Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

power sanding relative speed

Posts

power sanding relative speed

#1

power sanding relative speed

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9

>I know some turners like to sand slow and some fast, but what about the relative speed of the power sanding tool vs the speed of the turning? I have this idea that there is a kind of optimum relative speed, but I don't know what it is. Any thoughts?

Re: power sanding relative speed

#2

Re: power sanding relative speed

john lucas

>My thought, and it could be wrong. I think the sanding speed should be higher than the speed of the bowl but that's just what works for me.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#3

Re: power sanding relative speed

Texian

>Most data seen lately suggest that low speed lathe rotation, relatively low speed sanding disc rotation, and a light touch yield best results and best sanding disc life. Obviously there must be some differential surface contact speed/direction. Sometimes useful to run the lathe or the sander in reverse.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#4

Re: power sanding relative speed : (

GalenV

>Now you did it!

Made me think.

If I have my 2" sanding disc turning at 1500 rpm in my VS drill and touch the outside edge to the out outside edge of a 6" platter turning at 500 rpm, at point contact the relative velocity is 0 if they are both running the same direction, but about 1570 feet per minute if one is running in the opposite direction. I guess it is a good thing I have more surface contact or I would never get anything done one way and sand too much away the other.

Now I will worry about this every time I start to sand. :(

Must be time to retire for the night.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#5

Re: power sanding relative speed

Michael Stafford

>I also slow down the object I am turning and power sand at a higher speed. You can also somewhat control the aggressiveness of the action by changing direction of the drill while sanding. I find that having the sanding pad running clockwise while the lathe is running counter clockwise is slightly more aggressive. And the reverse is less aggressive.

In any event keep the pad moving and don't apply much pressure as that does not necessarily remove wood faster but it does create heat. And we all know it is better to minimize heat.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#6

Re: power sanding relative speed

Jim Rutten

>I went to see Bruce Hoover, inventor of the sanding glove, at SWAT this weekend. He suggested that the total RPM of the lathe plus the total RPM of the sander should be about 1000 RPM. So if your sander is running at 500 RPM the lathe should be 500 RPM also.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#7

Re: power sanding relative speed : (

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9

>I'm glad you did the math. I even checked it, and you're absolutely right. For your example,in opposite directions the relative speed is indeed 1750 ft/min. But you say this is too high. It may be. My question is .. what should it be? I, like Bill Neddow (spelling?), sand with a modified VS grinder at tremendously high relative speeds and have never experiences any problems so long as I keep a very light touch. But I know the conventional wisdom is keep things slow. What I'm actually wondering about is whether or not there have ever been any scientific studies. Everything here is really anecdotal.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#8

Re: power sanding relative speed

robo hippy

>Vince has a nice tutorial on his web site. www.VincesWoodNWonders.com

I am a big fan of slower sanding speeds. I let my bowls warp, so the lathe has to run in the 10 to 50 rpm range, can't keep my hands or drill on the wood above those speeds. I have the Sioux/Milwaukee angle drills, the favorites being the slow speed models, and run them with a piece of 1/4 inch cork under the trigger. This keeps the disc speed at about half, so in the 500 plus range. I was dubious at first because I thought it would take more time to sand, but it doesn't, and in face seems to be a bit faster. I also found one other benefit, by sanding at slower speeds, the bearings last longer. Typically, I would get 300 to 350 bowls sanded before the bearings were shot. The last one with running at slower speeds, I got about 450 bowls. I am trying another one to see if I get the same results.

robo hippy

Re: power sanding relative speed

#9

Re: power sanding relative speed

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>I think that Reed (robohippy) has come up with an excellent solution to his sanding needs. If the bowl is out of round, you cannot sand at high speed (or if you do, you will only be sanding the high spots).

However, as with most things in life, one size does not fit all. I sand at high speed. My bowls are round (twice turned and dried for over a year between turnings). I sand with a modified angle grinder, modified to run at 6000 rpm, with the lathe running at about 500 rpm. I use ceramic sandpapers or sanding disks from the auto industry, meant to grind paint and metal.

