Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Which hollowing tool?

Posts

Which hollowing tool?

#1

Which hollowing tool?

clay rose

>Hey everyone, What kind of hollowing tools should i use. Ive never attempted turning hollow forms before. What kind of tools are people using for both face and end grain hollowings, and of of various size? any do's, and dont's, words of advice, tool recomendations?? thanks

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#2

Re: Which hollowing tool? *LINK*

Randy G

>From what I've seen and heard, they all will work, and work well. Deciding what kind of aides you want in assisting you to hollow, then learning to use that system well.

I was able to take a class from Trent Bosch and learned to use his hollowing tools. As such I like them very well. It doesn't have the laser guides or other guides some have, but I like the feel and use of them.


Trent Bosch

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#3

Re: Which hollowing tool?

davidwalser

>Ray,

As with much in life, the answer is that it depends. In this case, it depends on what you want to turn and how willing (and able) you are to withstand the stresses associated with hollowing free hand. Here are some ideas to get you started:

For small turnings, like Christmas ornaments, you can do very well with very simple hand-held tools. Bob Rosand, who is well known for his Christmas ornaments and similar small turnings, uses (and sells) a simple hollowing tool. Only $20!

For larger turnings, you might want to consider some sort of "captured system" for hollowing. There are two types: An "articulated arm" and a "frame system" (I just made up that term). Captured systems are attached to the lathe and direct to the lathe the severe amounts of torque that might be generated by hollowing -- particularly if you take a bigger cut than you'd intended.

The articulated arm systems, such as Elbo Tool, are very easy to set up and use. They tend to take up more room than does the other type of captured systems. This tends to limit the depth of the hollow form you might be able to turn. Here's a link to the Elbo Tool's website. There you can see a video of the tool in action. Elbo Tool Another option: Monster Tool

Frame sytems (or what everyone else calls captured systems) use a frame to capture the hollowing tool. The frame mounts behind your regular tool rest. You slide the hollowing tool on both the frame and the tool rest, keeping the tool level. The frame prevents the tool from twisting in response to the forces generated by the hollowing process. By using thicker and longer hollowing tools, you can hollow just about any depth object that'll fit on your lathe. Here's a link to CSUSA's hollowing tools: CSUSA Another alternative is found on the Monster Tool website, linked to above.

Hope this helps

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#4

Related question: sizes?

wilbur

>I've been thinking about a first hollowing tool, myself. Where I get confused is trying to figure out what size object can be made with a given size hollowing tool.

For example, the John Jordan hollowing tools come in 1/2" and 3/4" diameters, and the 3/4" diameter hook tool comes in 16" and 20" lengths. The Munro hollowing tool comes in regular and mini sizes. The Ellsworth tools come in regular and small sizes. And the Hunter tools seem to be spawning more sizes every day. :@)

But I haven't been able to figure out how big of an object these tools should be able to hollow out. Are there any rules of thumb to follow, like the rule about if the tip of the gouge is x inches beyond the tool rest, your handle should be y inches long?

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#5

Re: Which hollowing tool?

Norm Smith

>Clay,

I have two captured systems, an Elbo tool and The Don Pencil system. If you are just starting out , I would recommend the Don Pencil system. With this system you get a real feel of whats going on inside the form, what are the proper angles, cutter sizes, etc. You will learn a lot which will be a good base for other larger systems. I use this system much more than others and prefer it for forms up to 8 inches.

Don advertises on this site.

Good luck,

Norm

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Which hollowing tool?

Dick Hines

>First you need to hollow free hand. After you get the hang of that then you can move on to a captured tool rig. I use both methods. For small things I free hand them. Fot larger pieces I set up my Jamieson rig.

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Everything I know about hollowing

steve antonucci

>For starters, no system is perfect or will handle every situation.

I hollow with my own tools, and I have made every one of them. On average, they cost less than $5 to make, and I probably have 20 or more now for different applications.

In general, the further over the tool rest you get , the longer the handle needs to be. I usually double the handle vs. the tool shank length. You can expect more vibration the longer over the rest you are and the thinner your shank is. To counter act the vibration, use a smaller cutter. I have used a light touch with a 14" overhand on a 1/2" shank with no ill effect.

I typically make the Ellsworth style hollowers. The straight cutter is effortless is you are cutting on centerline. The angled cutter is almost as effortless and can be used to undercut almost every shape with few exceptions. If you decide to get into smaller opening vessels, it's good to be able to make your own tools, because most of the systems are too big to get into really small holes.

All you need to make a tools is a length of steel, a cutter, and a drill. You simply drill hole in the end of the rod at any angle, doing your best to keep it level and consistent, then epoxy/CA glue the cutter in place. The rod can be purchased from the local hardware store, cutters from Enco. I usually cut the bits in 1/3rds or so, and turn a handle out of wood.

