Re: Which hollowing tool?
Joe Flemig
>Big question; lots of answers.
Just so you know, I'm a hollow tool junkie and have many tools and have experimented with dozens more. My recommendations are based upon my own experiences.
First of all, try out the systems before you buy. Borrow them from friends. Even the small systems can run you to $100. Larger systems several hundred.
Think about what you want to try. Hollow forms run from tiny ornaments, to very large vessels. They range from tall and thin to short and wide. Each can be accomplished successfully with different tools, but there is not one tool that will to them all.
For small vessels up to about 2-3": Packards mini hollowers and Keltons mini hollowers are good. I do not like the Chris Stott tools or the Don Derry little tool. The former vibrate too much and the latter is hard to use. I don't like its handle.
For vessels from 3-5": Keltons small hollowers, Jordan's 1/2" hollowing system. I do not like the Stinger from Pencil too much and my homemade "Ellsworth" type tool.
As a generalization, I don't like any Sorby bent tool because the swan neck is not the correct shape for hollowing. This includes their 3/8" tools, their 1/2" tools and their larger 3/4" tools. If you look at the curve on the Sorby, you will see that the arc is part of a circle. It is symmetrical. If you look at any of the Keltons, the Bosch's and the Jordan's, you will see that the curves are asymmetrical. They are broad on the shaft side and tighter on the cutter end. This shape gets into and out of closed vessels much more effectively.
For vessels from 4" to 10": Don Derry's captive system, Bosch, or Kelton 5/8". I'm experimenting with Mike Jackofsky's new tools for this size too, but its too early to recommend.
For vessels from 8" to around 12": Jordan, Bosch, Kelton 3/4" in a captured system such as Jamieson system. Pencil, Sorby or Stewart armbraces are great. The Exocet bent tool is not very good for these.
For really big vessels, use a captured system with a big thick bar.
For tall, thin vessels like 10" to 15" vases, I like the Exocet straight hollowing tool. Any of the 3/4" tools will work here too.
Joe Fleming - San Diego