The slower the speed, the cheaper the sandpaper you can use. Some people find this attractive. But I have found from bitter experience that it is probably the most expensive way to sand in the long run. The better sandpapers last much longer and, in the end are cheaper than cheap sandpapers. Also, by sanding at high speed, I dramatically reduce the time required to finish a bowl. As these bowls almost all go to galleries, the finish must feel like silk. No scratch marks allowed.

Strange, how something a simple as sanding can become so complex.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#10

Re: power sanding relative speed

John K Jordan

>eliot d,

I do most of my bowl sanding with the lathe turned off, rotating the piece by hand. This lets me address problem areas and I think it reduces the overall sanding needed.

When sanding with the piece turning, I set the speed very slow. If the piece is turning quickly, many of the scratches will be concentric or close to concentric - more similar to what you get by simply holding sandpaper against the work. If the lathe is turning slowly and the power sander somewhat faster (surface speed close to the same), the scratches are diagonal. Reverse the direction of either and the diagonals will change direction which I think is good for the process.

Also, power sanding too fast can create too much heat which can cause checks and melt the hooks on velcro pads.

JKJ

Re: power sanding relative speed

#11

Re: Scientific study

GalenV

>Being new to turning I am finding out that finishing is another art form with no clear scientific answer. I am in hopes that you can learn from other turners. I think you learn bits but must have to apply what works for yourself. I have not found that yet!!!

There seems to be so many variables: type of wood, particular piece of wood you used, the shape you formed, the quality of the surface cut you made, the quality and type of abrasive, the speed or motion of sanding, the pressure that you apply, your ability to see and feel the finished surface as you go through the grits, and others I probalby have not even begun to know.

Pieces that I have seen that are glassy smooth, that truner has been able to fine that magical answer for his work.

I enjoy learning what works for others.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#12

Re: power sanding relative speed

Russ Fairfield

>I have always been told that the maximum speed for sanding wood was 2400 feet per minute, and that most hardwood spieces would have to be sanded slower than this. This is based on sanding efficiency, dust control, controlling heat, reasonable feed rates across the sanding medium, etc. Relating this to a 3" sanding disc in a 2400 RPM drill, the disc has a velocity of just over 1900 FPM at its outer edge, so that gives me a starting point. I can easilly exceed 2400 FPM when both the wood and disc are spinning.

I know that others sand at these speeds, and some go much faster; but I have never been able to do it without having all kinds of problems from the heat - casehardened wood, sanding bruises on the wood, wood oils, clogged sandpaper that was beyond cleaning, and melting sanding discs. Someone once told me I just needed to buy better sanding discs.

I had never given much thought to what I was doing with sanding discs until I had to explain it on my finishing videos. I had to look carefully at what I was doing, so I could explain it to someone else.

My take on the topic is that the direction of the sanding scratches that are the result of the two spinning surfaces is more important than the magnitude of their speed.

We can control the direction of the sanding scratches on the wood by moving the contact area around the peripferary of the spinning sanding disc. The contact is the softest when both surfaces are running in the same direction at the point of contact, and there is no sanding when they are moving at the same speed.

Sanding is most aggressive when they are running in opposite directions. This duplicates the sanding action of hand-held sandpaper, and leaves the same circular scratches around the piece of wood. The only difference is that the combination of the 2 opposing velocities makes the scratches happen faster.

I always find that the sanding is best when the velocities of the wood and the sanding disc at the point of contact are the same and at right angles to each other. The resulting sanding scratch pattern is then at 45-degrees to the direction the wood is moving, and which 45 diagonal is determined by whether the top or the bottom of the sanding disc is in contact with the moving wood. Crossing these scratche patterns makes for faster sanding, and it breaks up the scratch patterns to make it less visible. This much the same effect as stopping a spinning turning and sanding with the grain to remove the circular scratches from sanding while it was spinning.