There are no rules for how long or short, thick or thin you need. You need them all. For really small forms, I love using allen keys. For small forms, I use O1 steel and temper the ends up to 1/4" thick. My entire collection is probably about $50 for stock and 20 minutes or less per tool.

Steve


img

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#8

Re: Which hollowing tool?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I like the Kelton line of hollowing tools. I also have Don Pencil's Scorpion system. I have two of the Sorby swan neck hollowers, but I don't care much for them.

I am not yet at a point where I want to use a captured system so I'm doing all mine by hand.

keithz

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#9

jim miles

Re: Everything I know about hollowing

Jim Miles

>I tend to agree with Steve. Start with something simple and get a little experience with things not to wide or deep. I like the ring tool ( termite, or hook ) the are simple, inexpensive and arent't too hard to learn to use. After you do some then you will better know what you want if you decide to graduate to a more complicated system.

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#10

Re: Which hollowing tool?

Joe Flemig

>Big question; lots of answers.

Just so you know, I'm a hollow tool junkie and have many tools and have experimented with dozens more. My recommendations are based upon my own experiences.

First of all, try out the systems before you buy. Borrow them from friends. Even the small systems can run you to $100. Larger systems several hundred.

Think about what you want to try. Hollow forms run from tiny ornaments, to very large vessels. They range from tall and thin to short and wide. Each can be accomplished successfully with different tools, but there is not one tool that will to them all.

For small vessels up to about 2-3": Packards mini hollowers and Keltons mini hollowers are good. I do not like the Chris Stott tools or the Don Derry little tool. The former vibrate too much and the latter is hard to use. I don't like its handle.

For vessels from 3-5": Keltons small hollowers, Jordan's 1/2" hollowing system. I do not like the Stinger from Pencil too much and my homemade "Ellsworth" type tool.

As a generalization, I don't like any Sorby bent tool because the swan neck is not the correct shape for hollowing. This includes their 3/8" tools, their 1/2" tools and their larger 3/4" tools. If you look at the curve on the Sorby, you will see that the arc is part of a circle. It is symmetrical. If you look at any of the Keltons, the Bosch's and the Jordan's, you will see that the curves are asymmetrical. They are broad on the shaft side and tighter on the cutter end. This shape gets into and out of closed vessels much more effectively.

For vessels from 4" to 10": Don Derry's captive system, Bosch, or Kelton 5/8". I'm experimenting with Mike Jackofsky's new tools for this size too, but its too early to recommend.

For vessels from 8" to around 12": Jordan, Bosch, Kelton 3/4" in a captured system such as Jamieson system. Pencil, Sorby or Stewart armbraces are great. The Exocet bent tool is not very good for these.

For really big vessels, use a captured system with a big thick bar.

For tall, thin vessels like 10" to 15" vases, I like the Exocet straight hollowing tool. Any of the 3/4" tools will work here too.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: Which hollowing tool?

#11

Re: Which hollowing tool? *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Hello Clay,

As has been said, there are a great many hollowing tools on the market and virtually all of them work for some applications. In 2004, Lyn Mangiameli wrote a five part series of articles for More Woodturning. That series and many of Lyn's other articles are at my web site. Lyn did post regularly to rec.crafts.woodturning and this message board, until he became very ill and could no longer turn wood and write articles.

There are some new hollowing tools on the market that did not exist when Lyn wrote his series of articles on hollowing tools. These tools use carbide cutters. The first that I came in contact with was the Hunter tool in February 2006 when we went to the first Desert Woodturning Roundup in Arizonia. Mike Hunter was there and I purchased one of his tools for my wife to use in hollowing endgrain. I tried the tool and called Mike for more information and then did a review on his tools. Mike has also come out with cutters to use with the Jamieson Stabilized Boring Bar system and other similar systems. These work very well, I purchased one from Craft Supplies at the Utah Woodturning Symposium this last spring.

Some time later, Jack McDaniel in the Seattle area, came out with a tool called The Eliminator, which uses the same carbide cutter as Mike Hunter. Jack's Eliminator tools have larger shafts with flats milled on the shaft to make it easy to position the cutter.

When we were in Australia in September 2006, I was introduced to the Vermec hollowing rig which is a stabilized boring bar that pops into the tool post hole in the banjo and uses the same carbide cutters for hollowing. I had to add one of these to my extensive list of hollowing tools and like it very much. It is designed to cut on the right side of the vessel with the lathe turning in its normal forward rotation direction.

I highly recommend that you take a look at Lyn's series of articles at the below link.


More Woodturning Website Lyn's Pages