Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Glaser vibration control fixture

Posts

Glaser vibration control fixture

#1

Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9

>I'm interested in building the Glaser vibration reduction contraption that one can find at morewoodturning.net. But it calls for a 18 in length of 3/4 inch heat treated all thread rod that is turned smooth and shot peened for part of its length. Sounds expensive. And where would you get that? And why shot peened? I suppose only a custom job. The claim is that ordinary 3/4 inch all thread will break from all the vibration. Wouldn't there be an easier way? My mustard monster has a 3/4 inch holder that was designed for a guard( I don't know anyone who uses a guard.) But couldn't I get some kind of hard 3/4 rod to go in there. This holder even has a spring loaded little peg that could fit into a hole in the rod to help hold it in place.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#2

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>I use a piece of 3/4 steel rod in that holder to secure support an overhead florescent desk type lamp. I replaced the spring locking pin with a hex bolt and then I drilled a 1/2" hole in the rod to accept the lamps pivot pin. I also drilled and tapped a hole in the end of the rod to lock the lamps pivot pin.

Where is there information on the Glaser vibration control fixture? I went to the Glaser site and didn't see it mentioned.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#3

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Sean Troy

>I'm not trying to be a wise @## or anything, but wouldn't controling your lathe speed be easier and cheaper (free)?

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#4

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Chuck Engstrom

>I built one of these a few years back. I'd have to research the MSC catalogue to find what I used for all-thread but I do seem to remember that they had a hardened variety. I did machine off the threading in the middle, as specified, but didn't get it shot-peened as I have no source for that.

I put it on a Delta 46-715 and it did seem to help a bit, but I sure wouldn't say that it was a cure-all. Every piece of wood is different and every cut you make in it changes its balance, so a cure for out-of-balance problems remains an always-moving target.

I'd be glad to get up a photo is anyone is interested -- I probably took one at some point in the past but can't find it now.

I do have 200 lbs of sand in a purpose-built case in the bed of my 3520, and that does seem to help but again, it's not a cure-all.

Best to all --

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#5

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture *LINK*

Fred Holder

>The article was written by Lyn in 2002 and is placed on my More Woodturning web site. The link is given below.


More Woodturning Website Lyn's Pages

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#6

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Sure, but sometimes things are off balance and too slow a speed just doesn't work. Also Glaser is no fool, and he and others noticed significant vibration reduction. It's supposed to be a superior method than adding weight. (And I don't think you're a wise #$$%^!) I like attention of any kind!

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#7

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I'd like to see your picture, if it's not too much trouble.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#8

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Yes, that's where I found it all right. So you're the trouble maker! Now tell us where to get the hardened, shot peened rod.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#9

Thank you, Fred.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#10

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Sean Troy

>i remember seeing someone adding a large coffee can full of cement hung off that fixture you mentioned for the guard. depending on how out of balance, they would lower or raise the can on a rope and tie off at the right height. The cement can was supposed to dampen vibration.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#11

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Texian

>Since most of the threads are to be removed from the allthread bar in question, one might consider using 5/8" cold rolled steel rod, and threading the ends of same as needed. I am skeptical of the benefits of such a device, compared to the alternatives of using lower speed and/or a substantial weight tray between the lathe legs. But I have been mistaken many times in the past, and could easily be wrong about this too.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#12

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>The physics wouldn't be right to just hang it off the holder. The weight would have to be hung off a rod(supposedly 3/4 x 18 inches) that , in turn, would be held in the holder. Tha would be essentially the Glaser design, It's the vibration of this rod with a heavy weight at one end that helps counter the oscillating vibrational forces. Glaser then specifically specifies that this rod be extremely strong and hard so as not to break because of all the vibration. I would like to try placing a 3/4 x 18 rod in the holder and affixing a 20 lb weight at its end. I would then use the spring loaded pin that's already in the holder , along with a series of holes in the bar, to vary the position of the weight. (It would almost certainly also be necessary to figure some additional way to hold the rod more firmly.) But the problem remans: where do I get a sufficiently strong rod?Does it really have to be shot peened?

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#13

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Sean Troy

>I don't see why you couldn't use some cold rolled steel. Drill and tap the bracket for a knob to loosen or tighten on the rod to move it as needed.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#14

vicmarc balancer *LINK*

john lucas

>I think this is a much better option. Of course you probably can't make this yourself unless you happen to be a machinist.


http://www.vicmarc.com/default.asp?contentID=550

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#15

Re: vicmarc balancer

Fog Tanner

>John,

I have one and use it all the time and your observation is correct. You would have to either be a machinest or at least have an engine lathe and milling machine to make one. That is the advantage of the Glaser system, you only need an engine lathe to machine the chrome molly threaded rod. I wonder what the delta is for getting heat treated chrome molly and having machine vs the Vicmarc system.