This ability to control the direction of the scratch pattern depends on the wood and the disc having the same velocity at the point of contact. I can tell when they are equal by the direction the sanding dust is being thrown from the sanding disc. The magnitude of the speed is determined by several factors - the species and hardness of the wood, how fast I am willing to spin the wood in ther lathe, the most efficient removal of wood from the surface, and all the while not letting either the wood or the sanding disc get hot.

I can achieve this same crossing of the scratch patterns when the wood is stopped by changing the orientation of the sanding disc. Since only the sanding disc is spinning, I can spin it faster - maybe even as faster than 1200 RPM.

All of this has kept me generally within the speed capabilities of a variable speed sanding disc with a 1200 RPM maximum speed. Sanding discs and their adhesives have improved to allow me to run everything faster, however I still stay under the 1200 RPM because of one factor - dust.

Controlling sanding dust hasn't been mentioned as a factor. The faster everything is spinning, the finer the dust particles, the more the dust is blown around, and the stronger and more efficient the dust collector has to be. Faster sanding speeds also generates smaller sized dust particles. Slow sanding makes larger dust particles that are more in keeping with the size of the abrasive grit, keeps the dust within the confines of the sanding area, and easier to pick up. Most of it falls down on the lathe bed.

Feel free to disagree. After all, it's the results that count.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#13

Re: power sanding relative speed

Vince Welch

>What Sanding speed should I sand is a question I hear often. My thought is there are many variables and not one quick number that stands true for all situations. Because there are variables that need to be considered and I do not believe that one magical number (1000 for example) would be the end all solution to sanding speed questions. One item I might add to be considered is that as you progress through grits you may want to slow your speed down whether via lathe or sanding device in your hand. Think about it... 80 grit abrasive is going to cut obviously more aggressively then say 320 or 400. At 320 or 400 you have a much finer grit and your speed needs to much slower. You are not looking for a nice shine from the piece as you sand it. I nice shine while sanding often is the result of burnishing your piece while sanding and this is due to sanding again with too much speed. People sometimes get confused, do not understand, or simply not aware of the difference and that is o.k. One answer fits all is not o.k. in my opinion and I caution you to be careful out there Will Robinson..... Vince

Re: power sanding relative speed

#14

Re: power sanding relative speed

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Bill, you're my sanding hero! Ever since I fixed up my angle grinder to accept a three inch velcro sanding disk from HF( 5/8 x 11 thread , I think) , I have been sanding at very high speeds and get superb results. I mostly use Astrodot sandpaper form Woodchuckers in Canada. I just don't have any of the expected problems with high speed sanding. Perhaps the bearings will wear out, but the angle grinder is designed to run fast. The surface I get is really super. Some of the people I mentor ask me what finish to use to get such fine finishes; I tell them that if you sand the way I do up to 2000 grit, that just about any goop will give a wonderful finish.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#15

Re: power sanding relative speed

Russ Fairfield

>Every woodturner has already made up their minds on what combination of fast and slow they want to use. There aren't that many choices - fast and slow spinning wood, and fast and slow spinning sanding discs. How fast is fast and how slow is slow are open for interpretation.

There is nothing I can say to change anyone's mind, and there is nothing they can say to change mine. We do what we do because it works; and we wonder why the beginners get confused.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#16

Re: power sanding relative speed

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Everything you have said here is great advice, Russ. What I have done is pushed the envelope, and I have been able to get excellent results. This is because I am using sandpapers not really designed for wood. The 3M Roloc and the Power Lock system from Craft Supplies USA need the speed to fracture the grit and keep the disc sharp. The discs were originally designed for the metal trades, for sanding steel and paint. Thus, they are tough, tough, though -- and last a long time. Adapting equipment is nothing new for wood turners. All the steels we use in oiur tools were originally designed for other uses.

If you use a velcro system, I find the Tim Skilton pads stand up for ever, even at high speed. I use the Astro Dot, already mentioned, or the ceramic sandpapers from 3M or Norton. I prefer the Astro Dot and the Norton papers as they have velcro backings. The 3M is just as good, but has a PSA (sticky) backing. The adaptor pads are not designed for high speed. If you are going to use this paper, get a pad with a PSA backing.

