sense to me. Leo's pictures make me think it is worth while to try some.

Ooooh! Wait! Barb Sidiqqui gave me some apricot some time ago. I still have it. It's got to be dry now! It's been years!

Now if I only were closer to my shop.... sighhh....

Thanks for all the thoughts, folks. Always good to know you all are around to scratch the knowledge itch from time to time. :-)

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: fruit wood ?'s

keith tompkins

>Hi Russ, Thinking about it, most fruit trees are trained to grow horizontally; they bear more fruit, and the fruit is easier to pick, while moisture problems which lead to disease are lessened. Vertical growth is pruned back. Therefore, lots of reaction wood. It pays to know where on the tree your turning stock comes from.

Re: fruit wood ?'s

#24

Dick Hines

Re: fruit wood ?'s

Dick Hines

>Russ I guess I am not the average wood turner because I will run to every piece of cherry and pecan I can find. I love turning both and will thae the chances that come with turning them.

I am going to a log yard this week if I can find the time just to get a cherry log. I think cherry if worth the effort.