It does work well and is quickly adjusted. While my original need was in off center pieces, I use it when roughing out large imbalanced blanks. Which is a strange experience. I start with and irregular piece of wood (in shape and garin density), which I balance. I turn the bowl up higher than I normally could at that stage and then start removing material. As the shape progresses, and it starts coming closer to finished shape I can feel some vibration. That is when I stop and quickly re-zero the counter weights and finish it up. So far using this balancing system, I can rough down larger (12"-22") blanks much quicker than I could before, so it is paying for itself in time saved. The same is true for my offcenter work.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#16

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

davidwalser

>Sean,

The bar acts as a spring and needs to be made of "spring steel". Cold rolled steel will not withstand the stress of near-constant vibration; it will break. Chrome molly, treated as specified, will withstand the vibration.

Down thread someone else suggests using a thicker rod of cold rolled steel. Thicker would better enable the rod to withstand the stress; it would also be stiffer and therefore might do little dampen the vibrations of the lathe. Glaser's device acts like a lighting rod. A lighting rod provides an easier path to the ground for a lighting bolt's energy. It takes energy to make a lathe vibrate. Jerry's vibration damper provides an easier, quicker, path for vibration energy to follow. The damper vibrates more easily than the lathe and any energy used up in making the damper vibrate cannot be used to make the lathe vibrate. For that to work, the rod has to be fairly thin (so it will vibrate easily). Jerry's an engineer, so I assume he did the calculations to get the right thickness and length of bar.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#17

Thanks, very interesting

john lucas

>

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#18

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi folks -- sorry for the delay in getting up a photo of my Glaser vibration control device.

The photo is meant only to show what it looks like and not to indicate how it should be used. Here it is at an angle to the bed, since the lathe is too close to the wall behind it for me to mount it perpendicular to the bed right near the headstock as it should be.

It's also a bit rusty and dusty here, as I haven't messed with it for several years. It was a fun experiment but I didn't find it to be a panacea for vibration, especially for out-of-balance pieces. Its greatest drawback is that there is no way to figure out how to get the most out of it except to fool around with location on the bed, weight amount and height, etc -- you may get lucky or you may make things worse. I suspect that if you actually get it waving around pretty good to dampen vibration you are at the same time shortening its life with the stresses of waving around.

I did read the article, somewhere, from which this thing derived, and last summer I got my library to bring in (via inter-library loan) a small but expensive book ($95 on Amazon) about rotational balancing. It covered the basics nicely but in the end was no real help for turning, in which the out-of-balance equations would change instantaneously as you cut.

I have had some success balancing fairly small stuff with a disc full of holes set in behind the chuck and inserting bolts and nuts for weight in the holes till I get some results. But this can't come near helping with a big lump that's several -- or more -- pounds out of balance.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom


img

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#19

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>It would seem that out-of-balance equations would apply to the Vicmark system -- not so much to the Glaser vibration reduction system. But I take your word that the Glaser system comes out of such equations. I certainly see your point that in either case the equations change as you turn. Apparently the turner must begin to feel some changes and then make adjustments. So either system really is a man/ machine interface sort of thing.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#20

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Eliot -- I don't think I'd say that the Glaser rig comes out of the equations in the rotational balancing book -- I just don't know that much about this -- and I apologize if I created some confusion on that. My understanding from the book was that rotational balance problems are solved by adding/removing weight in appropriate places around the rotating object, in mathematically predictable ways -- tire weights are the most common example.

I suspect it's more accurate to say that the Glaser just "burns off" some of the jiggle energy put into the lathe by the rotation of an out-of-balance piece. The book's equations may be able to predict the amount of energy being diverted by the out-of-balance condition and going off into unwanted vibration, but then you'd have to get into some other equations to figure out how to structure the Glaser's arm length, weight, etc.

Any real engineers out there?

Best--

Chuck

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#21

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Your absolutely right. And you put your finger on the really difficult aspect of all this when you reminded us that all the parameters in the equations change as you turn. So the results of whatever calculations you may have made to set the initial lengths, weights, etc. would have to change as you turn. To do it right would require some sort of complex feed back system to continually adjust for the effects of removing part of the out-of-balance as you turn. Hugely complicated! This is the sort of thing an organization like NASA would do at great expense.

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

#22

Re: Glaser vibration control fixture

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Where's Art Leistman when you need him?