If heat is a problem in any sanding system, you are putting too much pressure on the pad. If you are getting burnishing, throw away the paper and put on a new piece -- or better still, and get one of the papers I have mentioned. There is no excuse for burnishing.

One last note, on sanding dust. I think that if you are going to sand a bowl up to 2000 grit you are going to produce the same amount of dust no matter what technique you use. High speed sanding looks bad because the dust is produced over a short period of time. Sanding at low speed produces the same amount of dust, but over a longer period. Foir heaven's sake, protect yourself from the dust no matter what system you use!

Re: power sanding relative speed

#17

Re: How do I see those last scratches?

GalenV

>The small cherry bowls and hollow forms I have made so far I tried to follow down through good sanding from power to hand and have stopped at 400 but gone to 600 or 800 on some even when I do not see scratches. Put wipe on high gloss poly on some and HELLO scratches!

How do you see this before putting on finish? Some I did a final hand sand with the grain and they still show circular pattern.

I have wipped them down, moved my lighting, and crossed my fingers.

Do I need to go beyond the grits I used? Seems I miss in going through grits?

Any key to what I need to do?

Thanks

Galen

Re: power sanding relative speed

#18

Re: How do I see those last scratches?

John K Jordan

>Galan,

You can wipe the wood with some liquid that dries quickly and will not raise the grain or leave a residue or affect the subsequent finish, for example, naphtha. This tends to show scratches better.

If you are seeing scratches after sanding to 600 I suspect they are from a much earlier grit. One thing I sometimes do - as a final step with the coarser grits I will hand sand a bit across the grain or figure in a spot or two. This leaves scratches that are much easier to see and easier to see when they are gone with the next grit which is a hint of just enough sanding at that stage. I'm certainly no expert, but this works for me.

Another thing - don't use a broad, diffuse light source such as a long fluorescent bulb. A small, "point source" such as a small halogen bulb or even a hand-held bright flashlight held at a glancing angle will show up scratches.

JKJ

Re: power sanding relative speed

#19

Thanks John

GalenV

>Thanks for your reply.

May try the naptha as it would flash off faster and maybe the ordorless mineral spirits I use wets the surface too much to see.

I do have difficulty when to know I sanded enough with one grit to go to next. I guess I do recall the procedure to sand a spot cross grain and sand it till gone. I switch from power sanding at 320 as 400 and finer in sheets only. These scratches are fine and was not sure if not getting last grit sanded out or creating with next finer.

The better finished were the shallow hollow form bowls and sounds like maybe the light was better as I got out a small portable halogen to focus on inside and then used to light during finish sand. Others were under flourescent and the incandesant on the Jet 1220.

Thanks and I will keep trying.

The FEW times I get a real good finish cut I end up using too course of grit to start sanding and feel I lost the battle! :(

Re: power sanding relative speed

#20

choosing grit size

john lucas

>A lot of people start with too low a grit. That's not necessarily a bad thing but can cause problems. I know a lot of turner always start with 80 grit. Starting with the lower more aggresive grits can cause lumps from areas of wood that are harder than the rest of the wood. Actually this can also be caused with finer grits where it's necessary to sand a lot with that grit to get rid of tearout or other defects. The trick is to use the lowest grit that solves the problem fairly quickly.

One way to learn this is to actually start with a slightly higher grit. If you feel you got a good finish off the tool try 120 or 150. Don't waste a lot of time. If you feel your having to sand too long back down to 80 or 100. Sometimes you may feel like you did a really good tool job. In this case pick up 180 or 220 and hit it. After you do this a few times you will find that you may actually be able to start with 120 or 150 all the time.

Don't ever be afraid to lower the grade when necessary. It saves time and may cause less problems.

Re: power sanding relative speed

#21

Thanks John L. too!

GalenV

>